Consumer Response to New Retirement Income Products: A Test Alternative Methods for Presenting Key Information

How to cite

Hiscox, Michael. 2016. "Consumer Response to New Retirement Income Products: A Test Alternative Methods for Presenting Key Information." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001795. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1795-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michael Hiscox*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001795
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1795-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-12-02 – 2017-01-31
Countries
Australia ()
JEL codes
D03 (Behavioural Microeconomics: underlying principles); D14 Household Saving; Personal Finance; D91 Intertemporal Household Choice, Life Cycle Models and Saving
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1795

Abstract

The aim of the study is to provide evidence to help the Australian Government improve consumer understanding of retirement income products and maximize the alignment of consumer preferences with the choice of products. In particular, the study aims to test different methods for presenting information about the trade-offs consumers face between income, flexibility and risk protection when making choices between retirement income products, focusing on the comparison between new types of products aimed at managing longevity risks and the standard account-based pension (ABP) that most retirees receive. The effectiveness of various methods of presentation of information is measured by testing consumer comprehension and assessing the alignment of preferences with the self-reported likely choice of retirement income product.

Intervention

When individuals reach retirement, they have to make complex financial decisions about how to manage their retirement savings so that they get the most income for the rest of their lives. Currently it is common for retirees to choose to receive their superannuation as an account-based pension: an accessible managed fund from which they can draw annual income in amounts they choose. Most retirees appear to be drawing from these accounts at or near the regulated minimum rates, presumably in order to manage longevity risk.

The Australian Government has accepted the Financial System Inquiry recommendation to facilitate trustees pre-selecting Comprehensive Income Products for Retirement (CIPRs) for their members. This is aimed to help guide members at retirement and improve outcomes for retirees, including through increased private retirement incomes, increased consumer choice and better protection against longevity and other risks.

This study aims to provide insights about whether consumers can understand a hypothetical new type of retirement income plan (an example of a potential CIPR) and make choices that fit with their preferences, testing various methods for presenting the key information about the plan.

An online experimental survey will be used to present a hypothetical ‘offer’ of a potential new retirement income plan to participants. Eligible participants will be aged 45 and above and still in the superannuation accumulation phase with either active or inactive accounts, with a wide range of superannuation balances. The trial approximates a “framed field experiment” in which subjects are drawn from the population of interest and complete a familiar task (review the offer of a new financial product) in a naturally-occurring context, but understand that in this instance they are completing the task as part of a research study.

Individuals who agree to participate in the study will be randomly assigned to view different textual and/or graphical explanations of a retirement income plan with comparisons between this plan and a standard account-based pension. The different treatments are design to test how people respond to the presentation of the same information in text form versus graphical and numerical forms, whether the addition of star ratings improves understanding, and the impact of a salience prompt aimed at emphasizing one dimension of the choice (average income). Subjects will then be asked to indicate, hypothetically, how willing they would be to accept such a plan if it were offered to them by their superannuation fund. They will also be asked a set of questions to measure understanding of the alternative plans and the trade-offs involved in making a choice between them, as well as an open-ended question asking members to explain their choice. The survey should take no more than 15 minutes to complete.

Experimental design

The study is aimed at helping to develop solutions that the Government could realistically deploy in its regulatory framework to optimize the disclosure standards and recommendations for Comprehensive Income Products for Retirement. The key objective is to identify the best way to present information about the core features of CIPRs, in the context of a comparison with the alternative (standard) option of an account-based pension with minimum drawdown rates. The interventions are designed to test different ways to presenting key features of products as simply and clearly as possible in order to achieve sound understanding and to promote a preference-consistent choice.

The study will be conducted in partnership with superannuation fund managers who will provide contact information for a sample of their members. An online experimental survey will be used to present a hypothetical ‘offer’ of a potential new retirement income plan to participants. The study approximates a "framed field experiment" with eligible participants drawn from current fund members aged 45 and above and still in the superannuation accumulation phase with either active or inactive accounts, with a wide range of superannuation balances.

Individuals who agree to participate in the study will be randomly assigned to view different textual and/or graphical explanations of a retirement income plan with comparisons between this plan and a standard account-based pension. The different treatments are design to test how people respond to the presentation of the same information in text form versus graphical and numerical forms, whether the addition of star ratings improves understanding, and the impact of a salience prompt aimed at emphasizing one dimension of the choice (average income). Subjects will then be asked to indicate, hypothetically, how willing they would be to accept such a plan if it were offered to them by their superannuation fund. They will also be asked a set of questions to measure understanding of the alternative plans and the trade-offs involved in making a choice between them, as well as an open-ended question asking members to explain their choice.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer algorithm embedded within the survey.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
1,600
Arms
200 individuals in control group, 200 individuals in each of 7 treatment groups
Primary outcomes
The survey will enable us to measure how different presentations of the trade-offs impact the alignment of preferences and consumer choices, to help inform the development of a framework for CIPRs

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords