Who Gets to Work from Home? Evidence from an Employer Survey Experiment in Germany

How to cite

Zenker, Juliane. 2026. "Who Gets to Work from Home? Evidence from an Employer Survey Experiment in Germany." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017908. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17908-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Juliane Zenker*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017908
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17908-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-03-09 – 2027-05-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17908

Abstract

This study examines how employers ration remote work when flexibility cannot be granted universally. We field a pre-registered survey experiment in the 2026 wave of the SOEP-LEE2-Compare establishment survey in Germany. Establishment decision makers (HR staff, managers, owners) complete three short allocation tasks in which they distribute a fixed weekly budget of up to four remote-work days between two hypothetical candidates. Candidate profiles are otherwise identical but randomly vary along gender (mother vs. father), migration background (born abroad vs. born in Germany), parenthood (has children vs. childless), and a performance signal (excellent vs. average). The design identifies whether and how these characteristics shift remote-work priority under a binding constraint, and whether strong performance signals attenuate potential gaps—particularly for migrants. To aid interpretation, the survey also elicits post-choice beliefs about candidates’ productivity in home office and the likelihood of declining an offer if no remote work is available, as well as a norm-neutral social-desirability diagnostic based on “what other managers would do.” The study contributes employer-side evidence on the micro-foundations of remote-work access in a representative establishment sample and speaks to debates on flexibility, gender inequality, and migrant integration in the labor market.

Experimental design

The experiment is embedded in the SOEP-LEE2-Compare establishment survey (wave 2026) and administered in the “Home Office/Remote Work” module via CATI and, where applicable, CAWI. Respondents are establishment representatives (typically managers, owners, or HR staff) with responsibility for staffing or workplace-flexibility decisions. The experimental block is designed to be brief and standardized: interviewer prompts and vignette wording are scripted, and respondents complete three independent allocation tasks in which they distribute a fixed weekly budget of up to four remote-work days between two hypothetical candidates (half-days allowed; a zero allocation is permitted).

Candidate profiles are one-line vignettes with a fixed job context and randomly varied attributes: gender, migration background, parenthood, and a performance signal. Choices 1–2 are gender pairs contrasting an otherwise identical mother and father, with migration toggled across the two choices and the performance signal held constant within respondent. Choice 3 is randomly assigned to be either a migration pair (migrant vs. non-migrant of the same gender) or a parenthood pair (parent vs. childless with gender and migration held constant within the pair). Across all choices, the two profiles are identical in non-focal attributes and left–right placement is balanced by design; randomization is implemented ex ante at the firm/interview level and merged into the survey instrument.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented ex ante in Stata at the firm/interview level prior to fieldwork and merged into the CATI/CAWI instrument. Each sampled establishment is pre-assigned a complete set of six candidate profiles (A–F) that fully determines the left and right profiles in each of the three choices. Randomization is stratified by region and uses blocked procedures within strata to achieve balanced 50/50 splits for all binary attributes and to enforce the intended 50:50 share of the two Choice 3 pair types. A fixed random seed and a reproducible generation log are retained. All randomized attributes are binary: gender (woman vs. man), migration background (born abroad vs. born in Germany), parenthood (has children vs. childless), and a performance signal (excellent vs. average). The assignment follows simple design restrictions: within each choice, the two candidates are identical in all non-focal attributes, and only the focal attribute differs across left and right; left–right placement is balanced by construction. In Choices 1–2, the performance signal is drawn once per respondent and held constant, migration is constant within a choice but toggles across the two choices, and gender is mirrored to balance side presentation. In Choice 3, respondents are assigned to either a migration pair (contrast in migration background) or a parenthood pair (contrast in parenthood), with remaining attributes held equal within the pair and randomized across respondents.
Randomization unit
Firm
Observations
1000
Arms
1000
Primary outcomes
In each of three allocation choices, respondents assign 0–4 remote-work days per week (half-days allowed) across two candidates. The primary outcome is the within-pair allocation difference, coded so that positive values indicate an advantage for the focal attribute in that choice (mother vs. father in Choices 1–2; migrant vs. non-migrant or parent vs. childless in Choice 3, depending on arm). A key secondary outcome is the total number of days granted within a pair (the sum across the two candidates), capturing overall generosity and enabling analysis of performance effects on the extensive margin of granting remote work. After Choice 2, respondents also report (i) a third-person benchmark allocation for the same pair, (ii) which candidate would be more productive when working from home, and (iii) which candidate is more likely to decline if no remote work is offered; the module concludes with a short battery of 0–10 attitude items on perceived consequences of remote work. For more details, see attached pre-analysis plan.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords