Misperceptions and intergroup cooperation
How to cite
Gately, Pierce; Jiang-Wang, Ángela. 2026. "Misperceptions and intergroup cooperation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018155. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18155-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
How groups perceive each other can impede or facilitate intergroup cooperation, which is necessary to solve large scale collective action problems. If groups harbour negative feelings towards each other, it can foster an 'us' vs 'them' mentality which undermines societal progress by curtailing cooperation beyond group lines. A canonical finding in experimental literature is that most people are conditional cooperators, willing to cooperate if they believe others will do likewise. For such individuals’ beliefs about the cooperativeness of others are central to determining their own behaviour. In intergroup contexts perceived polarisation between groups can be self-reinforcing if individuals expect intergroup prejudicial attitudes to translate into discriminatory actions. We propose a series of studies to unpack the behavioural channels through which perceptions of polarisation between groups impact intergroup cooperation.
Experimental design
We are planning to conduct two studies:
Study 1. We will elicit participants' feelings toward President Donald Trump in order to classify them as Trump Lovers or Trump Haters following a method similar to that of Dimant (2024). Study 1 is composed of three treatments. In all treatments, in-group and out-group membership will be defined using the Trump Hate/Love paradigm. That is, all participants will play with a Trump Lover in one group and a Trump Hater in the other group in the S-PGG.
Anonymous treatment: No information will be given to participants regarding the identity of their partner in each group in the S-PGG.
Trump treatment: We will reveal to participants whether they will play with a Trump Lover or a Trump Hater in each group in the S-PGG. All participants will be randomly matched with a Trump Lover in one group and a Trump Hater in the other group.
Charity treatment: Same as Trump treatment; however, a fixed portion of the earnings generated from the group accounts will go toward a charity (Feeding America).
Study 2. If we detect misperceptions in Study 1, we will aim to correct them through information provision treatments in a follow-up study. We will have a control group where no information is provided, and information provision treatments where we will reveal the true personal norms, attitudes, and/or feelings thermometer ratings elicited in Study 1. We will aim to correct misperceptions in one domain per treatment. The final number of treatments will depend on whether we detect misperceptions in Study 1. Participants will then play another S-PGG mirroring the design of the Trump treatment in Study 1.
More details about the experimental design are disclosed in the attached materials.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.