How Important are Firm Visits for High School Students? Evidence from a Randomized-Control Trial
How to cite
Avdeenko, Alexandra. 2016. "How Important are Firm Visits for High School Students? Evidence from a Randomized-Control Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001823. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1823-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Firm visit experiences are de-facto established as an important screening tool in the labor market, signaling to the employer the quality and experience of a candidate. Compulsory firm visits (mostly as internships) become an essential part of many school and university curricula, withdrawing the students from education for weeks and months. It is expected that firm visits can support the occupational choice and establish important networks to the employer. At the same time, the labor market literature on the effects of firm visits is almost non-existent. If firm visits have no beneficial impacts on labor market outcomes, and what we so-far observe is driven by self-selection of very motivated students, then keeping students out of school/ university could even have negative impacts on labor market outcomes. In collaboration with UNICEF Montenegro and Giant's Shoulder, the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Labor we evaluate a program that investigates the effects of a unique labor market pilot initiative called ``Prilike''. Within the scope of the ``Prilike'' project, UNICEF and Giant's Shoulder have established a cooperation with over 50 companies, amongst others with Microsoft, Siemens, Inditex, Ernst \& Young, and KPMG. To evaluate whether the experience of going to these companies changes expectations about the labor market hiring process and expected wages, as well as ambitions to work in the private sector, we set-up a randomized-control trial. From the pool of all schools in Montenegro, we randomly select eight schools to the program. Following, using then individual-level administrative data and a survey responses for students from the 11th and 12th grade, we randomly match a randomly selected group of students to the companies. Overall, we find that the program has made the students' labor market expectations more realistic, optimistic and changed the students' locus of control.
Intervention
One-day internships to the companies took place between November 16, 2016 and December 2, 2016. In total around 60 companies participated in the initiative, all from different industries and across the country. Adolescents were assigned to at least one 1-day-internship at a company.
Experimental design
The randomization was performed in two steps: (1) we selected the schools and (2) we selected the students. On October 6th 2016 the Ministry of Education shared administrative records of all students in secondary education. Using administrative information to balance characteristics we randomly selected 8 schools out of 50 to be part of the initiative. Throughout the county we implement an online survey to acquire additional background information. Over 40% of students in grades 3 and 4 of secondary schools participated. For further analysis we use a total of 4,003 student surveys from treatment and control schools, Thereof 1,437 were from the 8 selected schools and 2,566 from other schools.
In the 8 schools we randomly selected we select 359 students who were eligible to attend a company and 360 students who were eligible to attend a company three times. 719 students remain in the control group, whereby 359 have already been assigned to a further future intervention.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.