Collaborative Contact in Tourism: A Randomized Field Experiment in Beach Volleyball

How to cite

Araña, Jorge. 2026. "Collaborative Contact in Tourism: A Randomized Field Experiment in Beach Volleyball." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018354. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18354-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jorge Araña*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018354
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18354-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-01 – 2027-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, J15, Z32
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18354

Abstract

Can structured collaborative contact between tourists and local residents reduce intergroup prejudice? We conduct a randomized field experiment in Gran Canaria, Spain, where growing tourismphobia has intensified resident-tourist tensions. 800 participants (tourists and Canarian residents) are randomly assigned to 2v2 beach volleyball teams that are either mixed (one tourist, one resident) or homogeneous (same group), cross-randomized with team pay versus individual pay.
Tournaments are organized under a formal agreement with the Federación Canaria de Voleibol across four beach locations. Each tournament runs approximately 3.5 weeks with eight matches per team. The primary outcome is an omnibus cross-group behavior index comprising six incentivized behavioral tasks and one attitudinal measure: social interaction choices, team formation decisions, cross-group trading, and trust game behavior. The design replicates Lowe (2021, American Economic Review), who found that collaborative contact through cricket leagues reduced caste prejudice in India by 0.23 standard deviations. We test three hypotheses: (H1) mixed-team assignment increases cross-group prosocial behavior; (H2) effects generalize beyond direct teammates to the outgroup as a whole; and (H3) adversarial contact through competition against outgroup opponents produces null or negative effects. This is the first randomized field experiment testing the contact hypothesis in a tourism setting.

Intervention

Participants are randomly assigned to 2v2 beach volleyball teams for a recreational tournament lasting approximately 3.5 weeks
(~8 matches). The primary treatment is team composition: mixed teams (one tourist paired with one local resident) versus homogeneous teams (two tourists or two residents). A secondary treatment cross-randomizes the incentive structure: team pay (prize money shared equally between teammates) versus individual pay (prize money awarded individually based on performance).
Tournaments are organized under a formal agreement (Convenio de Investigación) with the Federación Canaria de Voleibol, with professional referees, official equipment, and club infrastructure at four beach locations across Gran Canaria.

Experimental design

2×2 factorial randomized field experiment. 800 participants (tourists and local residents in Gran Canaria, Spain) are randomly assigned to 2v2 beach volleyball teams that are either mixed (one tourist + one resident) or homogeneous (same group). Cross-randomized with team pay (shared prizes) vs. individual pay. Tournaments organized under a Convenio de Investigación with the Federación Canaria de Voleibol.
Eight tournaments across four beach locations, two waves. Each tournament runs 3-3.5 weeks (~8 matches per team). All outcomes measured post-tournament using incentivized behavioral tasks with real monetary stakes.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-generated randomization stratified at the individual level by gender and volleyball ability (above/below median within each group). Randomization performed in office using statistical software (Stata/R) after baseline assessment. Match schedule randomized using the Bollobás random pairing algorithm (see Lowe, 2021, for implementation details).
Randomization unit
Individual (for team assignment). Team (for incentive structure — team pay vs. individual pay). Match schedule randomized at the tournament level.
Clusters
Approximately 200 teams (2 players per team) across 8 tournaments
Observations
800 participants (approximately 400 tourists and 400 local residents). Scaling option: 1,200 participants across 12 tournaments if funding permits.
Arms
Approximately 182 teams mixed composition (364 players), 98 teams homogeneous composition (196 players), 240 low-priority backup players. Within each composition type, approximately half assigned to team pay and half to individual pay.
Primary outcomes
Primary: Omnibus cross-group behavior index (mean of seven standardized components: six incentivized behavioral tasks and one attitudinal measure). Components: (1) number of outgroup want-to-interact nominations, (2) number of outgroup friendships, (3) outgroup chosen for team with stakes, (4) outgroup chosen for team without stakes, (5) cross-group trade (binary), (6) trust game amount sent to outgroup partner, (7) stated generalized trust toward outgroup. Secondary: Each component analyzed individually. Voting measure (allocating votes to outgroup candidates in a hypothetical committee election).
Secondary outcomes
Each of the seven omnibus index components analyzed individually. Additionally: votes allocated to outgroup candidates in a hypothetical committee election task (measure of revealed preference for outgroup representation).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords