Behavioral Nudges for Credit Card Debt Repayment in the Dominican Republic

How to cite

Laroze, Denise; Schwartz, Daniel; Adams, Paul. 2026. "Behavioral Nudges for Credit Card Debt Repayment in the Dominican Republic." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017979. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17979-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Denise Laroze* , Daniel Schwartz , Paul Adams

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017979
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17979-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-02 – 2027-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D180, C93, D12, D91, G21, G51
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17979

Abstract

Over-indebtedness among credit card holders is a persistent problem in emerging markets, where many consumers systematically pay below the minimum balance, incurring compounding interest charges and deepening financial vulnerability. In partnership with the Superintendencia de Bancos of the Dominican Republic and its ProUsuario app, we implement a large-scale RCT involving approximately 80,000 revolving-balance credit card users randomly assigned to one of four arms: a control group and three treatment arms differing in message framing (interest-cost salience, debt-cycle motivation, or both) and delivery pattern (fixed, alternating, or combined). Messages are delivered via SMS, push notification, and/or email. Primary outcomes are full balance payment, proportion of debt paid (payment-to-balance ratio), revolving debt payment, minimum payment compliance, and less than minimum payment. Secondary outcomes include number of months of revolving debt, existence of interest charges, and days past due. Randomization is stratified by number of cards and gender. A follow-up period using administrative data will assess persistence of effects.

Intervention

In partnership with the Superintendencia de Bancos (SB) and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA), the research team will implement and evaluate behavioral “nudge” messages intended to increase repayment behavior among ProUsuario users with revolving credit card balances. Messages will be delivered digitally and repeatedly to test whether low-cost information and reminders can generate sustained improvements in repayment and debt reduction.

Experimental design

We target credit card users in the Dominican Republic whose accounts are serviced by financial institutions supervised by the Superintendencia de Bancos (SB). Eligibility requires: (i) the account carried a non-zero revolving balance (i.e., was not fully paid) in at least two of the twelve months prior to the baseline month; and (ii) the statement balance in the baseline month (January 2026) was at least 500 DOP (approximately 8 USD). These criteria identify revolvers — users who habitually carry debt and are therefore most likely to benefit from repayment nudges and most likely to show detectable behavioral responses.

From this eligibility frame, we selected all accounts satisfying the criteria in the baseline billing cycle (January 2026), yielding a randomized sample of approximately 65,400 users. The unit of observation is a user–billing-cycle pair. We define a billing cycle for month X as comprising all accounts whose statement date falls within month X, regardless of whether the corresponding due date falls in a subsequent month (as is common). All outcome measurements follow this billing-cycle definition throughout the intervention and follow-up periods.

Randomization was conducted using stratified random assignment. The stratification variables are: (i) number of cards held (1 card vs. 2+ cards) and (ii) gender (female vs. male), yielding four strata. Within each stratum, users were allocated with equal probability (25% each) to the four experimental arms. A fixed random seed was set prior to randomization to ensure full reproducibility; the randomization script and seed are archived and available upon request.

We will implement a 4-arms RCT. The arms are defined as follows:

- Control
- Treatment 1 — Single message type: Participants receive one message per billing cycle. The message type is fixed across all 6 intervention months, assigned at randomization. Within T1, participants are sub-randomized to receive either an interest-focused message (M-I) or a debt-focused message (M-D).
- Treatment 2 — Alternating messages: Participants receive one message per billing cycle, alternating between M-I and M-D each month across the 6 intervention months. Within T2, participants are sub-randomized to start with either M-I or M-D in month 1.
- Treatment 3 — Combined message: Participants receive one message per billing cycle containing both debt and interest salience in a single communication. Within T3, participants are sub-randomized to receive either an interest-then-debt (M-I-D) or debt-then-interest (M-D-I) ordering across all 6 months.

Messages are delivered through three channels — email (Mailchimp), SMS (SendIU), and push notification (Firebase) — depending on the contact information available for each user. One message per billing cycle per user is delivered.

- M-D: Hola [NOMBRE], reduce intereses hoy: paga más de tu tarjeta el Banco Lopez de Haro si tienes balance pendiente.
- M-I: Hola [NOMBRE], rompe el ciclo de deuda hoy: paga más de tu tarjeta el Banco Lopez de Haro si tienes balance pendiente.
- M-D-I: Hola [NOMBRE], reduce intereses y rompe el ciclo de deuda hoy: paga más de tu tarjeta del Banco Lopez de Haro si tienes balance pendiente.
- M-I-D: Hola [NOMBRE], rompe el ciclo de deuda y reduce intereses hoy: paga más de tu tarjeta del Banco Lopez de Haro si tienes balance pendiente

The expected timeline for the project is defined as follows:
Baseline – January 2026: Eligibility and sample selection
Pre-intervention – Feb-March 2026: Randomization, protocol finalization and setup
Intervention – April-September 2026: Six monthly messages delivered to treatment arms
Follow up – October 2026 - March 2027: Three post-intervention billing cycles, no messages will be sent.

Our main specification is an OLS regression with standard errors clustered at the user level. We follow participants across multiple billing cycles from the start of the intervention, covering both the six intervention months and the six post-intervention follow-up months. We employ two complementary approaches to recover treatment effects over time. First, we estimate separate cross-sectional regressions for each billing cycle, yielding a period-specific ITT estimate without imposing any trajectory on the treatment effect. Second, we estimate a pooled regression with treatment × billing-cycle interactions, which allows us to formally test for effect decay, growth, or stabilization over time. We do not impose a priori restrictions on the treatment effect trajectory, as it is theoretically ambiguous; both specifications let the data speak to this directly. Pre-specified baseline covariates (age, gender, number of cards held, number of financial institutions, interest rates, and app login activity as a proxy for engagement) are included throughout to improve estimation precision. The unit of analysis is the user–billing cycle observation. Where a user holds multiple credit cards, debt balances and payment variables are aggregated across all their accounts prior to analysis..

Design details

Randomization method
We will conduct stratified random assignment through computer assisted software. The software used for the randomization is R from Posit. The randomization will stratify in the following two variables: 1. Gender of card holder: Male or female 2. Number of credit cards: One card vs two or more credit cards. As a result we have 4 possible stratas.
Randomization unit
The randomization will be conducted at user level
Clusters
Approximately 65,400 users
Observations
Approximately 65,400 users
Arms
- Control: 16,300 users - Treatment 1: 16,300 users - Treatment 2: 16,300 users - Treatment 3: 16,300 users
Primary outcomes
Full balance payment (dummy) Proportion of debt paid (payment-to-balance ratio) Revolving debt payment (dummy) Minimum payment compliance (dummy) Less than minimum payment (dummy) Statement balance net of payments, as a proportion of statement balance
Secondary outcomes
Number of months of revolving debt The existence of interest charges (dummy) Days past due Dummies for 1, 2 or 3 missed payments Interest amount Debt level Difference in payment behavior across cards (if the person has more than 1 card)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords