Perceived Value, Perceived Harm: Economic Incentives and Bystander Intervention in Workplace Harassment
How to cite
Saxena, Mansa; Beaman, Lori; Sharma, Anisha; Sharma, Karmini. 2026. "Perceived Value, Perceived Harm: Economic Incentives and Bystander Intervention in Workplace Harassment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017980. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17980-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Sexual harassment in customer-facing workplaces remains a significant barrier to women’s economic participation, particularly in settings where formal protections are weak. In small retail shops, harassment often occurs in public view, placing responsibility on coworkers or shop owners to decide whether and how to intervene. These decisions may be influenced not only by moral considerations but also by economic incentives.
This study examines whether a customer’s economic value to a business affects bystander responses to workplace harassment. We conduct a field-based vignette experiment with retail shop owners and employees working in customer-facing shops in Delhi, India. The vignette was specifically designed for this study to closely match the setting respondents know from their daily work: a small customer-facing retail shop in Delhi, Indian characters, locally familiar interactions, and the sale of kurtas and similar apparel. The behavior shown in the video is identical across participants. We experimentally vary only the customer’s total spending and how that spending is conveyed (through higher price per item or greater quantity purchased).
After viewing the video, respondents report what action they would take, if any, how serious they perceive the behavior to be, what consequences they anticipate from intervening, and what they believe others in the workplace would do, as well as expect them to do. This design allows us to isolate whether higher-spending customers receive different responses, even when the nature of the misconduct is unchanged. The study contributes to understanding how economic incentives and status signals shape workplace norms and bystander intervention in client-facing sectors.
Intervention
Our experimental design uses animated, video-based vignettes, designed to represent a typical customer interaction in an apparel store. Each vignette depicts the same pattern of customer harassment directed at a female employee. The harassment script and behavioral cues are held constant across treatment arms. We experimentally vary only the economic value of the customer to the shop, implemented through a cross-randomization of two dimensions of purchase behavior.
First, we vary the customer’s total spending, which serves as a signal of the customer’s economic importance. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of three conditions:
● High-value customer: high total spending
● Medium-value customer: medium total spending
● Low-value customer: low total spending
Second, we vary whether total spending is conveyed by quantity or quality. In one condition, spending is signaled through the price per unit, with the customer purchasing a single item at different prices. In the other condition, spending is signaled through quantity purchased, with the customer buying multiple units (three, two, or one) at a constant low per-unit price. Ultimately, respondents are assigned to one of five conditions with low total spending (buying 1 unit at low price) is the control group.
Respondents view only one vignette, ruling out within-subject contamination or learning effects. The design varies the economic cost of intervention both in magnitude and in the way customer value is signaled, by cross-randomizing total spending and whether spending is conveyed through price per unit or quantity purchased. Holding the harassing behavior constant, this allows us to study whether and how a customer’s perceived financial value and associated status cues shape bystanders’ interpretations of the situation and their intervention choices.
Experimental design
The study is a field-based, randomized vignette experiment conducted among retail shop owners, managers, and employees in Delhi, India. The target sample consists of approximately 1,000 shops. Within each shop, up to three respondents (owner/manager and up to two employees) are surveyed. Randomization occurs at the individual level within shops. Each respondent is independently assigned to one of five treatment conditions. The five conditions arise from variation in total customer spending (low, medium, high) and whether spending is conveyed through price per unit or quantity purchased. The low-spending condition serves as the baseline group. Each respondent views only one version of the vignette.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.