Calibrating Trust: An RCT on Anti-Fraud Education and Verification Behavior among Adolescents

How to cite

Chen, Zeyang; Liu, Yu-Jane; Wang, Jianhong; Kong, The University of Hong; Zhou, Tiantian. 2026. "Calibrating Trust: An RCT on Anti-Fraud Education and Verification Behavior among Adolescents." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018138. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18138-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zeyang Chen* , Yu-Jane Liu , Jianhong Wang , The University of Hong Kong , Tiantian Zhou

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018138
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18138-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-16 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18138

Abstract

This study investigates whether a short, school-based curriculum can improve adolescents' ability to verify information and protect themselves from digital fraud while calibrating their social trust appropriately. We conduct a randomized controlled trial in junior high schools in China, involving approximately 50 classrooms and 2,500 seventh and eighth-grade students. The intervention consists of a 45-minute anti-fraud education module delivered during regular class time. Rather than focusing on fear-based warnings, the curriculum teaches students to:
Identify common fraud signals (false authority, urgency, emotional manipulation); Apply cost-benefit reasoning to information verification decisions; Distinguish between healthy skepticism and excessive distrust. We measure impacts on students' verification behavior, fraud detection sensitivity, and generalized social trust using incentivized experimental tasks adapted from economics literature. This research addresses a critical gap in financial education by providing experimental evidence on whether verification skills—traditionally viewed as innate or experience-based—can be effectively taught in a classroom setting. The findings will inform policy discussions about scalable, cost-effective approaches to reducing youth victimization in the digital economy.

Experimental design

We employ a school-based randomized controlled trial with the following structure:
Setting: Public junior high schools (grades 7-8) in China. Schools represent a mix of high-performing and average institutions to enhance external validity.
Participant Recruitment: All students in selected classrooms are invited to participate.
Baseline: Students complete a 10-minute survey during school hours, including demographic questions and baseline outcome measures.
Intervention: Classrooms are randomly assigned to either:
(1) Treatment: Receive a 45-minute anti-fraud education module delivered by their regular teacher
(2) Control: Continue with standard curriculum (no intervention)
The anti-fraud module uses standardized materials (PPT, video, scripted lesson plan) that teachers receive before delivery. Teachers are instructed to follow the script closely to ensure fidelity.
Two waves of follow-up assessments:
(1) Immediate post-test: Administered within 48 hours of the intervention
(2) Three-month follow-up: Conducted during the same academic term to minimize attrition
Incentives: All outcome measurement tasks include real incentives. Students earn tokens exchangeable for school supplies (pencils, notebooks, etc.). Each incentivized question includes a random lottery where one student per classroom receives their earned reward.
School teachers and students' parents also receive a survey to evaluate the students' performance from the third-party's perspective.

Design details

Randomization method
Classrooms are first stratified by school and grade level. Within each stratum, classrooms are randomly assigned to treatment or control with equal probability (50/50), which is decided by random numbers generated by a computer.
Randomization unit
Classroom (cluster)
Clusters
50 classrooms across 3~4 junior middle schools
Observations
Students: Approximately 2,500 students (50 students per classroom × 50 classrooms) Observations per student: - Baseline: 1 observation - Immediate post-test: 1 observation - Three-month follow-up: 1 observation Total planned observations: 7,500 student-time observations (2,500 students × 3 time points)
Arms
Treatment Group (Anti-Fraud Module): - 25 classrooms - ~1,250 students (approximately 50 per classroom) - Receive: 45-minute anti-fraud education module + all three assessments Control Group (Standard Curriculum): - 25 classrooms - ~1,250 students (approximately 50 per classroom) - Receive: No intervention + all three assessments
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcome 1: Information Verification Behavior Measured through the behaviors in a modified trust game where students decide whether to verify an anonymous partner's type and how much to send to an anonymous partner Primary Outcome 2: Fraud Detection Sensitivity Measured as the ability to correctly distinguish between fraudulent and legitimate scenarios. Students evaluate 5 short vignettes and classify each as "likely fraud" or "likely legitimate." Primary Outcome 3: Generalized Social Trust Measured through standard World Values Survey question on trust in strangers and different types of social institutions Exploratory Outcomes: We will also examine spillover effects on their family and heterogeneous effects by gender, socioeconomic status, and baseline cognitive ability.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords