Nudging Microentrepreneurs into Formalization in Brazil

How to cite

Lenz, Anna-Katharina; Valdivia, Martin. 2026. "Nudging Microentrepreneurs into Formalization in Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018158. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18158-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anna-Katharina Lenz* , Martin Valdivia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018158
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18158-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-04-29 – 2026-03-17
Countries
Brazil (Rio de Janeiro)
JEL codes
C93, D22, D91, L26, O12, O17
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18158

Abstract

This study examines whether behavioral barriers and local conditions shape informal microentrepreneurs’ decisions to formalize their businesses, and whether simple, low-cost interventions can help them do so. The study was conducted in Complexo Maré, a large favela area in Rio de Janeiro marked by poverty, territorial criminal control, and mobility restrictions. A total of 790 informal microentrepreneurs were enrolled and randomly assigned at the individual level, within neighborhoods, to one of four groups. One group received an in-person informational visit about the government’s subsidized formalization program for individual microentrepreneurs (MEI). A second group received weekly SMS messages about formalization over a period of 10 weeks. A third group received both the in-person informational visit and the weekly SMS reminders. A fourth group served as the control group and received neither intervention.

The in-person visits explained the business and social protection benefits of MEI, including easier business registration, the possibility of hiring one worker under simplified rules, and access to social security benefits. The visits also explained the steps and documents needed to register and encouraged entrepreneurs to complete the process with support from the local SEBRAE office. The SMS messages reinforced this information over time and reminded entrepreneurs about the opportunity to formalize and the availability of free assistance. Because the registration process in this study was tied to an in-person visit to the SEBRAE office, the study also takes into account that some entrepreneurs faced additional barriers linked to violence, territorial boundaries, and restricted mobility across neighborhoods.

The study examines whether these interventions affect business formalization, compliance with the formalization program, and longer-term business survival. It also examines whether the effects of the interventions depend on the surrounding institutional and security environment. Outcome data on formalization were assembled for 728 entrepreneurs, and follow-up survey data were collected for 701 entrepreneurs. The goal is to better understand why many informal business owners do not adopt potentially beneficial business practices, and how policies to support formalization can be designed to work more effectively in complex real-world settings.

Intervention

A total of 790 informal microentrepreneurs in Complexo Maré, Rio de Janeiro, were randomly allocated across four groups. The study was designed to test whether low-cost behavioral interventions could help entrepreneurs overcome behavioral barriers to formalization, especially limited attention, procrastination, and the difficulty of following through on a decision that has immediate costs but delayed benefits.

Treatment group one (i) received an in-person informational visit at their business, during which trained field staff explained the government’s subsidized MEI formalization program, including its business benefits, social protection benefits, registration requirements, and the availability of free assistance through the local SEBRAE office.

Treatment group two (ii) received weekly SMS messages over a period of 10 weeks. These messages gave information about MEI and reminded entrepreneurs about the opportunity to formalize, and encouraged follow-through.

Treatment group three (iii) received both the in-person informational visit and the 10 weekly SMS reminders, allowing us to test whether reminders were needed to overcome behavioral biases that impede take-up after an information session.

A fourth group served as the control group and received neither the informational visit nor the reminders.

The central idea of the intervention was that many entrepreneurs may already see value in formalization, but fail to act because of behavioral frictions; the text-message nudges were therefore designed to help them move from intention to action.

Experimental design

The study uses an individually randomized field experiment with four arms. Informal microentrepreneurs in Complexo Maré, Rio de Janeiro, were randomly allocated at the individual level, stratified by neighborhood, to one of four conditions: (1) an in-person informational visit about the MEI formalization program plus weekly SMS reminders for 10 weeks, (2) weekly SMS reminders only, (3) an in-person informational visit only, or (4) a control group that received neither intervention. This design allows the study to compare the effects of information alone, reminders alone, and the combined treatment against a no-treatment comparison group, and to test whether behavioral nudges in the form of reminders help entrepreneurs act on information they receive.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was conducted on the spot during the baseline survey using the Randomizer in Qualtrics Survey Software. After the enumerator entered the entrepreneur’s identifying information, the software automatically generated a random treatment number from one to four, assigning the participant to one of the three treatment groups or the control group.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization was the individual microentrepreneur.
Clusters
The study included 790 informal microentrepreneurs at baseline.
Observations
The study included 790 informal microentrepreneurs at baseline.
Arms
Treatment Group 1 (i): 207 Treatment Group 2 (ii): 201 Treatment Group 3 (iii): 203 Control Group: 179
Primary outcomes
Here is a clean answer you can use: The key outcome variables in this experiment are measures of business formalization and longer-term business performance. The primary outcomes are: (1) whether the entrepreneur formally registered the business through the MEI program after the intervention; (2) whether the entrepreneur both registered and remained compliant with the program’s required tax payments; and (3) whether the business remained in operation at longer-term follow-up.
Secondary outcomes
In addition to the primary outcomes, the study examines intermediate outcomes related to the formalization process, including whether the entrepreneur contacted the local SEBRAE office, whether the entrepreneur knew about the existence and location of the SEBRAE office, whether the entrepreneur understood the benefits of the MEI program, and whether the entrepreneur reported thinking about formalizing the business. These outcomes allow us to study both whether the intervention changed final behavior and whether it first changed knowledge, perceptions, and intentions that could lead to formalization.
Partners
Name: SEBRAE Rio de Janeiro Partner_type: none Url: https://www.sebraerj.com.br/ Name: Redes da Mare Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.redesdamare.org.br/en

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords