Compensating Wage Differentials for Living in Sardinia.

How to cite

Angei, Fabio; Nieddu, Marco. 2026. "Compensating Wage Differentials for Living in Sardinia.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018037. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18037-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Fabio Angei* , Marco Nieddu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018037
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18037-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-10 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18037

Abstract

This study examines how much people value living and working in Sardinia, and whether better local conditions can make Sardinia more attractive as a place to live and work. The focus is on choices related to migration, return migration, and job location, in a context where geographic distance and access to services may influence where people want to settle.

The study is conducted through an online survey. Participants are presented with hypothetical job opportunities that differ in location and salary and are asked to choose between them. The comparison depends on where the respondent currently lives: for those living outside Sardinia, the alternative job is in Sardinia; for those living in Sardinia, the alternative job is outside Sardinia. Across a sequence of choices, the salary attached to the alternative location is adjusted in order to identify the salary difference required for respondents to prefer one location over the other.

All respondents first complete a baseline set of job-choice scenarios. They are then assigned to an additional set of scenarios. In most cases, the Sardinian option is paired with one of three pre-specified policy improvements: better connections with more frequent flights and lower fares to and from Sardinia, shorter waiting times for specialist visits and diagnostic exams, or a program facilitating the job relocation of a partner when moving to Sardinia. In a smaller share of cases, respondents complete additional scenarios without these improvements, as a placebo. The study uses these choices to estimate willingness to live and work in Sardinia and to assess whether better institutional and service conditions can increase its attractiveness.

Intervention

Participants complete an online survey in which they evaluate hypothetical job opportunities that differ in location and salary. In each scenario, respondents choose between two job offers: one corresponding to their current or baseline location and another located in an alternative region.

The comparison depends on the respondent’s current place of residence. For individuals living outside Sardinia, the alternative job is located in Sardinia. For individuals living in Sardinia, the alternative job is located outside Sardinia. The salary associated with the alternative job is adjusted across a sequence of choices in order to identify the salary differential required for the respondent to prefer one location over the other.

After completing an initial baseline set of job-choice scenarios, respondents are randomly assigned to an additional condition. In most cases, the job opportunity located in Sardinia is described together with one of three pre-specified institutional improvements that could make living and working in Sardinia more attractive: better air connections with more frequent flights and lower fares to and from Sardinia; shorter waiting times for specialist visits and diagnostic exams; or a program facilitating the job relocation of a partner when moving to Sardinia.

In a smaller share of cases, as a placebo, respondents instead complete additional scenarios without institutional improvements. This placebo condition allows the study to distinguish the effect of institutional improvements from the effect of receiving additional information or completing additional choice tasks.

By comparing responses across baseline, policy, and placebo scenarios, the study estimates individuals’ willingness to live and work in Sardinia and how this willingness changes when institutional and service conditions improve.

Experimental design

The study is implemented as an online survey experiment based on repeated hypothetical job-choice scenarios. Participants are asked to choose between two job offers that differ in location and net monthly salary. One option corresponds to the respondent’s current or baseline location, while the other corresponds to an alternative location drawn from a pre-defined set conditional on the respondent’s current place of residence.

For respondents living outside Sardinia, the alternative job is located in Sardinia. For respondents living in Sardinia, the alternative job is located outside Sardinia. Across a sequence of binary choices, the salary associated with the alternative location is adjusted in order to identify the salary differential required for the respondent to prefer one location over the other.

All respondents first complete a baseline set of job-choice scenarios. After the baseline module, respondents are randomly assigned at the individual level to one additional module. In most cases, respondents are assigned to a policy condition in which the Sardinian option is paired with one of three pre-specified institutional improvements: better air connections with more frequent flights and lower fares to and from Sardinia; shorter waiting times for specialist visits and diagnostic exams; or a program facilitating the job relocation of a partner when moving to Sardinia. In a smaller share of cases, respondents are assigned to a placebo condition in which they complete an additional sequence of scenarios without institutional improvements.

The design allows us to estimate the compensating wage differential associated with choosing Sardinia relative to an alternative location under baseline conditions and to assess how this differential changes when institutional and service conditions improve.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented automatically within the online survey platform (Qualtrics) using the platform’s built-in randomization tools combined with embedded JavaScript. Respondents are randomly assigned at the individual level to the experimental conditions by the survey software at the moment they reach the relevant block in the survey flow. After completing the baseline elicitation module, the survey platform randomly assigns respondents to one additional module. In approximately 80 percent of cases respondents are assigned to a policy scenario, while in approximately 20 percent of cases they are assigned to a placebo scenario. Within the policy condition, the specific institutional improvement attached to the Sardinian option is randomly drawn from a predefined set of policy interventions.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual respondent. Randomization occurs at the respondent level within the online survey platform. After completing the baseline elicitation module, each respondent is individually assigned by the survey software to one additional experimental module. In approximately 80 percent of cases respondents are assigned to the policy condition, while in approximately 20 percent of cases they are assigned to the placebo condition. Within the policy condition, the specific institutional improvement attached to the Sardinian job offer is also randomly assigned at the individual level. No clustering or group-level randomization is used in the experiment.
Clusters
3.000
Observations
3.000
Arms
All respondents complete the baseline elicitation module. After the baseline module, respondents are randomly assigned at the individual level to one additional module. Approximately 80 percent of respondents will be assigned to the policy condition, in which the Sardinian job option is paired with a randomly assigned institutional improvement. Approximately 20 percent of respondents will be assigned to the placebo condition, in which respondents complete an additional elicitation sequence without institutional improvements. Randomization occurs at the individual level, and the design is not clustered.
Primary outcomes
Baseline willingness to pay (WTP) for Sardinia The compensating wage differential required for a respondent to choose a job located in Sardinia relative to an alternative location in the baseline job-choice scenarios. Policy willingness to pay (WTP) for Sardinia The compensating wage differential required for a respondent to choose a job located in Sardinia relative to an alternative location when the Sardinian job is presented together with an institutional improvement.
Secondary outcomes
Beliefs about own potential salary in Sardinia Respondents’ expected net monthly salary if they were employed full-time in Sardinia. Beliefs about typical salaries in Sardinia Respondents’ beliefs about the net monthly salary of a typical full-time employee in Sardinia. Confidence in salary beliefs Self-reported confidence in the salary expectations provided in the belief questions. Preference for living in Sardinia Self-reported preference for living in Sardinia measured on a numerical scale. Heterogeneity in willingness to pay Differences in the main outcomes across key individual characteristics, including gender, age, current place of residence, previous experience living in Sardinia, current income, and employment characteristics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords