Expectations, Shocks, and Climate Adaptation: Evidence from a Rainfall Beliefs Experiment in Eastern Uganda

How to cite

Hees, Marius; Oort, Frank van. 2026. "Expectations, Shocks, and Climate Adaptation: Evidence from a Rainfall Beliefs Experiment in Eastern Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018045. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18045-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Marius Hees* , Frank van Oort

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018045
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18045-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-09 – 2026-03-23
Countries
Uganda (Eastern Uganda (Districts: Bugiri, Butaleja, Mayuge))
JEL codes
C93, D84, D83, Q54, Q12, O13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18045

Abstract

In rainfed agriculture, economic losses arise not only from adverse weather but from inaccurate weather expectations. This study examines how smallholder farmers in eastern Uganda recall past rainfall, form expectations about upcoming rainfall, and adjust their production decisions in response to localized historical information. Using experimental variation in village-level access to localized rainfall histories and satellite-based vegetation measures, we test how information shapes expectations and how expectations influence agricultural outcomes.

We introduce and test the concept of belief-relative shocks, deviations between expected and realized rainfall, as a more accurate predictor of agricultural performance than conventional anomalies based on historical averages. The study contributes both a behavioral framework for measuring climate shocks and direct empirical evidence on belief formation, updating, and forecast accuracy in a low-income agricultural setting.

Intervention

This study provides smallholder farmers in eastern Uganda with localized historical rainfall information immediately before the main planting season. Farmers in treated villages receive a laminated one-page card specific to their village, containing two elements.

The first is a rainfall calendar showing dekad-level (10-day period) rainfall classifications across the past five growing seasons (2021–2025). Rainfall in each period is classified as none or little, medium, or significant, relative to a 25-year historical baseline (2001–2025) derived from satellite rainfall data (CHIRPS). The calendar uses a simple water-droplet icon system (one, two, or three droplets) to make the information accessible to participants with limited formal education.

The second is a harvest outcome overview showing satellite-derived vegetation conditions (EVI2 from Sentinel-2) for each of the past five seasons, paired with a visual image of the corresponding rainfall condition and a written description of harvest outcomes in both absolute and relative terms.
The information cards are village-specific, generated from satellite data at the parish level, and produced before fieldwork begins. Enumerators present the card after the participant has completed a memory recall exercise and pre-season expectations elicitation. Enumerators answer clarifying questions but provide no interpretation, advice, or recommendations. The visual language of the card is consistent with the token-based belief elicitation tasks used in the survey.

The study also includes a third arm in which a subset of villages receives the information card before any expectation elicitation, to identify anchoring effects separately from belief updating.

Experimental design

This is a village-randomized field experiment with three arms implemented immediately before the main agricultural planting season in three Ugandan Districts (Bugiri, Butaleja and Mayuge), in eastern Uganda, west of Mt. Elgon. Sixty villages are randomly assigned to one of three groups: a control group (Group A, 24 villages), an information treatment group (Group B, 26 villages), and a robustness arm (Group C, 10 villages).

All participating farmers complete a survey covering farming background, memory of past rainfall conditions, expectations about the upcoming season, social networks, and planned agricultural adaptations. Rainfall expectations are elicited using a visual token allocation method in which respondents distribute 10 tokens across nine images depicting rainfall conditions from extreme drought to severe flooding. A separate token task elicits beliefs about the timing of rainfall onset. Both tasks are completed for each of the past five seasons (memory recall) and for the upcoming season (expectations).

Farmers in Groups B and C additionally receive a laminated information card specific to their village, showing historical rainfall patterns and satellite-derived vegetation outcomes for the past five growing seasons. Group B receives the card between two rounds of expectation elicitation, allowing measurement of within-person belief updating. Group C receives the card before any expectation elicitation, providing a robustness check on how objective historical information anchors first-stated beliefs.

Randomization is conducted at the village level using matched-pair rerandomization, stratified by subcounty and elevation, with pairs matched on elevation and satellite-derived vegetation indices.

Agricultural outcomes are measured at the end of the 2026 growing season using Sentinel-2 satellite imagery at respondent farm coordinates. The primary outcome is end-of-season vegetative performance (EVI2), standardized within village.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted in the office by computer prior to the start of fieldwork, using a pre-registered R script (02_randomize_villages.R) with a fixed random seed. The procedure implements matched-pair rerandomization following Bruhn & McKenzie (2009) and Imai, King & Nall (2009). Villages were first stratified into strata defined by subcounty × elevation tercile. Within each stratum, villages were matched into pairs using Mahalanobis distance on standardized elevation and satellite-derived peak vegetation index (EVI). Within each matched pair, one village was randomly assigned to Group A (control) and one to Group B (treatment) by computer coin flip. Ten pairs were randomly designated as donor pairs for Group C; within each donor pair one village was randomly assigned to Group C and the remaining village was randomly assigned to Group A or Group B by coin flip. The assignment was rerandomized if the balance criterion was not met — requiring all pairwise standardized differences for the A-B comparison to be below 0.10 and all comparisons involving Group C to be below 0.25. Starting from seed 123, balance was achieved at seed 966 after 844 draws. The full randomization log recording all 844 failed draws, the final assignment, and the balance table is attached to this pre-registration as a permanent audit trail. No field personnel or participants were involved in the randomization process. Treatment assignments were communicated to enumerators only through the pre-organized folder structure of village-specific materials, which makes arm membership explicit without disclosing the study hypotheses.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the village. All farmers surveyed within a village receive the same treatment assignment. There is only one level of randomization in this study; no individual-level or household-level randomization is applied within villages. Villages are nested within parishes, parishes within subcounties, and subcounties within Bulambuli District. Randomization is conducted at the village level but stratified at the subcounty × elevation tercile level to ensure balance across administrative and climatic dimensions. The information treatment is delivered at the village level via village-specific laminated cards; individual survey responses are the unit of observation and analysis. The choice of village-level randomization reflects two design considerations. First, the information treatment is inherently social; farmers in the same village share a common rainfall history and observe each other's planting behavior, making individual-level randomization within villages both operationally infeasible and likely to generate strong spillovers. Second, the primary agronomic outcome (end-of-season EVI2) is measured at farm coordinates via satellite and varies at the individual level within villages, allowing within-village variation in outcomes to be used for precision gains even though treatment is assigned at the village level. Standard errors are clustered at the village level in all primary specifications, consistent with the unit of randomization.
Clusters
60 villages
Observations
600 to 800 farmers (10 to 15 per village across 60 villages)
Arms
24 villages control (Group A), 26 villages information treatment (Group B), 10 villages anchoring robustness (Group C)
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is end-of-season vegetative performance at respondent farm coordinates, measured by the EVI2 composite (Enhanced Vegetation Index 2) derived from Sentinel-2 L2A satellite imagery at 10m resolution. The outcome is standardized as a within-village z-score using the 2021–2025 distribution. The primary estimand is the intention-to-treat effect of village-level information provision (Group B vs. Group A) on this standardized outcome. Three pre-declared outcome families are tested with Romano-Wolf stepdown correction: Family 1 — Agronomic Performance: EVI2 (primary), NDVI (secondary), Sentinel-1 SAR VH-VV ratio in dB (cloud-robust secondary). Decision rule: the treatment is deemed economically meaningful if at least one optical outcome shows an effect of -0.15 SD or larger with Romano-Wolf adjusted q ≤ 0.10, and the SAR outcome shows a concordant sign with unadjusted p ≤ 0.10. Family 2 — Belief Precision: Negative log probability score, ranked probability score, and Shannon entropy of post-information beliefs. These capture whether the information treatment improves forecast accuracy and reduces belief uncertainty. Family 3 — Belief-Relative Shock: The surprise measure S_i = 1 - F_i(k_i^R), where F_i is the farmer's pre-season cumulative belief distribution and k_i^R is the realized rainfall category. This tests whether expectation-relative deviations predict agronomic outcomes better than conventional rainfall anomalies from historical means. Secondary outcomes include planting timeliness (indicator for planting within the optimal onset window), the greenness integral from onset to onset + 90 days, and the onset-to-peak timeliness index.
Secondary outcomes
The survey collects a rich set of secondary variables that will be used both as controls in primary specifications and as outcomes in exploratory analyses examining the determinants of memory formation, belief accuracy, expectation updating, and adaptive behavior. These include: Demographic and household characteristics: age, gender, household size, years of farming experience, education level, land area cultivated, primary and secondary crops grown, asset ownership. Information environment: access to weather forecasts from extension services, radio, or mobile phone; frequency of receiving agricultural advice; social network size and composition; whether the respondent discusses weather expectations with neighbors or family before planting. Memory quality and salience: individual memory divergence (D_i) for each of the five recalled seasons; self-reported memorable weather events (drought, flood, late onset, early cessation); reported crop losses in past seasons; consistency between recalled distributions and reported memorable events. Belief characteristics: pre-information belief mean, variance, entropy, and skewness over the nine rainfall categories; onset timing belief mean and spread; pre-information confidence rating (1–5 scale); extreme weather expectation indicators (drought, flood, other). Belief updating: change in belief mean, variance, entropy, and skewness between Round 1 and Round 2 (Groups A and B); stated adjustment indicator (whether respondent reports wishing to update after seeing information); post-information confidence rating. Adaptation plans: whether any adaptation is planned for the upcoming season; type of adaptation (crop switching, input adjustment, planting timing, water management, other); estimated cost of planned adaptations; whether information receipt changes stated adaptation plans and estimated cost. Social and network outcomes: number of people respondent expects to share weather information with; whether respondent intends to show or describe the information card to others; trust in official weather information sources. Decision-making: primary and secondary decision-makers for farming choices; whether decisions are made individually or jointly; degree of autonomy in input purchases.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords