Human Capital as Insurance: Skill Portfolio Choices under Occupational Uncertainty
How to cite
Beam, Emily; Navarro-Sola, Laia; Dahis, Ricardo; Mello, Ursula. 2026. "Human Capital as Insurance: Skill Portfolio Choices under Occupational Uncertainty." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018196. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18196-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Individuals invest in human capital under uncertainty about their future labor market outcomes. Vocational training prepares students for a specific career path, but the distribution of potential occupations is generally wide, and many may lack information about dispersion of these outcomes and their own proficiency in transferable skills—leading to underinvestment in portable human capital. We test whether providing concise, data-driven information can correct these misperceptions and shift investment toward transferable skills. In partnership with SENAI-SP, Brazil's largest vocational training provider, we conduct a 2×2 factorial experiment among approximately 34,000 students across roughly 100 schools, 1,200 classrooms, and 47 vocational tracks in São Paulo. Classrooms are randomized to receive: (i) track-specific labor market information showing the distribution of occupational destinations among recent graduates, (ii) personalized feedback on students' relative standing in key soft skill domains, (iii) both, or (iv) neither. Both treatments are embedded within a baseline survey administered in classroom settings. The main outcomes are beliefs about occupational dispersion and self-assessed soft skills, hypothetical portfolio allocation across technical and transferable skill domains, and stated willingness to invest in further soft skills development.
Intervention
The experiment follows a 2×2 factorial design. Both information treatments are randomized at the classroom level and embedded within a baseline survey.
Treatment 1 — Labor Market Information (LM): Track-specific information about the distribution of occupational destinations among recent graduates. The information is drawn from administrative matches of prior cohorts (RAIS + SENAI) and shows that graduates disperse across a range of occupations rather than entering a single expected occupation. For each track, the module displays one expected occupation, three alternative occupations, and a residual category, along with track-level facts on vacancies, wages, and projected trends. Students see a neutral transition screen in lieu of SS.
Treatment 2 — Self-Information (SS): Personalized feedback on the student's relative standing in three soft skill domains (collaboration/teamwork, planning/organization, self-regulation), based on a validated baseline assessment battery. Feedback is presented as a percentile or coarse category relative to peers, highlighting strengths and areas for improvement. Students see a neutral transition screen in lieu of LM.
Combined arm (LM + SS): Both modules presented sequentially—labor market information first, then self-information.
Control: No information screens; students see a neutral transition screen of similar length.
All students (including control) complete the same baseline assessment modules before any information is shown, and the same outcome modules after.
Experimental design
We implement a 2×2 factorial experiment embedded within a baseline survey administered to approximately 34,000 students across roughly 100 schools, 1,200 classrooms, and 47 vocational tracks in São Paulo, operated by SENAI-SP.
Both treatments are randomized at the **classroom level** to limit within-class contamination and spillovers during survey administration.
Classrooms are assigned to one of four strata groups before randomization, based on data availability:
1. Standard tracks (≥10 classes per track): Each track forms its own stratum; classrooms randomized into all four arms. Combined with small tracks, this group comprises 1,092 classrooms (~30,600 students), with 273 classrooms per arm.
2. Small tracks (<10 classes per track): Pooled into sector-level strata when the sector contains at least 10 classes; randomized into all four arms. Included in the 1,092 classroom count above.
3. Early-survey classrooms (5 schools, surveyed before soft skill percentile scores are available): 61 classrooms (~1,700 students). Cannot receive the SS treatment; randomized into LM or Control only (30 control, 31 LM).
4. No RAIS match classrooms (11 tracks without RAIS–SENAI administrative match data): 46 classrooms (~1,300 students). Cannot receive the LM treatment; randomized into SS or Control only (23 per arm).
5. Both constraints (early-survey and no RAIS match): 2 classrooms (~55 students). Assigned to Control only.
This yields unequal arm sizes: Control 328 classrooms (~9,200 students), LM only 304 (~8,500), SS only 296 (~8,300), LM+SS 273 (~7,600). Total: 1,200 classrooms, approximately 34,000 students.
All estimation uses classroom-level clustered standard errors and includes strata fixed effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.