Belief Repair After Neglected Events

How to cite

Vizard, Nicholas; Bossaerts, Peter. 2026. "Belief Repair After Neglected Events." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018058. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18058-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nicholas Vizard* , Peter Bossaerts

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018058
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18058-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-09 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D81, D83, D84
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18058

Abstract

This study examines belief updating when later clarifying information changes how earlier evidence should be interpreted. We study whether participants revise beliefs by reprocessing earlier evidence or instead update only from their current beliefs once the clarification is received.

In an incentivized in-person laboratory experiment, participants complete two individual computer-based tasks at separate computers with no interaction across participants. In Task 1, participants observe a scripted sequence of diagnostic information and report beliefs immediately before and after two pre-specified changes in how the possible states are described. Participants are individually randomized by computer token to one of two arms that determine whether the informative change occurs at the first or second of these moments. In Task 2, participants complete a scripted belief-updating task and later receive clarifying information that changes how earlier observations should be interpreted.

The main outcomes are immediate participant-level changes in elicited beliefs at the key refinement or clarification moment in each task. Eligible participants are members of the Cambridge Judge Business School participant pool with native-level English proficiency, age 60 or below, and eligibility for in-person laboratory sessions. The main confirmatory study targets 80 usable participants. Recruitment will continue until ~80 participants have usable data for the main confirmatory outcome measures or until a maximum of 120 participants have been recruited, whichever comes first. Seventeen pilot participants were run before this registration for calibration and design refinement. No changes were made to the experimental design after these pilots. Due to the nature of the experiment, some protocol details are withheld from public fields during data collection to avoid influencing prospective participants; full pre-registered details are recorded in hidden registry fields and a private analysis plan.

Intervention

This study uses two individual computer-based belief-updating tasks for adult members of the Cambridge Judge Business School participant pool who are eligible for in-person laboratory sessions. Across both tasks, participants observe information, report beliefs, and later receive clarifying information that may change how earlier information should be interpreted. The purpose of the study is to measure how people revise beliefs when later clarification affects the interpretation of earlier evidence.

Experimental design

This is an in-person laboratory experiment in which participants complete two individual tasks at separate computers with no interaction across participants. One task includes individual random assignment to one of two arms that determine the order in which an informative change versus a non-informative change occurs. The other task uses a common scripted design for all participants. The main confirmatory analyses use participant-level immediate belief changes at pre-specified moments. Eligible participants are members of the Cambridge Judge Business School participant pool with native-level English proficiency, age 60 or below, and eligibility for in-person laboratory sessions. Recruitment will continue until 80 participants with usable confirmatory outcome data are obtained or until a maximum of 120 participants is enrolled.

Design details

Randomization method
At the start of Task 1, each participant is randomly assigned to a workstation/computer token from a shuffled set. Each token is pre-linked to arm O1 or O2 according to a computer-generated 1:1 allocation list. This implements individual-level random assignment to O1 versus O2. There is no session-level treatment assignment and no manual reassignment after the token draw. Task 2 has no separate treatment-arm randomization because all participants complete the same scripted design.
Randomization unit
Individual participant. In Task 1, assignment to O1 versus O2 occurs through random assignment to a pre-coded workstation/computer token. Task 2 has no separate randomized arms.
Clusters
Individual participants. Target usable sample: 80 individuals. Maximum enrolled sample: 120 individuals.
Observations
Maximum 120 enrolled participants across all arms. Recruitment stops when 80 participants have usable confirmatory outcome data or when the cap of 120 enrolled participants is reached, whichever comes first
Arms
Task 1 has two arms with approximately 1:1 allocation. Target usable sample: approximately 40 participants in O1 and 40 participants in O2. Maximum enrolled sample: approximately 60 participants in O1 and 60 participants in O2, subject to minor imbalance from random assignment. Task 2 is completed by all enrolled participants and has no additional randomized arms.
Primary outcomes
Task 1 primary confirmatory endpoint: difference between the subtype share assigned after the informative refinement to a pre-registered subtype of interest and the analogous subtype share assigned after the relabel-only refinement to a pre-registered comparison subtype. Task 2 co-primary confirmatory endpoint 1: immediate change in the reported probability assigned to the lowest state in Task 2 between the last report before clarification and the first report after clarification. Task 2 co-primary confirmatory endpoint 2: immediate change in the reported probability assigned to the highest state in Task 2 between the last report before clarification and the first report after clarification.
Secondary outcomes
Task 1 secondary inferential endpoint: difference between the immediate drop in belief in the parent condition at the informative refinement and the corresponding drop at the relabel-only refinement. Task 1 secondary descriptive endpoint: difference between the absolute distance from an even split across the two newly revealed subtypes at the informative refinement and the corresponding absolute distance at the relabel-only refinement. Task 1 secondary descriptive endpoint: difference between the absolute change in belief in the parent condition at the informative refinement and the corresponding absolute change at the relabel-only refinement. Task 2 secondary inferential endpoint: immediate drop in the expected value of the ordered state in Task 2 between the last report before clarification and the first report after clarification. Task 2 secondary descriptive endpoint: total immediate belief-reallocation magnitude at the clarification moment.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords