Seeing the Cliff Before You Fall: The Cognitive Cost of Misperception

How to cite

Tascon, Daniel. 2026. "Seeing the Cliff Before You Fall: The Cognitive Cost of Misperception." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018135. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18135-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniel Tascon*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018135
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18135-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-15 – 2026-05-06
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H53, J22, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18135

Abstract

This study examines how the format in which benefit information is presented affects low-income workers' understanding of multi-program benefit cliffs and their labor-supply decisions. Benefit cliffs occur when modest earnings increases trigger disproportionate losses in public assistance — such as SNAP, Medicaid, CCDF, and TANF — leaving households worse off despite higher wages. Using a 2×2 between-subject experiment recruited through Prolific, we randomly assign participants to one of two information formats (an interactive dashboard or an AI assistant) and independently vary whether they receive information about the temporary nature of benefit losses (recovery information). Participants first complete a baseline estimate of how a hypothetical job offer would affect their total household resources, then receive their assigned treatment and revise their estimate. We measure belief improvement (reduction in prediction error), decision quality, and money-metric regret. The study aims to identify which informational friction — computational complexity, format, and situational mapping, or intertemporal uncertainty — generates the largest share of welfare loss from misperceived benefit cliffs.

Intervention

Participants are randomly assigned to one of four arms in a 2×2 design. The first dimension varies the format in which benefit information is presented: (1) an interactive dashboard that visualizes how total household resources change at different income levels, or (2) an AI assistant that delivers the same underlying information conversationally and maps program rules to the participant's specific household. The second dimension independently varies whether participants receive recovery information — a brief statement indicating that workers who experience a benefit cliff typically return to their prior resource level within 1–3 years as wage growth offsets benefit losses. All participants first complete a baseline stage with no additional information beyond a standard text description of the scenario, replicating the information environment workers encounter in real life. In the second stage, participants receive their assigned treatment and answer the same questions again. This design allows us to separately identify the effect of information format (Frictions 1 and 2: computational complexity and situational mapping) from the effect of reducing perceived permanence of losses (Friction 3: intertemporal uncertainty).

Experimental design

This study uses a 2×2 between-subject experiment. Participants are randomly assigned to one of four arms crossing two dimensions: information format (interactive dashboard vs. AI assistant) and recovery information (absent vs. present). All participants complete a baseline estimation task before receiving their assigned treatment. The target sample is N = 300 U.S. adults recruited via Prolific who currently receive or have recently received at least one government assistance program.

Design details

Randomization method
Individual-level randomization is implemented automatically by the oTree platform at session creation. Participants are assigned to one of four arms using deterministic block randomization in blocks of 4, guaranteeing exact balance (25% per arm) across the full sample. Block order is shuffled randomly within each block using a pseudo-random number generator.
Randomization unit
Individual participant.
Clusters
300 participants
Observations
300 participants
Arms
75 participants — Arm A (Dashboard, no recovery information) 75 participants — Arm B (Dashboard, recovery information) 75 participants — Arm C (AI assistant, no recovery information) 75 participants — Arm D (AI assistant, recovery information)
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is belief improvement — the reduction in absolute prediction error between Stage 1 and Stage 2, measured in dollars per month: BI = |ε₁| − |ε₂| = |Δ̂₁ − Δ*| − |Δ̂₂ − Δ*| where Δ̂ₛ is the participant's stated prediction of monthly household resource change at stage s and Δ* is the true change computed from Policy Rules Database rules. A positive value indicates the treatment brought beliefs closer to the truth. This outcome captures the extent to which each information format reduces misperception of benefit cliff magnitudes.
Secondary outcomes
Decision quality — an indicator equal to 1 if the participant's job acceptance recommendation aligns with the financially optimal decision (accept if Δ* > 0, reject if Δ* < 0), measured at Stage 1 and Stage 2 separately. The treatment effect is the change in decision quality between stages: Optimal₂ − Optimal₁. Money-metric regret — the dollar value of welfare loss from a suboptimal decision, defined as Regret = R_best − R_chosen ≥ 0, where R_j is total monthly household resources under option j. Regret is positive only when the participant recommends the dominated option. Willingness to pay for benefit information — the percentage of the monthly wage increase the participant would pay for a service that reveals exact benefit changes before accepting a job offer (Stage 3), converted to dollars using the vignette wage increase. Reconsideration — an indicator for whether the participant changes their job acceptance recommendation after seeing the true resource change in Stage 3. Tolerance for short-term loss — the maximum monthly resource loss the participant would accept for a job with significantly better long-term career prospects (Stage 3), measured in dollars per month. Stated confidence — self-reported confidence in the prediction at Stage 1 and Stage 2, used to test whether treatments raise confidence without improving accuracy (over-confidence check, particularly relevant for the AI assistant arm).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords