Household electricity subsidies and investments in energy efficiency

How to cite

Punjabi, Maitri; Barnwal, Prabhat. 2026. "Household electricity subsidies and investments in energy efficiency." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018167. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18167-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maitri Punjabi* , Prabhat Barnwal

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018167
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18167-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-21 – 2026-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O13, Q41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18167

Abstract

With rising incomes and temperatures, India represents the world's fastest growing market for cooling. Simultaneously, the extensive use of residential electricity subsidies has effectively brought down the price of cooling, further accelerating the adoption of air conditioners. We study the adoption of energy efficient air conditioners in a large Indian state with a unique electricity subsidy program that induces a large bill discontinuity: households with utilization below an average of 10 kWh per day in a given billing cycle are exempt from paying their bill, whereas consumers that exceed this threshold pay for all units consumed. This induces a bill discontinuity equivalent to 18% of monthly per-capita income. Under this pricing schedule, air conditioner operating costs are zero for consumers that remain below the threshold. This experiment measures willingness to pay for energy efficiency in this setting. Treated households receive a discount voucher for the purchase of an AC---treatment arm 1 receives a base discount for the purchase of any model AC, and treatment arm 2 receives the same base discount plus a bonus discount for the purchase of a 5-star AC. We track AC purchase decisions across control and treated groups to map (i) any AC take up (control vs. T1) and (ii) energy efficiency take up (T1 vs. T2). This experiment will allow us to trace the demand curve and measure willingness to pay for energy efficiency. This project aims to comment on how electricity price subsidies could disincentivize investments in energy efficiency, leading to long-term consequences for energy consumption and pollution generation.

Intervention

Households will be randomized into two treatment arms: base discount group (T1) and base discount PLUS energy efficiency discount (T2). T1 will receive a base discount of Rs. 2000 for the purchase of any model AC. T2 will receive the same base discount, plus an additional discount of Rs. 4000 for the purchase of an energy efficient model AC (specifically, a 5-star rated AC according to India's BEE standards). This discount is provided through a physical voucher provided to the household, eligible to be redeemed at selected partner retailers in the city. The household will have approximately 4-6 weeks to purchase an AC and redeem the discount directly from the retailer.

Experimental design

This study involves a baseline and endline survey and the provision of a discount voucher to randomly selected households in our sample. Households will be assigned to one of three groups: Control, Treatment arm 1, or Treatment arm 2. Control households will only complete the baseline and endline surveys and will not receive any discount vouchers. Treatment arm 1 will receive a discount of Rs. 2000 for the purchase of any type of AC (purchased from a participating partner retailer). Treatment arm 2 will receive the same discount offer of Rs. 2000 for the purchase of any type of AC, plus an additional bonus discount of Rs. 4000 if the purchased AC is a 5-star rated appliance (according to India's official BEE ratings). For example, a respondent in T2 that purchases a 5-star AC will receive a total discount of Rs. 6000.

Typical AC prices for the most common star rating (3 star) fall in the range of Rs. 25-30K and this price increases to 35-40K for 5-star. A discount of Rs. 4000 therefore covers about 40% of the price differential, though this may vary across brands and models. Our study aims to measure the willingness to pay for energy efficiency by observing the 5-star take-up rate across T1 and T2 households.

Consumers will be visited at baseline to complete the survey and will be given a physical voucher for them to maintain and redeem at partner retail stores. They will have approximately 4-6 weeks to redeem the voucher for a discount. The partner retailer will verify the voucher and participant details (to ensure the voucher is being redeemed by the same household it was provided to) and provide the discount directly to the consumer at the time of purchase. The retailers will then request payment from the project.

Consumers will be visited again at endline to complete a survey about their AC purchase decisions. We will triangulate endline data with the data received from retail partners on discount vouchers redeemed.

Design details

Randomization method
Households are randomly pre-assigned to a treatment group using Stata following a non-weighted, sampling-without-replacement method. Surveyors are informed of this treatment assignment toward the end of the survey through Survey CTO, which uses prefills based on the household ID entered by the surveyor at the beginning of the survey.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
225 households
Observations
225 households
Arms
Control: 75 households, T1: 75 households, T2: 75 households
Primary outcomes
For each treatment group (Control, T1, T2), our key outcomes of interest include: a. What proportion of households purchased an AC? b. What proportion of households purchased a 5-star AC?
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity in treatment effects by pre-treatment electricity utilization levels. Difference in stated WTP and revealed WTP. Characteristics of ACs purchased, by treatment group.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords