Are School- and Home-Based Social-Emotional Learning Interventions Complements or Substitutes? Experimental Evidence from Rural China
How to cite
Shi, Yaojiang; Chang, Fang; Liu, Han; Tang, Bin; Xia, Yiming. 2026. "Are School- and Home-Based Social-Emotional Learning Interventions Complements or Substitutes? Experimental Evidence from Rural China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018314. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18314-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Social-emotional skill development has attracted growing attention in the literature, but two gaps remain: limited evidence from low-income settings and a weak understanding of the role of parents in such interventions. We address both gaps using a stratified randomized controlled trial across 149 primary schools in counties in western China. We implement a cross-cutting design in which schools are independently randomized along two dimensions: first into a school-based SEL intervention or control, and then into a home-based intervention or control. This yields four groups: school-based only, home-based only, both, and control. The design allows us to identify the main and joint effects of each intervention and to test for complementarities between school-based and home-based inputs. The school-based program consists of weekly SEL classes delivered by trained teachers. The home-based intervention provides structured, low-cost parent–child activities delivered via an app and is designed to be scalable and less resource-intensive. The intervention lasts one year, with data collected at baseline and endline. Our primary analysis estimates the effects of each treatment arm on students’ social-emotional skills and academic performance. Guided by a theory of change, we also collect detailed data to examine behavioral responses of key actors, including teacher and parent beliefs and engagement, as well as student behavior. Finally, we compare cost-effectiveness across intervention arms, providing evidence to inform the design and scaling of SEL policies in low-resource settings.
Intervention
T1: The school-based program consists of weekly SEL classes delivered by trained teachers.
T2: The home-based intervention provides structured, low-cost parent–child activities delivered via an app.
T3: The combined intervention integrates both T1 and T2 (from a cross-cutting design).
Experimental design
We implement a cross-randomization design in which school-based and home-based interventions are assigned independently, with the school as the unit of randomization. We stratify schools into three groups based on school size. Within each stratum, we independently randomize the 149 schools along two dimensions. First, schools are assigned to receive the school-based intervention (74 schools) or not (75 schools). Second, they are independently assigned to receive the home-based intervention (74 schools) or not (75 schools).
Because the two randomizations are conducted independently, this procedure yields four groups: (i) school-only treatment, (ii) home-only treatment, (iii) combined school and home treatment, and (iv) pure control, each comprising approximately 37–38 schools. Within each school, all Grade 3 classes are included in the study sample.
Schools assigned to the school-based intervention receive a structural SEL curriculum delivered by local teachers selected by each school. At the start of each semester, the research team conducts a brief SEL training for participating teachers and provides accompanying materials, including teacher guidelines, student textbooks, instruction slides, and teaching props. Teachers deliver one SEL class per week and log completion through a mobile application after each session. In addition, SEL teachers are randomly assigned to discussion teams, which are led by a stellar teacher selected from within the team, who is incentivized to arrange monthly discussions.
Schools assigned to home-based intervention receive a program of parent-child activities designed by the research team, covering three core domains: self-awareness, self-management, and interpersonal skills. To ensure accessibility for diverse family contexts. The activities are low-cost and easily implementable, requiring no specialized equipment and drawing on materials and scenarios from daily family life. All activity materials (e.g., instructions and content) are delivered through a mobile application. Parents and children are instructed to complete one activity per week, with each session lasting approximately 30 minutes.
The control group receives no intervention from the research team during the study period.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.