This study investigates whether deterrence messages and social norm messages are complementary or substitutes in generating voluntary tax compliance among firms. Phase 1 employs a 2×2 factorial experimental design involving firms that failed to file their 2024 Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) declarations in Medellín, Colombia. Using stratified randomization by firm size, sector, and location, firms are assigned to four groups receiving: (1) a neutral reminder (control), (2) deterrence-only message highlighting penalties and enforcement, (3) social norm-only message emphasizing peer compliance rates, or (4) a combined deterrence and social norm message. The primary research question tests whether these mechanisms exhibit complementarity (combined effect exceeds sum of individual effects) or crowding-out (combined effect is less than sum of individual effects), and whether this interaction varies by firm size. Phase 2 (June–December 2026) is an observational follow-up tracking firms that failed to file their ICA declaration during Phase 1 (expected ~3,800 firms, assuming 2-5% voluntary compliance rate) to explore whether prior message exposure affects responses to subsequent formal enforcement notices (emplazamientos) sent according to the Tax Authority's standard prioritization procedures. The study period extends from April 2026 through December 2026, enabling assessment of both immediate voluntary compliance effects and long-term behavioral persistence.
Intervention
Firms receive official letters from the Secretaría de Hacienda de Medellín reminding them of their obligation to file their 2024 Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) declaration. Letters vary in content across four groups: (1) neutral reminder (control), (2) deterrence message highlighting penalties and enforcement, (3) social norm message emphasizing peer compliance rates, and (4) combined deterrence and social norm message.
Due to administrative and operational considerations in identifying eligible non-filers, the study is implemented in two phases:
Phase 1 (May 2026): n≈1,000 firms. Messages sent May 5, 2026 via email and certified mail, with a 15-day deadline to file voluntarily.
Phase 2 (July-August 2026): Approximately 6,000 additional firms receive messages using identical protocols.
All messages are official communications from the Tax Authority. Outcomes measured at 90 days post-intervention from administrative records.
Experimental design
Design: 2×2 factorial randomized controlled trial testing two behavioral mechanisms in tax compliance messaging
Sample: Firms in Medellín, Colombia that failed to file their 2024 Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) declaration. Implementation in two phases due to administrative process of identifying eligible non-filers on a rolling basis: - Phase 1 (May 2026): n≈1,000 firms - Phase 2 (July-August 2026): n≈6,000 firms - Total: ≈7,000 firms
Randomization: Stratified random assignment by taxpayer type (2 categories) × sector (4 categories) × firm size (4 quartiles) × firm age (4 groups). Each phase uses independent randomization. Firms are randomly assigned with equal probability to one of four groups within strata.
Treatment Arms: - Group 1: Control message (neutral reminder) - Group 2: Treatment A - Group 3: Treatment B - Group 4: Treatment A + Treatment B (combined)
Intervention Timing: - Phase 1: Messages sent May 5, 2026 - Phase 2: Messages sent July-August 2026 All messages sent via email and certified mail from Secretaría de Hacienda de Medellín. Firms receive a 15-day deadline to file voluntarily.
Primary Outcome Measurement: Tax filing and payment behavior measured at 90 days post-intervention using Tax Authority administrative records
Follow-up Period: Observational follow-up (through December 2026) tracks firms that did not file during the initial 90-day window. This phase analyzes responses to the Tax Authority's standard enforcement procedures using propensity score matching (non-experimental).
Analysis: Primary analysis pools both phases with phase fixed effects, comparing filing and payment rates across the four groups using ordinary least squares regression with stratification controls. The factorial design enables estimation of main effects for Treatment A and Treatment B, as well as their interaction effect to test for complementarity or substitution.
Statistical Power: - Phase 1 only (n≈1,000): Main effects MDE ≈2.5pp, Interaction MDE ≈3.5pp - Both phases combined (n≈7,000): Main effects MDE ≈1.1pp, Interaction MDE ≈1.5pp Calculations assume baseline filing rate of 3-5% and α=0.05 (two-tailed).
Design details
Randomization method
Method: Computerized stratified block randomization conducted by the Secretaría
de Hacienda de Medellín using R statistical software
Procedure:
The Tax Authority uses a random number generator to assign firms to treatment
groups. Randomization is conducted on the message deployment date using the
following steps:
1. Stratification: Firms are sorted into strata based on:
- Taxpayer type (2 categories: natural person vs. legal entity)
- Economic sector (4 categories: construction, restaurants, tourism/RNT,
financial services)
- Firm size (4 quartiles based on log of taxable base)
- Firm age (4 groups: pre-2000, 2000-2009, 2010-2019, 2020 onwards)
2. Block randomization within strata: Within each stratum, firms are randomly
assigned to one of four groups (1=Control, 2=Social Norm, 3=Deterrence,
4=Combined) with equal probability using computer-generated random numbers
3. Implementation: The Tax Authority executes the randomization algorithm and
generates the treatment assignment list. Each firm receives a unique treatment
code determining which message variant they receive.
4. Documentation: The randomization seed and complete assignment list are stored
securely by the Tax Authority. Researchers receive only anonymized data with
treatment codes (no firm identifiers).
Fixed Seeds (for reproducibility):
- Phase 1 (May 2026): seed = 12345
- Phase 2 (July-August 2026): seed = 123452
Timing: Randomization occurs on the same day as message dispatch to minimize
time between assignment and treatment delivery.
Unit of randomization: Individual firm (identified by NIT - Número de
Identificación Tributaria)
Level: Firm-level randomization. Each firm is independently assigned to one of
the four treatment groups within its stratum. There is no group-level or
cluster-level randomization. Each firm is randomized individually, even if
multiple firms share the same address, ownership, or accountant.
Stratification note: While randomization occurs at the firm level, it is
stratified by firm characteristics to ensure balance across groups. Stratification
does not constitute a separate level of randomization—all randomization occurs
at the individual firm level within strata.
Unit of analysis: Matches unit of randomization (firm-level). All outcome
measures (filing, payment) are recorded at the firm level from administrative
records.
Phase 2 exclusions: Firms assigned in Phase 1 are explicitly excluded from
Phase 2 randomization to prevent double-treatment. This is implemented by
filtering the Phase 1 firm list (by NIT) from the Phase 2 eligible population
before randomization.
Quality checks: After randomization, balance checks verify that observable
characteristics (firm size, sector, taxpayer type, age, prior compliance history,
debt amounts) are statistically similar across the four treatment groups.
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization: Individual firm (identified by NIT - Número de
Identificación Tributaria)
Level: Firm-level randomization. Each firm is independently assigned to one
of the four treatment groups within its stratum.
No cluster randomization: There is no group-level or cluster-level randomization.
Each firm is randomized individually, even if multiple firms share the same
address, ownership, or accountant.
Stratification: While randomization occurs at the firm level, it is stratified
by firm characteristics (taxpayer type × sector × firm size × firm age) to
ensure balance across groups. Stratification does not constitute a separate
level of randomization—all randomization occurs at the individual firm level
within strata.
Unit of analysis: Matches unit of randomization (firm-level). All outcome
measures (filing, payment) are recorded at the firm level from administrative
records.
Clusters
Not applicable - no cluster randomization.
Randomization occurs at the individual firm level. Total sample: ≈7,000 firms
across two phases.
Observations
≈7,000 firms across two phases (≈1,750 firms per treatment group)
Arms
Total: ≈7,000 firms
- Phase 1 (May 2026): ≈1,000 firms
- Phase 2 (July-August 2026): ≈6,000 firms
By treatment group (expected):
- Group 1 (Control): ≈1,750 firms
- Group 2 (Treatment A): ≈1,750 firms
- Group 3 (Treatment B): ≈1,750 firms
- Group 4 (Combined): ≈1,750 firms
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcome 1: Tax Filing (Binary)
Definition: Whether the firm filed its 2024 Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) declaration within 90 days of receiving the Phase 1 treatment letter (April 16 - June 7, 2026)
Measurement: Binary indicator (1 = filed, 0 = not filed) extracted from Tax Authority administrative records
Timeline: Measured on June 1, 2026
Primary Outcome 2: Days to Filing (Continuous)
Definition: Number of calendar days between April 16, 2026 (treatment letter sent) and the date the firm filed its ICA declaration
Measurement: Continuous variable (0-90 days) for firms that filed; censored at 90 days for non-filers
Source: Tax Authority filing timestamp data
Primary Outcome 3: Tax Payment (Binary)
Definition: Whether the firm paid its self-declared 2024 ICA tax liability within 90 days of receiving the treatment letter
Measurement: Binary indicator (1 = paid, 0 = not paid) from Tax Authority payment records
Timeline: Measured on June 1, 2026
Primary Outcome 4: Amount Paid (Continuous)
Definition: Total amount (Colombian Pesos) of 2024 ICA tax paid by the firm within the 90-day window
Measurement: Continuous variable (COP) from Tax Authority payment records
Note: Zero for firms that did not pay
All primary outcomes are measured at the firm level using administrative data from the Secretaría de Hacienda de Medellín. The 90-day window (April 16 - June 7, 2026) corresponds to Phase 1 voluntary compliance period before enforcement actions begin.
Secondary outcomes
Phase 1 Secondary Outcomes (Voluntary Compliance Period):
1. Filing Within 15 Days (Binary)
Definition: Whether firm filed within the initial 15-day deadline stated in the letter (April 16- May 1, 2026)
Measurement: Binary indicator from administrative records
Purpose: Test responsiveness to explicit deadline
2. Tax Base Declared (Continuous)
Definition: Self-reported tax base (gross revenue subject to ICA) in Colombian Pesos
Measurement: Extracted from filed declaration form
Note: Only observable for firms that filed
3. Tax Liability Declared (Continuous)
Definition: Self-calculated ICA tax owed based on declared tax base and applicable rate
Measurement: From filed declaration (COP)
Purpose: Assess whether messages affect reporting accuracy
4. Partial vs. Full Payment (Categorical)
Definition: Payment status categorized as: (0) No payment, (1) Partial payment (<100% of declared liability), (2) Full payment (≥100% of declared liability)
Measurement: Ratio of amount paid to tax liability declared
Phase 2 Secondary Outcomes (Enforcement Response - Exploratory):
5. Filing After Enforcement Notice (Binary)
Definition: Whether firm filed within 30 days of receiving emplazamiento (enforcement notice)
Measurement: Binary indicator for firms that received enforcement
Note: Conditional on non-random enforcement assignment; analyzed with propensity score matching
6. Payment After Enforcement (Binary)
Definition: Whether firm paid within 30 days of receiving emplazamiento
Measurement: Binary indicator from payment records
7. Long-term Compliance Persistence (Binary)
Definition: Whether firm filed AND paid during September-December 2026 follow-up period (delayed compliance)
Measurement: Binary indicator for firms that did not comply in Phase 1 or Phase 2 enforcement window
Purpose: Assess treatment effect persistence beyond immediate response
8. Email Engagement (Binary)
Definition: Whether firm opened the treatment email (if tracking data available)
Measurement: Email open rate from delivery system logs
Purpose: Mechanism check for message delivery
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.