Understanding the Barriers to Promotion for Factory Workers

How to cite

Lin, Wei; Chen, Zixu; Chen, Ziyue. 2026. "Understanding the Barriers to Promotion for Factory Workers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018044. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18044-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Wei Lin* , Zixu Chen , Ziyue Chen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018044
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18044-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-13 – 2027-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D83, D91, J24, M51, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18044

Abstract

Why do workers decline promotion opportunities even when advancement is feasible and associated with higher pay? This study investigates supply-side barriers to promotion by examining whether workers' willingness to accept leadership roles is limited by underestimation of the on-the-job learning due to their low current interpersonal skills. Motivated by our survey results of factory workers, we conduct a two-stage randomized controlled trial with vocational students and factory workers. Students are organized into three-person production teams that complete a sequence of manufacturing tasks designed to simulate a factory production environment. The experiment consists of two production rounds with opportunities to choose or accept a leadership role. The design introduces three sources of randomized variation. First, participants are randomly assigned to the leadership role in the initial production round, generating exogenous leadership experience. Second, teams are randomized to environments that vary the difficulty of the leadership task, implemented through production shocks that require groups to adjust their production plan. Third, an information intervention is delivered between production rounds to a subset of participants. The intervention aims to address potential projection bias by providing information about learning-by-doing in leadership roles through a short video in which experienced leaders share their past experiences. In the factory setting, a similar video-based information intervention is integrated into the promotion process. The primary outcomes include participants’ willingness to take leadership roles in subsequent production rounds. By experimentally varying both leadership exposure and information about skill acquisition, the study seeks to assess whether underestimation of on-the-job learning represent important frictions that discourage workers from pursuing internal promotion opportunities.

Intervention

The study involves two distinct field experiments designed to simulate and analyze internal labor market dynamics and promotion decisions.

1. Vocational Student Experiment (Lab-in-the-Field): The study utilizes a factory simulation experiment involving the production of bracelets to investigate supply-side barriers to promotion. The experiment is divided into two 3-hour production rounds (Round 1 and Round 2). Participants are organized into three-person teams consisting of one manager (Leader) and two workers (Members).

The study includes three layers of randomized intervention:
1.1 Exogenous Leadership Exposure: In Round 1, participants are randomly assigned to the role of Leader or Member to generate variation in leadership experience.

1.2 Task Difficulty (Production Shocks): Teams are randomized into different production environments characterized by varying levels of difficulty. This is implemented through "production shocks" where the required bracelet patterns and material inputs are changed during the production process, requiring the Leader to coordinate the team, calculate new material needs, and manage the transition.

1.3 Information Intervention: Between Round 1 and Round 2, a subset of participants (specifically those who were Members in Round 1) are randomly assigned to receive an information intervention. This consists of a video designed to address "projection bias" regarding skill acquisition.

2. Factory Worker Experiment (Field): In a partner manufacturing firm, current employees are provided with opportunities to apply for internal promotion to leadership positions. A subset of these employees is randomly selected to receive an informational video intervention similar to the student experiment, integrated into the standard internal recruitment process.

Experimental design

The study is a two-stage Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT).
1. Vocational Student Experiment (Lab-in-the-Field)
1.1 Stage 1: Participants are randomly assigned to roles (Leader vs. Member) and teams are randomly assigned to production difficulty levels (Plan 1 vs. Plan 2).
Interim Stage: Participants who were Members in Stage 1 are randomized into an Information Treatment group (Video) or a Control group (No Video).

1.2. Stage 2: Participants indicate their willingness to be Leaders. Roles are assigned based on these preferences (with random tie-breaking). Production continues.

2. Factory Worker Experiment (Field): In a partner manufacturing firm, current employees are provided with opportunities to apply for internal promotion to leadership positions. A subset of these employees is randomly selected to receive an informational video intervention similar to the student experiment, integrated into the standard internal recruitment process.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual and team-level.
Clusters
400 vocational students and 300 factory general workers.
Observations
400 vocational students and 300 factory general workers.
Arms
1. Vocational students (400 students) Total Participants: 90 to 120 participants in each panel, four panels in total. Total Teams (Clusters): 30-40 teams (3 participants per team). Arms Breakdown in each panel (Approximate): Leadership Experience (Round 1): 40 Leaders / 80 Members. Production Difficulty: ~20 Teams in Plan 1 / ~20 Teams in Plan 2. Information Intervention: Of the 80 Round 1 Members, approximately 40 are assigned to the Video Treatment and 40 to the Control. 2. Factory general workers (300 students) A subset of these employees is randomly selected to receive an informational video intervention similar to the student experiment, integrated into the standard internal recruitment process.
Primary outcomes
Willingness to accept a leadership role in Round 2.
Secondary outcomes
1. Self-assessed leadership ability (Beliefs). 2. Predicted rate of learning (Projection Bias). 3. Team Production Performance. 4. Leadership Behavior / Task Execution.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords