Synthetic Identity and the Dilution of Opportunity Cost: A longitudinal study on the erosion of financial agency under predictive algorithms).

How to cite

Lopez, Francisco Jacobo Murillo. 2026. "Synthetic Identity and the Dilution of Opportunity Cost: A longitudinal study on the erosion of financial agency under predictive algorithms).." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017833. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17833-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francisco Jacobo Murillo Lopez*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017833
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17833-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-09 – 2026-07-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D91 D12 D83 L81 M37
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17833

Abstract

This study investigates how predictive recommendation algorithms in e-commerce platforms influence consumer sovereignty and financial decision-making. We introduce the concept of "Synthetic Identity"—a digital profile co-created by algorithms—and hypothesize that individuals increasingly prioritize purchases that validate this digital persona over traditional rational budget constraints.

Using a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a 16-week longitudinal panel design, we track 180 young adults in Mexico. The treatment group is exposed to high-fidelity predictive environments, while the control group interacts with neutral search interfaces. We measure three primary dimensions: (1) perceived financial agency, (2) identity-algorithm affinity, and (3) shifts in spending patterns (opportunity cost). Data is collected through weekly Experience Sampling Methodology (ESM) and pre/post-expenditure audits.

The analysis employs Differences-in-Differences (DiD) and Latent Growth Models (LGM) to identify the specific point where algorithmic influence begins to erode human agency. This research contributes to behavioral economics by redefining the "opportunity cost" in the age of Artificial Intelligence

Intervention

The study implements a randomized intervention with two arms to compare the effects of predictive personalization on consumer agency:

Treatment Group (High-Fidelity Predictive Interface): Participants in this group interact with a simulated e-commerce environment (via an API overlay or specialized browser extension) that utilizes a "Synthetic Identity" engine. This engine goes beyond standard recommendations by predicting "future-self" desires, utilizing high-frequency behavioral data to nudge users toward purchases that align with an algorithmically generated persona rather than their historical budget constraints. The intervention includes daily personalized notifications and a "predictive cart" feature.

Control Group (Neutral Search Interface): Participants interact with a standard search-based interface. Recommendations are limited to "top-rated" or "generic category" items, requiring the user to initiate the search process and maintain active authorship over their browsing path without predictive identity-nudging.

Key components of the intervention across 16 weeks:

Experience Sampling (ESM): Weekly triggers to measure perceived agency and identity-algorithm affinity.

Identity Nudging: The treatment group receives prompts specifically designed to test the "Synthetic Identity" hypothesis (e.g., "This item matches your evolving style").

Measurement: Continuous tracking of spending (spent_mxn) and time spent on platform (use_minutes_week).

Experimental design

The study employs a between-subjects, randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a longitudinal panel design spanning 16 weeks. The goal is to isolate the effect of predictive personalization on financial decision-making and consumer agency.

1. Participant Selection and Randomization: A sample of 180 young adults (ages 18-35) will be recruited and screened for baseline digital literacy and shopping habits. Participants will be randomly assigned to one of two parallel arms with a 1:1 allocation ratio:

Group A (Control): Access to a neutral e-commerce interface using standard search-based navigation.

Group B (Treatment): Access to an enhanced interface driven by a high-fidelity predictive engine ("Synthetic Identity" model).

2. Data Collection Phases:

Baseline (Month 0): Comprehensive assessment of historical spending patterns across 8 categories, psychological profiling (impulsivity, agency, and self-concept), and digital literacy.

Intervention Phase (Weeks 1–16): Participants interact with their assigned interface. Weekly data is collected via Experience Sampling Methodology (ESM) to track real-time changes in perceived agency, identity affinity, and decision authorship.

Outcome Audits (Monthly): Detailed expenditure reports are generated at the end of each month to measure shifts in budget allocation and the dilution of opportunity cost.

