The Economic and Social Integration of Refugees in Germany: Evidence from a Field Experiment

How to cite

Giesing, Yvonne; Laurentsyeva, Nadzeya; Battisti, Michele. 2016. "The Economic and Social Integration of Refugees in Germany: Evidence from a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001799. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1799-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yvonne Giesing* , Nadzeya Laurentsyeva , Michele Battisti

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001799
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1799-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-05-11 – 2017-11-11
Countries
Private
JEL codes
F22, J61, J68
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1799

Abstract

We design a field experiment to evaluate the role of matching frictions in the labour market integration of refugees. During CV writing sessions with refugees in Munich, we collect information from around 500 refugees that recently arrived in Munich and have a work permit. All of our participants receive a complete CV in German. We then randomly allocate half of the refugees to the treatment group, which is added to the database of an NGO that matches job candidates to suitable employers. This treatment can isolate the effect of matching and information frictions, while it has no effect on the underlying skill set of refugees. The experimental setting allows to track both control and treatment groups over time. Our survey data includes new information on the background characteristics of refugees, their existing job-search strategies, and perceptions of integration.

Intervention

We design a field experiment to evaluate the role of matching frictions on the employment prospects of refugees, and to shed light on the effects of employment on economic and social integration of refugees. During job-search training sessions taking place at refugee accommodation and other locations in and around Munich, we collect information from several hundred refugees that recently arrived in Munich and have (or are about to obtain) a work permit. All of our participants receive a complete CV in German. We then randomly allocate fifty percent of the refugees to our treatment group and fifty percent to our control group. The treatment group is then forwarded to an NGO that matches job candidates to suitable employers and supports the former through the placement process. We believe that this treatment can isolate the effect of matching and information frictions, while has not effect on the underlying skill set of refugees. The experimental setting allows to track both control and treatment groups over time.
As a first stage, we analyse how successful the supported refugees are in obtaining interviews and job offers. If we were to find any treatment, we would also be able to discuss the possible mechanisms at work and attempt an evaluation of the treatment in a cost-benefit setting. We then use the treatment as an instrument for employment and focus on the integration outcomes of migrants, which we are able to measure through a panel survey. Our survey data include information on the background characteristics of refugees, their existing job-search strategies, and perceptions of integration.

Experimental design

Our experimental set-up can be divided into three stages: the CV preparation stage, the treatment stage and the follow-up stage. The difference between the treatment and the control group is made during the second stage; through randomisation 50 percent of participants receive the additional job-matching treatment. The first and second stage have started in May 2016 in Munich and are ongoing until May 2017. The follow-up stage begins six months after the CV preparation stage and is conducted from November 2016 to November 2017.\footnote{The experimental design was approved by the Ethics commission of the Economics faculty of the University of Munich.}

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
To determine which candidates are allocated to the treatment and the control group, we randomise for each session separately, thereby insuring that for each session we have the same number of participants in the treatment and in the control group. For every session, participants are ranked by a random number generator and the upper 50 percent of participants are allocated to the treatment.\footnote{If the number of candidates is odd, the additional person is randomly allocated to the control or the treatment group.} As the sessions take place at different locations and time and individuals in the same session are more likely to be similar, we believe that this procedure helps us in having people with similar characteristics in the treatment and in the control group. Therefore this provides a useful (albeit weak) stratification. People who attend the regular CV sessions are likely to differ from those who get interviewed directly in their camp, participants from different camps might have access to varying degrees of support services through local social workers, etc. Moreover, it is logistically impossible to reach and to interview all potential participants within a short time span. This means that a single randomisation of all candidates would not be feasible. We conduct this session-based individual randomization every two weeks, so that the NGO receives new CVs twice a month. We thereby guarantee a stable flow for the NGO and ensure that the treatment starts at about the same time after the first meeting with the participants.\footnote{On average, every week we meet with 15 new job-seekers during the CV preparation sessions.}.
Clusters
Approx. 70 sessions (times and location)
Observations
500 participants
Arms
500 participants, 250 in treatment, 250 in control
Primary outcomes
Employed (at the point of the follow-up survey) Duration of employment (in months from the randomization day to the day of the follow-up survey) Wage (monthly (gross and net) wage at the point of the follow-up survey or in the last employment) Time until the first interview/trial/employment offer Number of job interviews for the first job (invited, happened) Number of job trials for the first job (invited, happened) Number of applications for the first job Where searched for vacancies (indicator variable as in the baseline survey) Job/skill match (an indicator variable: overqualified/ok/underqualified, based on observables, can measure for jobs they apply to and for the job they actually get) Self reported job satisfaction, self reported match quality Reservation wage (at the point of the follow-up) Difficulty in the job search (indicator variable as in the baseline survey) (Ask employers to see if they consider our treatment as a referral, if refugees contacted them directly) Intention to stay (dummy variable) Knowledge of German language (indicator variable) Local acquaintances (dummy) Activities: study, sport, shopping, meeting with friends (total number) Feel at home (indicator on Likert scale) Integration index: A2German + German\ friends + Invited + Activities + Feel\ home$Any other investment in human capital (as driving license)? Housing conditions Stress, happiness and optimism levels

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords