Do prayers to private charities crowd out giving?

How to cite

James, Alexander; Thunstrom, Linda; Veld, Klaas Van 't; Noy, Shiri. 2026. "Do prayers to private charities crowd out giving?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018026. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18026-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexander James* , Linda Thunstrom , Klaas Van 't Veld , Shiri Noy

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018026
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18026-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-02-26 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D64; C9; Z12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18026

Abstract

Seminal work by James Andreoni and others suggests that large contributions to charitable organizations partially crowd out individual donations. We extend this literature by assessing whether non-monetary actions - specifically prayers - similarly crowd out donations to charitable causes. To do so, we designed a survey experiment in which religious Christian respondents were given the opportunity to donate either to an individual or to a community in need following a natural disaster. A baseline condition simply solicits a donation. Treatment conditions inform subjects that either one or one hundred other people had previously offered a prayer for the individual’s or community’s full recovery. We hypothesize that others' prayers reduce people's perceived marginal benefit of donating and so decrease both the likelihood and the amount of giving.

Intervention

Seminal work by James Andreoni and others suggests that large contributions to charitable organizations partially crowd out individual donations. We extend this literature by assessing whether non-monetary actions - specifically prayers - similarly crowd out donations to charitable causes. To do so, we designed a survey experiment in which religious Christian respondents were given the opportunity to donate either to an individual or to a community in need following a natural disaster. A baseline condition simply solicits a donation. Treatment conditions inform subjects that either one or one hundred other people had previously offered a prayer for the individual’s or community’s full recovery. We hypothesize that others' prayers reduce people's perceived marginal benefit of donating and so decrease both the likelihood and the amount of giving.

Experimental design

The survey experiment was designed and implemented using Qualtrics. Subjects first consent to participate in the study and then provide basic demographic information. After learning they have received a $5 bonus payment, they are informed of either a person or a community that is in need of support following exposure to a natural disaster (Winter Storm Fern). The study leverages a 2x3, between-subjects design in which subjects are randomly assigned to learn about a community or individual in need following a natural disaster and are then asked to donate up to $5. Subjects in the control group are solicited for a donation without any mention of prayer. Subjects in the two treatments are either told that i) one person has prayed for full recovery (for either the town or individual, depending on treatment assignment) or that ii) one hundred people have prayed for full recovery. Following the donation decision, subjects answer a set of questions designed to elicit their level of religiosity.

Design details

Randomization method
Subjects are randomly assigned to treatments using randomization logic within Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
NA
Clusters
1
Observations
Our sample includes 800 respondents; roughly 266 subjects in the control group and each of the two treatments.
Arms
Our sample includes 800 respondents; roughly 266 subjects in the control group and each of the two treatments.
Primary outcomes
We are primarily interested in estimating treatment effects on i) the rate of giving and ii) the amount that people give.
Secondary outcomes
In addition to estimating treatment effects on donation rates and amounts, our survey includes questions that will allow us to estimate a perceived, "prayer production function." To do this, we ask subjects about their perceptions of how likely an individual or community are to recover when i) no one prays, ii) 1 person prays, or iii) 100 people pray. We will explore several sources of heterogeneity. Here, we are especially interested in how treatment effects vary by a person's level of religiosity. In particular, we will estimate heterogeneous effects among people who i) attend church at least once per week, ii) read religious scripture at least once per week, iii) pray at least once per week, iv) define themselves as "very religious", and v) interpret the Bible literally. We will additionally estimate heterogeneous effects among people who believe that a person (or community, depending on treatment assignment) is more likely to recover from a natural disaster after i) anyone prays for their recovery, ii) one person prays for their recovery, and iii) one hundred people pray for their recovery.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords