We evaluate to what extent an edutainment intervention delivered through a mobile cinema in pastoral communities from seven ethnic groups in northern Kenya mitigates inter-group livestock raiding and theft. We conduct a cluster-randomized control trial of a 14-minute animated film promoting skills-based jobs for young men as complementary livelihood to herding, promoting grazing and restitution agreements, and highlighting the consequences of raiding and theft for women. The film is followed by a structured and standardized post-screening discussion. 130 communities were randomly assigned to receive the edutainment intervention and 116 were not. We study effects on the likelihood of raiding and theft and animal losses and loss of human life due to raiding and theft as primary outcomes. Further outcomes are the share of pastoral men in alternative jobs, the likelihood of active grazing and restitution agreements, and first and second order beliefs about raiding and theft, alternative income sources to herding, grazing and restitution agreements, and costs of raiding and theft.
Intervention
The intervention consists of the public screening, through a mobile cinema set-up, of a 14-minute animation video followed by a 1 hour structured and standardized discussion. The video depicts events leading up to a violent pastoral raid, its consequences for all members of the community including women, and alternative solutions to raiding for sustainable income provision: skills-based jobs during rainy seasons when opportunity costs of conflict are lowest, and grazing- and herding agreements between communities to preserve pasture and reduce the profitability of raiding. The post-video discussion facilitated by the International Livestock Research Institute and peace-building NGO International Alert uses a fixed set of questions that are addressed to the community, which the community then discusses among themselves.
Experimental design
We conduct a cluster-randomized control trial (RCT) in 246 sublocations in Isiolo, Marsabit, Samburu, Turkana, Tana River, and Wajir counties in Kenya. It has two arms: Treatment (T1), where the video is screened through a public mobile cinema screening and discussed in a structured and standardized post-video discussion; and Control (T0), where no intervention is received.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization by computer.
Randomization unit
Given that there is significant variation in conflict across sublocations, we created clusters of subcounties for comparison based on geographical closeness and similar conflict experiences in prior panel surveys. In this first step, through computer randomization, these subcounty clusters were randomly assigned to the high or low intensity treatment. In the high intensity treatment, 70% of sublocations were treated and 30% of sublocations functioned as control. The low intensity treatment has 30% of sublocations treated and 70% as control.
After randomizing the subcounty clusters into high and low treatment intensities, we allocated the sublocations within the subcounty clusters into treatment and control through computer randomization. This is stratified by an insurance encouragement intervention, which is an exogenous determinant of insurance. Hence, for high intensity subcounty clusters, 70% of the standard sublocations and 70% of the sublocations with the insurance encouragement intervention are randomized into treatment for edutainment, and the rest to control. For low intensity treatment subcounty clusters, 30% of sublocation without the insurance encouragement and 30% of sublocations with insurance encouragement are randomized into treatment, and the rest to control. The exception here are the 20 added sublocations, as these were not a part of the insurance encouragement study. Hence, these were not stratified but followed the other randomization steps. We have checked whether household and sublocation characteristics were balanced by treatment assignment based on the following characteristics: At the household level, whether the household as experienced conflict in the last year (binary), household head has attended school (binary), herding as a primary livelihood strategy (binary), petty trading as a primary livelihood strategy (binary), casual labor as a primary livelihood strategy (binary), wage employment as a primary livelihood strategy (binary), owning camels (binary), owning cattle (binary), owning goats (binary), owning sheep (binary), number of camels, cattle, goats and sheep. At the sublocation level: conflict experienced in the last year (binary), raids experienced in the last year (binary), grazing agreements (binary), restitution agreements (binary), women groups (binary), number of households with as a primary, secondary and third livelihood strategy herding, livestock production, shop or business, petty trading and farming.
1. Likelihood of livestock raids
2. Animal losses, human injury and loss of human life due to raids
Secondary outcomes
1. Likelihood of livestock theft
2. Animal losses (in TLU), human injury and loss of human life due to theft
3. Share of young men engaging in alternative livelihood strategies out of total young men
4. Number of grazing- and restitution-agreements
5. First and second order beliefs about the costs of raiding and theft
6. First and second order beliefs about alternative sources of income to herding
7. First and second order beliefs towards grazing- and restitution agreements
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.