Energy Transition and Fiscal Preferences: A Survey Experiment (2)
How to cite
Mukherjee, Srutakirti; James, Alexander. 2026. "Energy Transition and Fiscal Preferences: A Survey Experiment (2)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018078. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18078-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study people's preferences for - and willingness to move in order to receive/avoid - various fiscal responses to declining fossil-fuel revenue. Our survey instrument includes two experiments. Experiment 1 is designed to assess factors that influence people's willingness to move to a community in a fossil-fuel-rich state (Laramie, Wyoming). Factors considered include i) tax policy, ii) public goods provision, and iii) natural amenities. Experiment 2 evaluates the factors that influence people's preferences for - willingness to move away in order to avoid - certain policy responses. This second experiment is designed to answer three main questions: i) Do people respond differently to tax increases when they are framed as responses to declining fossil-fuel revenue? ii) Which types of policy responses do people prefer (and are there meaningful heterogeneous preferences)? iii) Do people respond differently to the implementation of a tax as opposed to an increase in an existing one?
Intervention
We run an online survey experiment that targets United States residents in one of the top eleven fossil-fuel-rich states ( Alaska, Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, and Wyoming) and above the age of eighteen. The survey is designed in Qualtrics and administered on Prolific.
Respondents are first asked to report basic demographic information about themselves.
Respondents are then randomly assigned to one of two experiments. Experiment 1 provides respondents with information about Laramie, WY., and then gauges their i) interest in moving to Laramie, WY., and ii) their expected satisfaction associated with living there. Experiment 2 elicits i) people's stated willingness to leave their state and ii) people's expected life satisfaction of remaining in their state, under various conditions in which their state government has responded (hypothetically) in a certain way to declining fossil-fuel revenue.
After exposure to one of the two experiments described above, subjects are then asked to report their stated preference for various policy responses to declining fossil-fuel revenue in their state.
Experimental design
For Experiment 1, treatments include i) baseline information about Laramie, WY., ii) information about high quality public goods in Laramie, iii) information about the low-tax climate in Laramie, iv) information about natural amenities in Laramie, or v) all of the above. Subjects are then asked to state their willingness to move to Laramie and their expected life satisfaction associated with living there.
Experiment 2 allows us to answer three main questions:
Q1: Do people respond more strongly to the implementation of a tax as opposed to an increase in an existing one
a. We will do this by comparing stated willingness to move (and expected life satisfaction) among subjects assigned to the “income tax raise” treatment to those in the “income tax implement” treatment. We will also estimate whether the effect of tax implementation is more significant among people who live in an oil-rich state without an income tax (Wyoming, Texas, and Alaska).
b. We will also explore whether people are more opposed to an income tax (regardless of whether it is framed as being “implemented” or “raised”) among people in states without an income tax (Wyoming, Texas, and Alaska) compared to oil-rich states with an income tax.
Test 2: Which type of tax do people prefer?
a. We will test whether people have preferences over how they “lose” $1,000. We do this by testing people’s responses (willingness to move and expected life satisfaction) to three informational treatments: a) a hypothetical situation in which they pay $1,000 more in income tax, b) they pay $1,000 more in sales tax, and c) they lose $1,000 from a wage cut (all as a result of declining fossil-fuel revenue).
b. We will also test whether people have heterogeneous preferences over different types of taxes and/or spending cuts:
a. Income tax increase
b. Sales tax increase
c. Education spending cut
d. Health spending cut
Q3: Do people respond differently to taxes if they are framed as being in response to a negative oil shock?
a. We will compare responses (stated willingness to move and stated life satisfaction) among subjects who are assigned to tax increase treatments that are framed as being in response to a negative energy shock to those among people who are assigned to tax increase treatments that are not framed as being in response to a negative energy shock.
Finally, we will explore people’s preferences for different fiscal responses to negative energy shocks using a within-subject design in which we simply ask people to choose their preferred response. Here, we will explore peoples preferences again based on political ideology, income, and education level.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.