Evidence Provision, Defendant Race, and Criminal Justice Punitiveness: A Survey Experiment in Brazil

How to cite

Stragliotto, Fernando. 2026. "Evidence Provision, Defendant Race, and Criminal Justice Punitiveness: A Survey Experiment in Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018157. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18157-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Fernando Stragliotto*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018157
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18157-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-20 – 2028-02-29
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18157

Abstract

This study examines whether providing causal evidence on the effects of pretrial detention changes public attitudes toward criminal justice policy in Brazil. Participants are randomly assigned to a treatment group that receives a summary of peer-reviewed research showing that pretrial detention increases criminal reoffending, or to a control group that does not receive this information. All participants evaluate two criminal case vignettes — involving theft and knife assault — and make bail and sentencing recommendations. Defendant race (Black or White) is independently randomized across participants, with each participant seeing defendants of only one racial group. The study investigates whether scientific evidence shifts policy preferences, and whether the effect of evidence varies by defendant race, respondent characteristics, or political orientation. Data are collected via an online survey experiment with a nationally representative quota sample of Brazilian adults (N=550).

Intervention

Participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions. The treatment group receives a summary of a peer-reviewed study (Dobbie, Goldin, and Yang, 2018, American Economic Review) on the effects of pretrial detention on recidivism and labor market outcomes. The control group completes the same survey without receiving any research summary. To ensure comparability across arms, Bilendi applies identical non-interlocking demographic quotas on gender, age, region, race, and income independently to each survey link, with target proportions specified separately for each arm.

Experimental design

Two-arm randomized survey experiment with a nationally representative quota sample of Brazilian adults (N=550), recruited via the Bilendi online panel. Participants are randomly assigned to treatment (N=275) or control (N=275), with with independant demographic quota balancing applied to each treatment arm. All participants complete demographic questions, a prior recidivism belief elicitation with a confidence rating, an attention check, and two case vignettes (theft followed by knife assault) requiring bail and sentencing recommendations, followed by a mechanism vignette and stated policy preference questions. The treatment group additionally receives a summary of peer-reviewed evidence on pretrial detention effects between the prior belief elicitation and the vignettes. Defendant race (all-Black or all-White AI-generated images) is independently randomized at the individual level.

Design details

Randomization method
Individual-level randomization implemented via JavaScript executed within the Qualtrics survey platform at survey entry. Treatment vs. control assignment is determined by two separate survey links distributed by the panel company Bilendi, with independant demographic quota balancing applied to each link. Within-survey randomization (defendant race) uses a pseudorandom number generator seeded at runtime.
Randomization unit
Individual. Each participant is independently randomized to treatment or control via survey link assignment, and to defendant race condition via in-survey JavaScript randomization.
Clusters
550 individuals (no clustering; unit of randomization equals unit of observation)
Observations
550 individuals; 1,100 vignette-level observations (2 vignettes per participant)
Arms
275 individuals in treatment arm; 275 individuals in control arm
Primary outcomes
Bail recommendation for the theft vignette (pretrial release vs. pretrial detention) — binary Bail recommendation for the knife assault vignette — binary Sentencing recommendation for the theft vignette — binary (most punitive (lenient) option vs. any less punitive option) and ordinal (1=most lenient, 3=most punitive) as robustness check Sentencing recommendation for the knife assault vignette — binary and ordinal Prior and posterior recidivism beliefs: estimated number of reoffenders out of 10 defendants released before trial (0–10 slider), elicited before the intervention for all participants and again after the intervention for treatment participants who report updating their beliefs Heterogeneous treatment effects by defendant race (Black vs. White images shown)
Secondary outcomes
Support for CRV petition (nationwide expansion of prison occupancy regulation) — binary (yes/no/unsure) Budget allocation to prison expansion vs. rehabilitation programs — continuous (0–11 BRL billions slider) Perceived likelihood that the theft vignette defendant has a prior criminal record — 5-point Likert scale Perceived likelihood that the theft vignette defendant will commit a violent crime in the future — 5-point Likert scale Confidence in prior (and posterior if applicable) recidivism beliefs — 5-point Likert scale, elicited immediately after the prior/posterior belief slider Perceived adequacy of the evidence study methodology — 5-point scale, elicited retrospectively at the end of the survey for treatment participants only Estimated reduction in reoffending for Black defendants specifically - 5 point scale (ranging from increase in recidivism to a reduction larger than the overall reduction in the evidence) Estimated reduction in reoffending for White defendants specifically Heterogeneous treatment effects by respondent race, other respondent characteristics, and evidence uptake (treatment group only)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords