Impact Evaluation of Delivering Support as Cash versus Mobile Money in South Sudan
How to cite
Christian, Paul; Jospe, Eric; Manea, Roxana Elena; Heirman, Jonas; Waidler, Jennifer; López, Agustina. 2026. "Impact Evaluation of Delivering Support as Cash versus Mobile Money in South Sudan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018256. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18256-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In South Sudan, the delivery of assistance is shaped by constraints on infrastructure, access to technology, and financial literacy. This study evaluates the comparative effectiveness of delivering transfers via mobile money relative to traditional cash transfers in a low-connectivity, fragile setting. While digital transfers have the potential to reduce transaction costs, improve the safety of delivery, offer recipients greater flexibility in managing their resources, and expand financial inclusion, limited access to mobile networks, low penetration of mobile phones, and poor mobile vendor infrastructure may constrain their impact.
Using an experimental design, we compare outcomes across delivery modalities, focusing on take-up and use of mobile money, welfare, financial inclusion, and social capital. We further examine how take-up and impacts vary with exposure to mobile money infrastructure and transaction costs.
The results provide evidence on the feasibility and effectiveness of digital transfer systems in environments with weak infrastructure and can inform the design of assistance programs in fragile states.
Intervention
This impact evaluation will test two alternative methods to deliver support, cash and mobile money, in the context of two WFP programmes, social safety nets (SSN) and asset creation and livelihoods (ACL), in South Sudan.
SSN consists of 8 months of unconditional transfers, while ACL is relatively smaller and amounts to 3 months of conditional support. The sample for the impact evaluation includes mostly ACL villages (approximately 90%).
The ACL programme makes transfers to households against their commitment to work on creating or rehabilitating communal assets. The goal is to improve food security, restore livelihoods, while contributing to peace. The assets created by the programme include land restoration, water management solutions, feeder road construction or rehabilitation, cultivation of agricultural land, and the creation of infrastructure for livelihood diversification. The SSN programme, too, aims to help households meet their basic needs and improve resilience. The programme targets eligible urban and peri-urban areas based on their relative poverty and food insecurity.
WFP’s Country Office in South Sudan has traditionally been delivering support as either cash or in-kind (e.g., cereals and pulses), the modality being informed by county-level market assessments. Moving forward, however, the Country Office aims to switch to mobile money where cash is a feasible delivery method. A significant expansion is thus planned for 2026, with further scale-up efforts thereafter until the switch to mobile money is complete where possible.
Experimental design
We initially planned to implement a two-arm cluster-randomized controlled trial in approximately 126 villages. Villages were randomly assigned, in equal proportions (and stratified at the payam level) to receive either cash transfers or mobile money transfers. The village-level randomization reflects the operational scale of program delivery and mitigates concerns about within-community spillovers. Treatment effects are to be estimated by comparing mean outcomes across arms, with inference adjusted for intra-cluster correlation.
As the mobile money scale-up depended heavily on the network operator, the RCT was ultimately implemented in the strata (payams) where the mobile money expansion was possible. Out of the initially planned sample, 5 strata were dropped because the network coverage proved insufficient for registration and the use of mobile money. As the treatment arm assignment was stratified at the payam level, the sample has remained balanced: 41 villages continuing to receive Cash and 41 villages switching to Mobile Money.
Data collection schedule: Ultra-brief baseline (less than 20 questions) in May 2026, follow-up round 1 in September 2026, and follow-up round 2 in December 2026.
Estimation specifications:
Y = cst + a MoMo + d Strata + e (round-based)
Y = cst + a MoMo + b Round2 + c MoMo x Round2 + d Strata + f Strata x Round2 + e (pooled)
Alternative specification where baseline values of Y are available (e.g., HHS, phone use, MoMo use):
Y = cst + a MoMo + b Round2 + c MoMo x Round2 + d Strata + f Strata x Round2 + g BaseChar + e
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.