Do expressions of care crowd-out monetary donations?
How to cite
James, Alexander; Thunstrom, Linda; Veld, Klaas Van 't; Noy, Shiri. 2026. "Do expressions of care crowd-out monetary donations?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018029. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18029-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Existing literature suggests people give in part because it makes them feel good, or receive "warm glow". But there is also evidence that people give due to social pressure and use donations as a public signal of their pro-social type. As such expressing one's level of care for a charitable cause reduces the signaling power of additional action and so reduces donations. We test this theory using an online survey experiment in which subjects were given the opportunity to donate to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA). We hypothesize that giving people the opportunity to express their level of care for animals in need reduces their monetary donations to the ASPCA.
Intervention
Existing literature suggests people give in part because it makes them feel good, or receive "warm glow". But there is also evidence that people give due to social pressure and use donations as a public signal of their pro-social type. According to this theory, expressing one's level of care for a charitable cause reduces the signaling power of additional action and so reduces donations. We test this theory using an online survey experiment in which subjects were given the opportunity to donate to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA). All subjects are given a $5 bonus payment. Subjects assigned to the control group are simply given the opportunity to donate some amount of money (between $0 - $5) to the ASPCA. Subjects assigned to the "care only" treatment are simply asked to state their level of care for abused animals. Subjects assigned to the "decision" treatment first decide whether to i) donate only, ii) express their level of care only, or iii) donate & express their level of care. If their decision involves expressing their level of care or donating, these decisions are made on the following page.
Experimental design
The survey experiment was designed and implemented using Qualtrics. Subjects first provide their consent to participate in the study and then answer a set of demographic questions. Subjects are then told they will receive a $5 bonus payment before being randomly assigned to one of three treatments:
i) donate
ii) express care
iii) donate and/or express care
Subjects assigned to the first treatment and simply asked if they would like to donate some of their $5 bonus payment to the ASPCA. Subjects in the second treatment are simply given the opportunity to state how much they care about abused animals. Subjects in the third treatment are given the option of i) donating, ii) expressing care, iii) both, or iv) nothing. For subjects in this third treatment, if their choice includes donating or expressing care, they do so on a following page. After donation decisions are made, additional demographic information is collected.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.