The Role of Information about Worker Skills in Hiring Decisions

How to cite

Oberti, Mitia; Brouard, Marion; Rathelot, Roland. 2026. "The Role of Information about Worker Skills in Hiring Decisions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017993. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17993-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mitia Oberti* , Marion Brouard , Roland Rathelot

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017993
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17993-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-01-30 – 2025-06-30
Countries
France ()
JEL codes
J23, J24, J62
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17993

Abstract

Labour markets differ widely in candidate availability and quality across occupations. In tight occupations, firms face few qualified applicants per vacancy and may struggle to identify productive candidates, especially when applicants come from distant occupations where skill signals are less clear. In slack occupations, recruiters face many applicants and screening becomes more selective. These differences may shape not only hiring decisions, but also the value of additional information about job seekers' skills. We study these mechanisms using an incentivised resume-rating (IRR) experiment with recruiters. Each recruiter evaluates synthetic CVs tailored to their hiring occupation. We experimentally vary education, work experience (in terms of occupational distance between experience and hiring occupation), skill certificates, as well as gender and ethnicity signals within recruiters. We also randomise the quality of the applicant pool between recruiters. We study the impact of these signals on the way recruiters assess productivity, and on their callback decisions.

Intervention

We conduct an incentivised resume-rating (IRR) experiment with professional recruiters. Each recruiter evaluates a pool of 20 synthetic CVs tailored to their hiring occupation.

Within the 20 CVs, we experimentally vary candidate attributes: (i) education, (ii) work experience (in terms of occupational distance between experience and hiring occupation), (iii) gender and ethnicity signals, and (iv) skill certificates.

In addition, we vary the quality of the pool of applicants across recruiters by changing the composition of the 20 CVs.

Experimental design

We conduct a clustered randomised trial in which recruiters are the randomisation clusters and CV evaluations are the observation units.
- At the individual level, we first randomise assignment to 6 kinds of profiles defined as combination of education (either ideal education for hiring occupation, or another diploma of same level but targeted for another occupation), experience (either in the hiring occupation or in a different one, with two groups of occupational distance), and skill certificates. Independently from the profiles, we randomly assign combinations of gender and ethnicity (French sounding names and North-African sounding names). Finally, we randomly assign home address and CV templates.
- At the cluster level, there are three treatment arms, corresponding to three levels of quality for the pool of candidates. In practice, we vary the number/share of profiles with education and work experience matching the target occupation.

Design details

Randomization method
- Cluster level: deterministic function of meaningless identifier. - Individual level: pseudo random number generator in statistical software. The exact randomization design is presented in the additional randomization_notes document.
Randomization unit
- Cluster: recruiter - Individual: application to a given recruiter.
Clusters
Around 100 recruiters.
Observations
Around 2000 (100 recruiters with 20 applications each).
Arms
- Cluster level: around 33 per treatment arms. - Individual level:
Primary outcomes
- Callback decision in the pool choice task (dummy): whether the candidate is selected for callback when the recruiter chooses among the 20 CVs in the experimental pool. - Callback decision in the standard-pool task (dummy): whether the recruiter would call back the candidate if the CV were part of their usual applicant pool for similar vacancies (elicited CV-by-CV). - Perceived productivity (graded by recruiters between 0 and 10).
Secondary outcomes
- Perceived retention probability (graded by recruiters between 0 and 10). - Perceived probability that the candidate would accept an offer if made (graded by recruiters between 0 and 10). - Weights allocated to CV attributes (education, experience, soft skills, others) - Interest for skill certification services

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords