Impact of Early Childhood Comprehensive Care on Children and their Families in the Dominican Republic

How to cite

Santana, Maria Isabel; Pellerano, Jose Antonio; Mejia-Mantilla, Carolina; Fuente, Alejandro De la; D'Exelle, Ben. 2026. "Impact of Early Childhood Comprehensive Care on Children and their Families in the Dominican Republic." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017987. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17987-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maria Isabel Santana* , Jose Antonio Pellerano , Carolina Mejia-Mantilla , Alejandro De la Fuente , Ben D'Exelle

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017987
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17987-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-27 – 2030-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17987

Abstract

Investment in childcare is essential for poverty reduction as it improves children's cognitive and social skills, which can later translate into better performance at school and income earning potential. The adequate provision of childcare can also increase women’s employment and productivity, create new jobs and drive economic growth. In order to maximize both child development and female labor force participation, governments play a crucial role. They can help ensure that quality childcare is available, affordable, and meets the needs of all families, particularly the most vulnerable.

The public childcare service in the Dominican Republic is based on a comprehensive centre-based model: children from three months to five years of age in target areas are enrolled in daycare centres where they receive early stimulation and initial education coupled with routine health checkups. At the same time, parents participate in monthly workshops, where a range of topics are discussed, such as play in early childhood, responsible fatherhood, breastfeeding, nutrition, domestic violence, etc.

Using a randomized control trial, we will estimate the impact of enrollment to daycare centers on both children and their families. We will focus on early childhood outcomes such as language development, fine and gross motor, socio-emotional development and cognitive skills, as well as parental skills, employment, income, women’s agency, IPV exposure and gender norms.

Intervention

Using a randomized control trial, we will estimate the impact of enrollment to daycare centers on both children and their families. We will focus on early childhood outcomes such as language development, fine and gross motor, socio-emotional development and cognitive skills, as well as parental skills, employment, income, women’s agency, IPV exposure and gender norms.

Experimental design

We will use two treatment dimensions assigned at the household level. First, we will randomly vary whether a household has access to the services provided by a CAIPI center (T2) or not (T1). This involves a place for all children 0-5 years’ old in the household. In addition, parents will be invited to monthly parental workshops that cover a variety of topics.
Second, among the households that received a place at a childcare center, we will vary whether parents receive a Whatsapp message on their mobile phone that reminds them of the upcoming monthly workshop. The message includes an infographic and a link to a very short video that encourage them to attend the workshop.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is conducted at the household level rather than the child level, to preserve household integrity: all eligible children in a selected household are admitted together. This rule reflects both the way INAIPI operates (families enrol siblings jointly) and the way we will analyse outcomes (intra-household dynamics are part of the theory of change). Household-level randomization combined with age-group capacity caps creates a non-trivial allocation problem: a uniform draw at the household level can violate age-group capacity in any single age cell. To respect both capacity and household integrity while pre-serving well-defined ex-ante admission probabilities, we use a scarcity-ordered stratified lottery with household integrity (hereafter, the bucket-lottery protocol). The protocol proceeds within each center as follows: (i) Eligible age cells are defined at one-year resolution: g0–1, g1–2, g2–3, g3–4, g4–5. Per-cell capacities are set ex ante based on the center’s expected age distribution. Two indicative vectors were used in simulations, both summing to 195 seats per center: a conservative allocation (23, 28, 44, 50, 50) and a benevolent allocation (30, 36, 39, 45, 45) (scenarios S-A and S-C, see attached documents for more information). (ii) Each household is assigned to a bucket corresponding to the age cell in which it is hardest to accommodate (its scarcest occupied cell). Households with children in multiple cells are bucketed by the scarcest occupied cell; households with children in a single cell are bucketed by that cell. (iii) Buckets are processed in descending order of demand-to-capacity ratio (scarcest age cell first). Within each bucket, a uniform random ordering of households is drawn. Households are admitted in order until the bucket’s target age cell is filled (the treatment tranche), accounting for any spillover of siblings into other cells from earlier buckets; all remaining households constitute the control tranche. The same ordering is retained for the substitution rule described below. (iv) A residual fill-up step admits additional households (drawn uniformly from eligible buckets) if any cell remains under-filled after all primary buckets are processed. Ex ante simulations show this step does not activate under realistic scenarios (zero activations in 4,000 replications), but it is pre-specified for completeness. This protocol delivers (a) household integrity by construction, (b) known ex-ante admission probabilities per bucket, and (c) capacity filled by design. Analysis of treatment effects proceeds with center × bucket fixed effects, which fully absorb the differential admission probabilities across strata. Substitution for declined slots. A share of admitted households is expected to decline the offered slot (central assumption: 10%; see the compliance discussion in Section 5.3). Declined slots must be filled for operational reasons. To do so without compromising the design, the same uniform random ordering of households drawn within each bucket in step (iii) is used to define a substitution order : when an admitted household declines, its slot is offered to the next control-tranche household in that pre-drawn order, subject to the same age-cell capacity checks as steps (iii)–(iv). The household that accepts the substituted slot is retired from the analysis (it counts neither as treatment nor as control), because its enrolment depended on the realised pattern of declines rather than on the initial assignment. This rule preserves one-sided noncompliance: only households promoted through the substitution order can transition from the control tranche to enrolment, and those households are excluded from the confirmatory comparison, so no household that remains in the control tranche for analysis can become enrolled. The ITT/TOT framework therefore applies unchanged. The cost is a modest reduction in the size of the confirmatory control group, in expectation equal to the realised number of declined slots. Two sources of heterogeneity in our sample motivated this design. First, based on existing survey data, we expect around 45% of households to be single-mother households (no male partner present), and the other 55% to be households with a male partner. This implies that for only around half of the sampled households will we have data on the male partner and on intra-household dynamics. Second, INAIPI attends children from 0 to 5; treatment relevance and outcome instruments differ across this age span, motivating the age-cell structure above. Stratification on mothers’ employment and marital status at baseline is not necessary because the realised variation in these dimensions (around 40% of women are employed; roughly one third are single mothers) is sufficient to support heterogeneity analyses without ex ante balancing.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
We will include 6 new CAIPI centers in this study. The intended CAIPIs for the evaluation will be located in urban and densely populated communities.
Observations
390 pupils per center, for a total of 2,340.
Arms
T1: 1,170 (195 pupils per center x 6 centers) control households. T2: 1,170/2=585 attending CAIPI centres and not receiving workshop reminders T3: 1,170/2=585 attending CAIPI centres and receiving workshop reminders.
Primary outcomes
Child: Children’s socio-emotional and cognitive development. Household: Employment and income, Time use, Mental well-being (general stress, parental stress), Parenting practices, parent-child interaction, Spousal relation, Women’s empowerment, intra-household decision-making, Social ties, Social norms
Secondary outcomes
Anthropometric measures

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords