Job-matching for Displaced Populations in El Salvador

How to cite

Sviatschi, Maria Micaela; Melnikov, Nikita; Padilla, Carlos Schmidt. 2026. "Job-matching for Displaced Populations in El Salvador." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017827. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17827-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maria Micaela Sviatschi* , Nikita Melnikov , Carlos Schmidt Padilla

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017827
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17827-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-15 – 2027-12-31
Countries
El Salvador ()
JEL codes
K42; I25; J24; O54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17827

Abstract

Displaced individuals and residents from former gang-controlled neighborhoods frequently face employment discrimination stemming from employers' apprehension about potential gang affiliation. In partnership with INCAF in El Salvador, this study proposes a randomized controlled trial that subsidizes firms to offer apprenticeship contracts to displaced individuals lacking formal work experience. The participants will engage in five-month work contracts, with two months fully subsidized by INCAF and the research team. This subsidy aims to overcome the frictions preventing firms from hiring first-time job seekers from marginalized communities, both due to their lack of employment experience and their perceived association with criminal actors. By reducing these hiring costs, we seek to examine the long-term impact on the participants' labor market outcomes and overall socioeconomic status. We also aim to analyze whether this program can effectively combat firms' biases against hiring displaced individuals from former gang- controlled communities.

Intervention

The intervention to be evaluated consists of subsidizing two months of wages for displaced first- time job seekers from former gang-controlled communities. This short-term subsidy is expected to help overcome the structural barriers to formal employment faced by these individuals, leading to increased short-term and long-term formal employment, development of job-related skills, improved socioeconomic conditions, and reduced risks of future displacement. On the side of employers, the increase in exposure to displaced workers from former gang neighborhoods is expected to impact the firms’ hiring decisions, making them permanently more willing to hire individuals from these communities.

Target population and sample size:

The main target population of this study consists of displaced individuals from communities that were previously under the de facto control of the gangs. We aim to recruit a total of 2,000 eligible participants, 1,300 of whom will be invited to participate in the program, while the remaining 700 will be in the control group. Based on the previous waves of this program, we anticipate that 1,300 invitations to participate in the program will result in approximately 140 long-term contracts signed between the workers and the firms. We also aim to recruit a total of 600 eligible firms that are willing to hire the participants of the program, 300 of which will be invited to participate in the program, while the remaining 300 will be in the control group. Based on the previous waves of this program, we anticipate that the participation of approximately 300 firms is required to sign 140 long-term contracts between the workers and the firms.

Study or evaluation design:

On the worker side, the ideal implementation of the treatment would have the following structure:

1. Together with INCAF, we would recruit 2,000 eligible displaced individuals from communities that were previously under the de facto control of the gangs.

2. At the time an individual is recruited, they will be asked to participate in a baseline survey about their education, training, and other sociodemographic characteristics. Once the baseline survey is completed, we will randomly select 1,300 participants who will be invited to participate in the program. Based on the previous waves of this program, we anticipate that 1,300 invitations to participate in the program will result in approximately 140 long-term contracts signed between the workers and the firms. The remaining 700 individuals will be assigned to the control group.

3. We will conduct post-treatment surveys with all the individuals recruited into the program four months after the treatment (i.e., when the subsidy expires) and a year after the treatment to determine the effects of the program on their labor market outcomes and other socioeconomic conditions in the short and long run.

On the firm side, the implementation of the treatment will have the following structure:

1. Together with the INCAF, we would recruit 600 eligible firms that are willing to hire the participants of the apprenticeship program.

2. At the time the firms are recruited, they will be asked to participate in a baseline survey about their hiring practices. Once the baseline survey is completed, we will randomly select 300 firms that will be invited to participate in the program. Based on the previous waves of this program, we anticipate that approximately 300 firms are required to sign 140 long-term contracts between the workers and the firms. The remaining 300 firms will be assigned to the control group.

3. Once the program is concluded and the firms stop receiving the subsidies for the newly hired workers, we will conduct follow-up surveys with all the initially surveyed firms to determine whether participation in the INCAF program affected their hiring practices.

Implementing partner(s): This study will be performed in partnership with the INCAF in El Salvador. INCAF, the National Institute for Formation, is a government entity in El Salvador that recently received oversight responsibility for skills training and job programs from the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection (MTPS). Thus, given INCAF’s mandate, if the program is successful, it has the potential to be scaled up and implemented at the national level.

Experimental design

This is a two-sided randomized controlled trial with parallel randomizations of workers and firms.

Worker-Side Design:

Together with INCAF, recruit 2,000 eligible displaced individuals from communities formerly under gang control. Upon recruitment, administer baseline survey covering education, training, and sociodemographic characteristics. Randomly assign 1,300 to treatment (program invitation) and 700 to control using computer-based randomization in Stata. Stratify by gender, age group, education level, and municipality. Conduct follow-up surveys at 4 months (short-run) and 12 months (long-run) post-treatment with all recruited individuals.

Firm-Side Design:

Together with INCAF, recruit 600 eligible firms willing to hire program participants. Upon recruitment, administer baseline survey on hiring practices. Randomly assign 300 firms to treatment (eligible to hire subsidized workers) and 300 to control using computer-based randomization. Stratify by firm size, sector, and geographic location. Conduct follow-up surveys at 12 months post-program to assess hiring behavior changes.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based randomization using Stata's random number generator
Randomization unit
Individual level for workers; firm level for employers. No clustering in randomization design.
Clusters
Not applicable - no clustering
Observations
Worker sample: 2,000 individuals (1,300 treatment, 700 control) Firm sample: 600 firms (300 treatment, 300 control)
Arms
Worker sample: 2,000 individuals (1,300 treatment, 700 control) Firm sample: 600 firms (300 treatment, 300 control)
Primary outcomes
Worker-Side Primary Outcomes: 1. Formal Employment Status 2. Job related skills 3. Socioeconomic conditions Firm-Side Primary Outcome: 3. Firms hiring decisions: Number of workers hired from former gang-controlled neighborhoods following program completion.
Secondary outcomes
Overall, the project will evaluate the effects of the apprenticeship program on displaced individuals from communities that were previously under the control of criminal groups. Thus, in addition to the standard barriers to formal employment encountered by young, poor, and less educated job seekers, these individuals also routinely face employment discrimination due to employers’ fear that they might be affiliated with gangs. Such instances of employment discrimination particularly affect individuals whose demographic profile most closely matches those of active gang members (i.e., young, less educated, male). Consequently, we anticipate the effects of the program to be particularly pronounced for these sub-populations, and we intend to evaluate this hypothesis as a part of our project.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords