Rational Arbitrage or Behavioural Friction? Isolating the Microfoundations of Demand for Buy Now, Pay Later
How to cite
Caballero, Juan Sebastian Medina. 2026. "Rational Arbitrage or Behavioural Friction? Isolating the Microfoundations of Demand for Buy Now, Pay Later." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017819. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17819-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This experimental study investigates the micro-foundations of demand for “Buy Now, Pay Later” (BNPL) credit, specifically isolating the role of surcharge aversion in intertemporal decision-making.
Current BNPL market structures often hide the cost of credit from consumers through “No Surcharge Rules” (NSRs). This study tests whether consumer demand for immediate liquidity is driven by rational time preferences (standard discounting) or by behavioural responses to how price is framed.
Using an money-earlier-or-later (MEL) design via multiple price lists (MPLs), participants face mathematically equivalent intertemporal choices framed in two distinct ways:
1. Discount Frame: The cost of immediate payment is presented as an opportunity cost (a forgone discount).
2. Surcharge Frame: The cost of immediate payment is presented as an explicit fee (a surcharge).
By comparing the Individual Discount Rates (IDR) across these treatments, the study identifies the causal effect of price framing on credit demand.
Intervention
The experiment utilizes an incentivized Multiple Price List (MPL) design to elicit individual discount rates (IDR) under two distinct framing conditions. Participants face a series of intertemporal choices between a smaller, immediate reward (t = 0) and a larger, delayed reward (t = 4 weeks). The principal value is fixed at £60.
1. Treatment 1 (T1): Time discounting (control): Standard intertemporal choice task where the cost of liquidity is presented as an opportunity cost.
1.1 Option A (Now): Receive £X.
1.2 Option B (Later): Receive £60.
2. Treatment 2 (T2): Loss (surcharge) aversion (fee frame): Mathematically isomorphic to the control, but the cost of liquidity is framed as an explicit “transaction fee” or surcharge.
2.1 Option A (Now): Receive £60 minus £Y Fee.
2.2 Option B (Later): Receive £60 (Free).
The net present value (NPV) of Option A in T2, is identical to the Control condition for every row. This isolates the behavioural effect of “surcharge aversion” from standard time preferences.
To Ensure incentive compatibility, the study employs a Random Incentive System (RIS). One row from one MPL is randomly selected for payment implementation.
Experimental design
This study is a 2x1 between-subjects Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) designed to elicit individual discount rates (IDRs) under varying descriptive frames. The experiment is conducted online and consists of four distinct phases:
Phase 1: Endowment Induction (Real Effort Task). To mitigate “house money effects” and ensure engagement, all participants must first complete a Real Effort Task (counting zeros in matrices) to earn their study endowment. Only successful completion grants access to the main decision stage.
Phase 2: The Main Intervention (Time Preference Elicitation). Participants are randomly assigned to one of two experimental groups. In both groups, participants face a Multiple Price List (MPL) consisting of 10 binary choices between a smaller immediate reward (“Tonight”) and a larger delayed reward (“In 4 Weeks”). The Net Present Value (NPV) of the choices are mathematically identical across groups; only the framing of the immediate deduction varies:
- Group 1 (Standard Frame): The immediate option is presented as a reduced principal amount (e.g. “Receive £59.40”).
- Group 2 (Surcharge Frame): The immediate option is presented as the full principal minus a transaction fee (e.g. “Receive £60.00 minus a £0.60 fee”).
Phase 3: Structural Parameter Elicitation. Following the main intervention, all participants complete a secondary incentivized task to elicit risk preferences, utilising the Holt & Laury (2002) Multiple Price List. This allows for the joint estimation of utility curvature and time preference. Subsequently, participants report their “Cognitive Uncertainty” regarding their previous choices (Enke & Graeber, 2023).
Phase 4: Demographics & Financial Literacy. The study concludes with a survey collecting demographic data, a validated Financial Literacy score (Lusardi & Mitchell, 2011), and self-reported credit usage metrics.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.