Financial Distress and the Cost of Learning: Evidence from a Field Experiment

How to cite

Badio, Levenson; Palma, Marco. 2026. "Financial Distress and the Cost of Learning: Evidence from a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018292. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18292-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Levenson Badio* , Marco Palma

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018292
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18292-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-19 – 2028-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, O33, D91, D83, C93, Q16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18292

Abstract

This randomized field experiment studies whether the timing of payment for previously earned wages affects workers’ willingness to enter and persist in a learning-intensive production task. The study takes place in a maize-processing firm in rural Haiti. Participants first complete a paid manual corn-shelling task and earn a fixed payment. The experiment then randomizes whether those previously earned wages are paid immediately or deferred until after the next work session, holding total compensation fixed. In the next session, participants receive standardized instruction on a higher-throughput mechanical sheller that requires self-assembly and then face production choices involving the familiar manual method and the mechanical sheller. Within the firm’s real production need for both manual- and machine-shelled corn, the design also randomizes the initial production method, allowing the study to distinguish initial entry into the learning-intensive technology from subsequent switching, escape from the familiar low-productivity task, and retention on the unfamiliar technology. The primary outcomes are initial choice of the mechanical sheller and post-assignment machine use. The unit of randomization is the individual worker. The planned sample is 400 eligible workers recruited from the firm’s labor pool. Treatment assignment is implemented using computer-generated individual-level randomization, stratified by work session.

Intervention

Workers are individually randomly assigned to one of two treatment arms. In the cash-relief arm (Arm 1, n = 200), each worker receives a cash advance of $38, approximately five days of earnings and 2–3 weeks of typical lean-season salary delivered privately at their home two days before the work session. The advance is framed as an early installment of their expected compensation, consistent with occasional company practice. Workers in this arm receive the remaining expected earnings plus their actual piece-rate earnings at the end of the session; total compensation is identical across arms, with only the timing of the first installment varying. In the control arm (Arm 2, n = 200), workers receive no advance and no unusual contact before the session; all compensation is paid at the end of the session, so they arrive in their natural lean-season financially stressed state. On arrival, all workers are offered a binary technology choice: (A) manual corn shelling by hand, which requires no preparation and can begin immediately; or (B) a mechanical corn sheller, which yields higher piece-rate output but requires self-assembly after watching a five-minute instructional video on a tablet. The machine is provided at zero monetary cost. Workers may switch back to manual shelling at any time; pay depends solely on total output regardless of method. This design holds liquidity, information, and compensation constant across arms, isolating the cognitive margin of technology adoption.

Experimental design

This study is a randomized field experiment conducted with workers in a maize-processing firm in rural Haiti. The study examines whether earlier access to previously earned wages changes willingness to adopt a more productive but unfamiliar production technology. The experiment has two randomized components. First, after all participants complete an initial paid manual shelling task, participants are individually randomized to receive the wages earned in that task either immediately or after the next work session. Total compensation is held constant. Second, during the next work session, after standardized instruction on the mechanical sheller and measurement of initial task choice, participants are individually randomized to an initial production method, manual shelling or mechanical shelling, subject to the firm’s real production need for both types of output.

The design therefore creates a 2 by 2 structure: immediate payment plus manual start; immediate payment plus machine start; deferred payment plus manual start; deferred payment plus machine start. The first randomization identifies the effect of earned-wage payment timing on technology entry and post-assignment machine use. The second randomization identifies path dependence in production method by separating the effect of starting with a familiar low-productivity method from starting with the unfamiliar higher-throughput method. The primary sample consists of eligible workers recruited from the firm’s labor pool who complete the first paid work session and are randomized to payment timing. The planned sample is 300 workers. Enrollment will occur through work sessions organized with the firm. Randomization will be implemented by the research team using a computer-generated assignment list, stratified by work session.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted by computer by the research team before each work session. The payment-timing assignment will be randomized at the individual-worker level using a reproducible randomization seed and stratification by work session. The initial production-method assignment in the second session will also be randomized at the individual-worker level, stratified by work session and subject to the firm’s operational requirement that both manual- and machine-shelled corn be produced. Assignment lists will be prepared before treatment revelation. Field staff will reveal assignments only at the relevant implementation point.
Randomization unit
Individual worker. Payment timing is randomized at the individual-worker level. Initial production method in the second work session is also randomized at the individual-worker level. Work session fixed effects will be included in the main analysis to account for stratification and session-level conditions.
Clusters
Not applicable. Randomization is at the individual level; there is no clustering. 400 individual workers total (200 per arm).
Observations
400 workers (individuals). An observation is considered complete only if the worker participated in the full four-hour production task and consented to the post-session survey. Data collection continues until 400 completed post-session surveys are reached or at the end of the scheduled lean-season field period (April-May 2027).
Arms
Planned assignment is 150 workers to immediate payment and 150 workers to deferred payment. Within the second work session, planned assignment is 200 workers to manual start and 200 workers to machine start, yielding approximately 100 workers in each of four cells: immediate payment plus manual start; immediate payment plus machine start; deferred payment plus manual start; deferred payment plus machine start. Actual cell sizes may differ slightly because of attendance, operational production constraints, or incomplete participation, all of which will be documented.
Primary outcomes
Primary outcome 1: Initial entry into the learning-intensive technology. This is an indicator equal to one if the participant chooses the mechanical sheller rather than manual shelling at the initial task-choice point in the second work session. Primary outcome 2: Post-assignment machine use. This is an indicator equal to one if the participant uses or chooses to continue using the mechanical sheller at the pre-specified post-assignment choice point after randomized initial production-method assignment. This outcome will also be decomposed by randomized starting method: switching from manual start to machine use, and retention among participants randomly assigned to start with the machine.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include: attendance at the second work session; completion of mechanical-sheller assembly; time required to complete assembly; abandonment during assembly; total output during the work session; productivity measured as output per unit of time; piece-rate or total earnings during the work session where applicable; time until first switch; self-reported perceived difficulty of the mechanical sheller; comprehension of standardized instructions; stated preference between manual and mechanical shelling after experience; and measures of short-run financial pressure, including debt repayment, urgent expenditures, and liquidity constraints measured before the second work session.
Partners
Name: Private Company Partner_type: private_company Url: https://hbl.tamu.edu/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords