Equality of Opportunity and Preferences for Redistribution
How to cite
Nuutinen, Juho. 2026. "Equality of Opportunity and Preferences for Redistribution." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018070. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18070-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A prominent stylized fact in contemporary inequality research is that countries with greater inequality of incomes also tend to be countries in which family background plays a stronger role in determining the adult outcomes of young people. This association is commonly referred to as The Great Gatsby Curve. In my research, I examine individuals' fairness views regarding equality of opportunity and intergenerational inequality in a controlled and incentivized experimental framework. More specifically, the empirical approach is the setting where participants act as impartial third-party spectators and make real redistribution decisions on initial allocations. Main research questions are as follows: First, do differences in parental merit justify unequal opportunities for the children? Second, assuming that equality of opportunity is causally connected to the level of cross-sectional inequality, how do individuals weigh the two potentially different fairness judgements concerning the two generations?
Intervention
Participants assigned the role of impartial third-party spectators are presented with a real redistribution decision involving workers and their adult children. Across treatment conditions, the redistribution decision concerns either parents' earnings or the children's playing field, or both (in the two so-called Gatsby treatments). Pre-redistribution inequality is varied by describing the initial allocations as resulting from luck (lottery) or merit (productivity in the assignment).
Experimental design
This is an online, individual-level randomized experiment conducted on Prolific. Participants are randomly assigned to one of six treatment conditions in a between-subjects design. After consent and instructions, participants complete the allocation task and will be asked post-experiment questions, including a few demographic questions. The target sample is 2400 participants, with approximately 400 in each treatment condition.
The parents and their adult children who solely have the role of incentivizing the spectators' redistribution decisions are the workers in the experiment. The worker-part of the experiment is also conducted online. The target is 168 parents and their 168 adult children via The Helsinki Laboratory for Behavioral and Experimental Studies (Helsinki LABBET). This would mean that each spectator decision is implemented with a probability of approximately 1/19.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.