Economic Insecurity and Discrimination towards Transgender People

How to cite

Aktas, Mia. 2026. "Economic Insecurity and Discrimination towards Transgender People." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018170. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18170-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mia Aktas*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018170
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18170-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-03-23 – 2026-03-31
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18170

Abstract

This study tests whether acute economic insecurity amplifies discrimination toward transgender women in prosocial decisions. Non-LGBTQ+ adults are recruited online (Prolific) and they are assigned to economic (in)security based on the payday calendar they report. If the current date is 2 to 4 days before their payday they are assigned to insecurity treatment and they do a writing task to prime income insecurity, if its 0 to 3 days after they receive their wage they are assigned to do security treatment and do a security writing task.
and After the writing task, participants report current affect (PANAS) and then play a give-or-take dictator game in which the outcome is the net transfer to the recipient (positive values indicate giving; negative values indicate taking). Each dictator makes allocation decisions for three recipient profiles: a transgender woman, a cisgender woman, and a man. Recipient profiles were identical expect color of the tshirt and month of birth, with transgender status signaled via the profile’s gender field and avatar. The within-subject component is fully counterbalanced using all six possible profile orders (balanced panel; no feedback between rounds), and one decision is randomly selected for payment.

The primary estimands are (i) the effect of economic insecurity on average transfers, (ii) the within-person allocation gap between transgender and cisgender women (a behavioral measure of discrimination), and (iii) whether insecurity moderates this trans--cis gap. Order and carryover will be evaluated via profile-by-position interactions and prior-profile indicators; if diagnostics indicate meaningful carryover, a pre-registered fallback estimates discrimination using the first decision only (between-subject comparison). Secondary analyses examine heterogeneity in discriminatory gaps, moderation by baseline prejudice and demographics, associational mediation via PANAS and CRT, and downstream effects on policy attitudes.

Intervention

Participants are screened/assigned to insecurity vs security using a pre-specified rule based on self-reported payday date (2–4 days pre-payday = insecurity; 0–3 days post-payday = security). The manipulation is reinforced with a 4-minute writing task about a past/present episode of financial insecurity vs security. PANAS is measured immediately after the writing task. Dictators then complete a give-or-take dictator task with three recipients (trans woman / cis woman / man), shown in one of the six fully counterbalanced orders. Profiles are identical on substantive characteristics; minor cosmetic variation (e.g., T-shirt color; month/quarter of birth) is used to reduce demand effects. Trans status is signaled only by the gender category and avatar. No outcome feedback is given. One round is randomly selected for payment (plus any fixed participation payment).

Experimental design

Hybrid design combining (i) a between-subject income (in)security condition assigned via payday timing plus a writing prime, and (ii) a within-subject dictator task in which each participant makes net-transfer decisions for three recipient profiles (trans woman, cis woman, man). The within-subject component is fully counterbalanced across all six profile orders; no feedback is provided. One decision is randomly selected for payment.

Design details

Randomization method
Income (in)security condition: assigned by a pre-specified rule using self-reported payday timing (2–4 days pre-payday vs 0–3 days post-payday) + corresponding writing prime. Within-sub profile order: computer randomization assigns each participant to one of the six possible profile sequences with equal probability. Incentives: one dictator decision is randomly selected for payment by the experimental software.
Randomization unit
Individual participants (dictators). Within-sub profile order is randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
500 participants
Observations
500 individuals total (primary unit). Each provides 3 dictator-game observations (1500 decision-level observations) plus survey outcomes.
Arms
250 security, 250 insecurity
Primary outcomes
Net transfer in the give-or-take dictator game for each recipient profile (positive = giving; negative = taking)
Secondary outcomes
PANAS Positive Affect and Negative Affect scores, CRT score, transgender policy attitudes (indices/subscales). Heterogeneity measures (distribution of individual discrimination gaps)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords