Evaluation of Educational Intervention Programs in Mental Health and Their Effects on Academic Performance

How to cite

Cuesta, Maite Blazquez; Moro-Egido, Ana Isabel; Zucchelli, Eugenio; Sánchez, Ainhoa Herrarte. 2026. "Evaluation of Educational Intervention Programs in Mental Health and Their Effects on Academic Performance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017973. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17973-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maite Blazquez Cuesta* , Ana Isabel Moro-Egido , Eugenio Zucchelli , Ainhoa Herrarte Sánchez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017973
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17973-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-11-20 – 2026-05-07
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I10; I20; I30
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17973

Abstract

Mental health issues among adolescents represent a growing public health concern, with significant ramifications for human capital accumulation, academic achievement, and long-term socioeconomic outcomes. The extant literature demonstrates a consistent pattern of findings, indicating that mental health interventions, despite exhibiting significant variations in format, intensity, and delivery settings, have the capacity to effect substantial improvements in psychological well-being and associated life outcomes.

Despite the growing recognition of the importance of mental health for educational outcomes, there is a paucity of credible causal evidence on scalable, school-based interventions in economics. A significant proportion of extant research is predicated on observational designs or is focused on clinical or high-risk populations. There is comparatively less experimental evidence evaluating universal, preventive interventions embedded in school curricula and assessed through administrative academic records.

This study addresses existing evidence gaps by providing rigorous causal estimates of the academic effects of school based mental health interventions. By combining administrative academic records with validated psychological measures within a randomized framework, the project clarifies the mechanisms linking mental health, socioemotional skill formation, and academic achievement, generating actionable insights for the development of effective and equitable school based mental health policies.

Moreover, the study contributes to the economics literature through a cluster randomized controlled trial that integrates validated mental health survey instruments with objective administrative data, enhancing the credibility of the findings. The analysis focuses on intention to treat estimates under classroom level randomisation, offering robust evidence on the intervention’s impact in real educational settings

Intervention

The intervention consists of four structured workshops delivered during regular tutorial hours by trained psychologists from Asociación Candelita. Each session lasts approximately 55 minutes and follows a standardized manual to ensure consistency across schools. Specifically, we articulate the intervention into four workshops:

1) Workshop I: Self-Knowledge and Self-Esteem
Focuses on self-awareness, identification of personal strengths, and emotional reflection exercises. These components aim to enhance self-efficacy and internal locus of control, traits linked to educational attainment in the economics literature.
2) Workshop II: Assertive Communication and Conflict Resolution
Introduces communication styles (passive, aggressive, assertive). Students complete adapted assertiveness exercises and engage in structured role-play scenarios. Interpersonal skills are increasingly valued in the labor market (Deming, 2017).
3) Workshop III: Coping Strategies
Introduces adaptive coping mechanisms and emotional regulation tools grounded in cognitive-behavioral principles. Improved coping may mitigate the impact of mental health shocks on schooling (Currie & Stabile, 2006).
4) Workshop IV: Recognition of Warning Signs and Help-Seeking
Provides students with information about mental health warning signs and formal/informal help pathways. Reducing informational frictions and stigma may improve timely help-seeking behavior.

Control classrooms do not receive the intervention during the evaluation period.

(See Documento_3 for a more detailed description of the Workshops)

Experimental design

DESIGN OVERVIEW
The study is a classroom-level cluster-randomized controlled trial, with randomization stratified by school.

The intervention is implemented among students enrolled in 2º ESO (second year of compulsory secondary education of the Spanish school system). Within each participating school, all classrooms corresponding to 2º ESO are identified prior to randomization.

Randomization occurs at the classroom level within each school and within this grade. Specifically, at least one 2º ESO classroom per school is randomly assigned to the treatment condition, while at least one other 2º ESO classroom in the same school serves as the control group.

This design is therefore not a school-level randomization, but a within-school, within-grade cluster-randomized design at the classroom level.

WITHIN-SCHOOL AND WITHIN-GRADE STRUCTURE

Because both treatment and control classrooms belong to the same grade (2º ESO) within the same schools, this design has two key implications. First, it enhances internal comparability, as treatment and control students share the same school leadership and infrastructure, the same grade-level curriculum, and the same academic calendar and evaluation system. This reduces confounding from school-level differences and increases comparability across study arms. Second, it introduces the potential for peer spillovers. Because treatment and control classrooms coexist within the same grade cohort, students may interact across classrooms, potentially generating spillover effects if treated students share workshop content or attitudes with control students. Such spillovers, if present, would likely attenuate estimated treatment effects toward zero. The primary estimand therefore remains the intention-to-treat effect of classroom-level assignment, interpreted under potential partial interference across classrooms.

SAMPLE STRUCTURE
We collect our sample using the following procedure. We first run a pilot experiment (Phase I) within 1 public secondary school in Madrid. We randomize between 2º ESO classrooms. We end up with a total of 81 students, among which 45 were assigned to treatment classroom and 36 were assigned to control classroom.
In a second phase (Phase 2), we fully implement our experiment in 11 secondary schools in Madrid (7 public and 4 semi-private/private). We end up with a sample of 751 students belonging to 11 treated classrooms and 23 control classrooms. Each school contributes at least two 2º ESO classrooms. In schools with two classrooms, one classroom is assigned to treatment and one to control. In schools with more than two classrooms in the grade, additional classrooms are randomly allocated while ensuring representation in both arms.

Design details

Randomization method
Within each participating school, all 2º ESO classrooms are first enumerated. Randomization is then conducted centrally by the research team using statistical software with a reproducible random seed. Assignment is stratified by school to ensure that each school contributes both treatment and control classrooms. In schools with exactly two 2º ESO classrooms, one classroom is randomly assigned to treatment and the other to control. In schools with more than two classrooms in the grade, at least one classroom is assigned to each arm, and additional classrooms are randomly allocated while maintaining balance within the school. Assignment is determined prior to intervention delivery and is not based on student characteristics.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the classroom (grupo-clase). Students are not individually randomized within classrooms. All students within a treated classroom are exposed to the intervention during tutorial hours, conditional on parental consent and student assent. Participation in the study is voluntary and requires written parental consent prior to inclusion in the study, as well as written student assent prior to participation in surveys and intervention activities. Students and parents are informed that participation is voluntary, that they may withdraw at any time without penalty, and that refusal to participate does not affect academic standing. Only students with completed consent procedures are included in survey data collection. Because treatment assignment varies at the classroom level, outcomes of students within the same classroom may be correlated. Statistical inference must account for intra-class correlation. Accordingly, all primary analyses will report standard errors clustered at the classroom level (Moulton, 1990; Angrist & Pischke, 2009). The unit of analysis is the individual student.
Clusters
40 classrooms
Observations
751 pupils
Arms
11 schools; 17 classrooms: treatment 23 classrooms: control
Primary outcomes
1.A standardized Mental Health Index constructed from validated depression items (6-ITEM Kutcher Adolescent Depression Scale; KADS). 2. Grade Point Average (GPA) and subject-specific grades (administrative records).
Secondary outcomes
1. Heterogeneity Analysis: i) Gender differences; ii) Mental health status (above/below median of baseline index); iii)School type (public vs. semi-private/private). 2. Other potential indexes: i) Assertiveness index: ii) Coping strategy index; iii).Help-seeking knowledge index All indices are standardized relative to the baseline control-group distribution

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords