Impact of family planning and business trainings on private sector health providers: Results from an RCT in Nigeria

How to cite

Kinnan, Cynthia; Toriola, Modupe; Baruwa, Sikiru; Johnson, Doug; Chatterji, Minki; Leegwater, Anthony; Ugaz, Jorge. 2016. "Impact of family planning and business trainings on private sector health providers: Results from an RCT in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001803. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1803-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cynthia Kinnan* , Modupe Toriola , Sikiru Baruwa , Doug Johnson , Minki Chatterji , Anthony Leegwater , Jorge Ugaz

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001803
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1803-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2013-01-01 – 2014-09-30
Countries
Nigeria (Africa)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1803

Abstract

Through a randomized experiment, this study measures the impact of an innovative multi-faceted package of trainings-related activities targeted to private health providers in Nigeria on healthcare and financial outcomes. Facilities in the treatment group were offered a comprehensive training package that included counseling skills, contraceptive technology update, clinical skills, and business practices, while facilities in control were offered no training. Using data collected through facility and mystery client surveys, we estimated impacts on multiple healthcare and financial outcomes. Treated facilities increased the range of contraceptive methods offered by 10.2 percent relative to control facilities. Assignment to treatment also increased the overall quality of a provider's counseling services, interpersonal skills, and overall knowledge. Business practices also improved, although there was no effect on revenue generation.

Intervention

To address the gap in private health providers' family planning knowledge, healthcare skills, and business practices, the research team designed an intervention including different types of trainings, supportive supervision services, and other complementary services aimed at doctors, nurses, and/or nurse midwives.

1) Trainings Treatment: Private health providers were offered a comprehensive training package that included sessions on counseling skills, contraceptive technology update, clinical skills, and business practices. The providers then decided which training sessions, if any, their staff would participate in. Supportive supervision services, and other complementary services were also offered.
2) Control: Private health providers were not offered any elements of the training package or complimentary services.

Since each private health provider independently chose which training sessions and complimentary services to take advantage of, our analysis employs an “intent-to-treat” approach to examine the impact of offering the multi-faceted intervention, regardless of participation in the training sessions.

Experimental design

This study used a randomized controlled trial research design, with a baseline survey (prior to randomization) and an endline survey of the 965 private healthcare facilities. We randomly assigned those 965 private health facilities into either a treatment group (484 facilities) or a control group (481 facilities) using the following steps for stratification: First, we created strata for each of the 20 local government areas, or LGA, creating 20 “primary cells.” We made sure that each cell contained at least four facilities in order to avoid sparsely populated cells. Second, we created sub-strata. This was done as follows. For primary cells with more than 16 facilities, we created sub-strata by splitting the primary strata into those above and below the median vignette score (defined below) and, within each of the resulting sub-strata, splitting again into those above and below the median business score . Thus, we created “final cells,” which were groupings of facilities from the same LGA and, if the sample size permitted, were also similar in terms of the vignette score and business score. Finally, we randomly assigned all 965 facilities, one by one within each of those ‘final cells’ to either a control or treatment group.

Design details

Randomization method
After stratification (explained in the "Experimental Design" section), we randomly assigned all 965 facilities, one by one within each of those ‘final cells’ to either a control or treatment group.
Randomization unit
private healthcare facility
Clusters
No clusters.
Observations
965 private healthcare facilities
Arms
484 private healthcare facilities treatment, 481 private healthcare facilities control
Primary outcomes
Healthcare: the range of contraceptive methods offered, overall quality of counseling services, provider interpersonal skills, provider overall knowledge. Business Practices: record-keeping, loan applications, current loans, revenue generation.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords