National Pride or Personal Gain? Experimental Evidence on Framing the Energy Transition in Indonesia

How to cite

Sim, Armand; Mohamad, Paramita; Bimardhika, Elghafiky; Patricia, Agnes. 2026. "National Pride or Personal Gain? Experimental Evidence on Framing the Energy Transition in Indonesia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017920. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17920-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Armand Sim* , Paramita Mohamad , Elghafiky Bimardhika , Agnes Patricia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017920
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17920-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-01 – 2026-07-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q48, Q54, D83, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17920

Abstract

Public support is essential for the energy transition, yet many citizens in developing countries remain poorly informed about transition policies, and the sense of urgency for climate action is declining. Whether highlighting personal gains or national interests when communicating the transition's benefits is more effective remains untested. We conduct a randomized field experiment with 2,000 nationally representative Indonesian adults, randomly assigning short videos that frame transition benefits at the state level (economic sovereignty, climate leadership), the individual level (health, stable prices, local jobs), or an unrelated placebo topic. Indonesia is an ideal setting for this study because its heavy coal dependence and large fuel subsidies make energy transition trade-offs salient to individuals, while strong national pride makes it suitable to identify which framing resonates most. We measure treatment effects on incentivized behavioral outcomes, including donations to an environmental NGO, petition signing with identity disclosure, and information seeking.

Intervention

Respondents are randomly assigned to one of three arms, each exposed to a 2.5-minute video during the survey interview.

T1 (State Benefits): Video emphasizing national-level benefits of the energy transition, such as economic sovereignty, reduced import dependence, increased attractiveness for foreign investment, and global climate leadership.

T2 (Individual Benefits): Video emphasizing individual- and community-level benefits, such as improved air quality and health outcomes, stable energy prices, local employment opportunities, and environmental protection.

Control (Placebo): Video on an unrelated topic with no energy or climate content.

T1 and T2 share identical basic climate science information and a call to action. They differ only in the framing of benefits (national vs. individual).

Experimental design

Randomized experiment with 2,000 nationally representative Indonesian adults (aged 18+), conducted between April and May 2026. Survey will be conducted once alongside intervention, which is embedded within the survey.

Respondents are stratified by urban/rural residence and randomly assigned with equal probability to three arms, where each respondent will be exposed to a 2.5-minute video.

- T1 (State Benefits frame),

- T2 (Individual Benefits frame)

- Control (Placebo).

Outcomes are measured immediately after a transitional survey module designed to reduce demand effects. Incentivized attention and manipulation checks are included to assess compliance. A self-monitoring scale is included to assess potential demand effect bias.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted by computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2000 clusters (individuals)
Observations
2000 nationally representative adults
Arms
2000 individuals distributed evenly to three groups: roughly 667 per group.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes measure costly commitments, not stated preferences. (1) Donation Amount: allocation of IDR 0–30,000 (~USD 2) from survey compensation to an environmental NGO. We will capture both the extensive margin (any donation) and intensive margin (amount conditional on giving). (2) Petition Signing: binary choice to sign an online petition urging coal phase-out and renewable energy expansion, requiring disclosure of the respondent's name (3) Information Seeking: binary choice to receive a link to additional environmental videos after the survey. We will then construct an index variable (behavioral engagement) out of those three measures
Secondary outcomes
We examine standard attitudinal outcomes capturing respondents’ beliefs and policy preferences regarding the energy transition. - Fossil Fuel Attribution Index: extent to which respondents attribute harms to fossil fuels - Transition Urgency: perceived urgency of Indonesia's energy transition - Policy Support Index: feasibility and acceptability beliefs for energy transition policies - Energy Policy Priorities (selection and ranking across 6 policy domains: fuel subsidies, power generation, social assistance, mining, green incentives, transportation) - Development Policy Priorities (selection and ranking across 6 development domains). We will also explore plausible psychological mechanisms through which our treatments operate as our intermediate outcomes. - Energy Transition Comprehension Score (extensive and intensive margins) - Moral Emotions Index - Politicized Identity Index - Collective Efficacy Index.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords