Shaping social norms: how experience affects moral judgments
How to cite
HENRY, EMERIC; Galbiati, Roberto; Jacquemet, Nicolas. 2026. "Shaping social norms: how experience affects moral judgments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017858. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17858-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study aims to investigate how personal experience with a decision influences individuals’ moral judgments of others’ behavior in a charitable giving context. The project builds on the idea that individuals strategically manage their self-image, including through the avoidance of payoff-relevant information, and introduces a “coherence principle,” In the online experiment we propose, participants are randomly assigned to the role of passive or active observers. Passive observers will evaluate others’ donation decisions before making their own donation choice, while active observers will make a donation decision first and subsequently evaluate others. We will also vary the access of participants to the information on the NGO to which they can donate. The study is designed to assess whether facing a similar decision affects judgments of pro-social versus selfish behavior, and whether information avoidance during one’s own decision persists when judging others.
Intervention
We have 4 treatments:
T1: Active observer treatment. Participants must make a donation choice, described below. They are told that their actions will be observed by another participant in the experiment (without specifying what this participant does). In a second stage, they judge the action of a randomly matched participant. We specify that this player knew that he would be observed.
• T2: Passive observer treatment. The order is reversed compared to the active observer treatment. First a judgement is made on the action of a randomly matched participant. Then the player makes the donation decision and is told her action will be observed.
• T3-T4: same treatments as those described above, but where the participants are offered the possibility to see the identity of the NGO in the donation decision.
Experimental design
The experiment will be run using an online panel administered by the LEEP in Paris 1 univeristy. It will be programmed in O-tree.
Subjects first respond to a survey on socio-demographic characteristics. The initial questions also include survey items designed to measure the level of altruism. The answers to these questions will be used as predictors of whether participants are likely to donate.
The users are then allocated to 4 treatment groups.
• T1: Active observer treatment. Participants must make a donation choice, described below. They are told that their actions will be observed by another participant in the experiment (without specifying what this participant does). In a second stage, they judge the action of a randomly matched participant (i.e donation decision of another active observer). We specify that this player knew that he would be observed.
• T2: Passive observer treatment. The order is reversed compared to the active observer treatment. First a judgement is made on the action of a randomly matched participant. Then the player makes the donation decision and is told her action will be observed.
• T3-T4: same treatments as those described above, but where the participants are offered the possibility to see the identity of the NGO in the donation decision.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.