3. Analysis Strategy: The primary analysis will use a Differences-in-Differences (DiD) approach to compare the evolution of spending and agency between the two groups. Additionally, Latent Growth Curve Modeling (LGCM) will be applied to the longitudinal data to identify the trajectory of "agency erosion" over the four-month period.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization Method The randomization was performed in-office via a computer-generated algorithm (using R's set.seed() function for reproducibility). To ensure the internal validity of the study and account for individual differences that could confound the results, we employed a stratified randomization approach based on the following baseline characteristics: Algorithmic Literacy: Participants were stratified into high and low digital literacy groups. Innate Impulsivity (Barratt Impulsiveness Scale): To ensure that the "Synthetic Identity" effect is not merely a reflection of pre-existing impulsivity. Process: After the baseline assessment (Month 0), the sample of 180 participants was divided into strata. Within each stratum, individuals were assigned to either Group A (Control) or Group B (Treatment) using a simple random number generator (1:1 allocation ratio). This process ensures that both arms of the study are balanced regarding their psychological profiles and technical skills before the 16-week exposure begins.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the individual. Justification: The intervention is delivered at the individual user level through personalized e-commerce interfaces. Since the primary outcomes focus on personal financial agency, individual psychological constructs (identity affinity), and private expenditure patterns, individual-level randomization is the most robust method to isolate the causal effect of algorithmic influence. There is no cluster-level randomization (e.g., at the household or geographical level) in this study design.
Clusters
180 Individuals
Observations
180 Individuals
Arms
90 individuals control, 90 individuals treatment (Synthetic Identity algorithm)
Primary outcomes
1. Divergence in Spending Patterns (Economic) Variable name: spent_mxn (Category Divergence). Description: Total monthly expenditure across 8 categories (Groceries, Fashion, Electronics, Fitness, Outdoor, Beauty, Gaming, Home). Measure: Difference in Mexican Pesos (MXN) between Month 0 (Baseline) and Month 4 (Post-intervention). Time of measurement: Month 0 and Month 4. 2. Perceived Financial Agency (Psychological) Variable name: agency_scale. Description: A composite index measuring the individual's sense of authorship and control over their purchase decisions. This is calculated as the average of the sub-scales: authorship, trust in own judgment vs. algorithm, and intention-action gap. Measure: Scale from 1 to 5 (Likert). Time of measurement: Weekly (from Week 1 to Week 16) via ESM. 3. Identity-Algorithm Affinity (Relational) Variable name: id_affinity (Synthetic Identity Congruence). Description: The degree to which the participant perceives the algorithm's suggestions as a reflection of their "true" or "evolving" self. Measure: Scale from 1 to 5 (Likert). Time of measurement: Weekly (from Week 1 to Week 16) via ESM.
Secondary outcomes
Para completar los Secondary Outcomes, debemos incluir aquellas variables que, aunque no son el corazón de tu hipótesis, aportan evidencia crucial sobre el impacto colateral de la Identidad Sintética. Aquí tienes los tres puntos finales secundarios basados en tus modelos de validación: 1. Post-Purchase Regret (Arrepentimiento de Compra) Outcome Name: post_purchase_regret Description: An assessment of the cognitive dissonance experienced after a transaction. This measures if the "Synthetic Identity" purchase leads to long-term satisfaction or immediate buyer's remorse. Measure: Scale from 1 to 5 (Likert). Timepoint(s): Monthly (Months 1 through 4) and 15 days after the final intervention. 2. Platform Engagement and Time Sunk (Uso de Plataforma) Outcome Name: use_minutes_week Description: The total amount of time spent interacting with the commerce interface. This helps determine if the "dilution of opportunity cost" is correlated with an increase in time spent within the algorithmic environment. Measure: Continuous variable (Minutes per week). Timepoint(s): Weekly for 16 weeks. 3. Algorithmic Trust vs. Human Expertise (Confianza Algorítmica) Outcome Name: trust_ratio Description: The ratio of acceptance of algorithmic suggestions versus external search results or peer recommendations. Measure: Ratio (Accepted Suggestions / Total External Searches). Timepoint(s): Bi-weekly during the 16-week period.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords