Delivering Foundational Skills, Mentorship, and Agency through Remote Instruction
How to cite
Callen, Michael; Angrist, Noam; Cullen, Claire; Dam, Anaya; Dube, Oeindrila; Muthukumaran, Saipremnath. 2026. "Delivering Foundational Skills, Mentorship, and Agency through Remote Instruction." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017807. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17807-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study the role of remote instruction in building foundational skills and promoting agency and empowerment. We conduct a randomized controlled trial with 2,399 children aged 7–16 in Afghanistan, a setting where access to formal schooling, labor markets, and public life is constrained for girls. The experiment evaluates two phone-based interventions delivered weekly over eight weeks: (i) one-on-one foundational literacy and numeracy tutoring using a teaching-at-the-right-level approach (ConnectEd tutoring arm), and (ii) structured conversations with a trained teacher (Structured conversations arm). A third group serves as a control and receives no intervention.
The study is designed to address four questions. First, can low-tech, remote instruction improve foundational learning in settings of prolonged educational disruption? Second, can this type of instruction lead to gains in agency? Third, are any observed gains in agency driven primarily by skill acquisition itself or by sustained interaction with trained adult mentors? Fourth, are there well-being impacts—positive or negative—of receiving education when structural constraints restrict opportunities?
Primary outcomes include standardized indices of foundational literacy and numeracy as well as agency and empowerment. We measure the latter across five dimensions: (i) curiosity, reasoning, and aspirations; (ii) confidence and self-efficacy; (iii) social capabilities; (iv) parents’ confidence in their child’s capabilities; and (v) civic agency and institutional engagement, using a combination of behavioral tasks, real-effort choices, and incidental indicators. Secondary outcomes include adjacent cognitive skills not taught during the tutoring sessions, child well-being, and household gender attitudes.
Intervention
The study consists of three experimental arms: (i) ConnectEd Tutoring, (ii) Structured Conversation, or (iii) a control group receiving no intervention.
(i) ConnectEd Tutoring
The intervention in this arm delivers one-on-one instruction in foundational literacy and numeracy with a female teacher through a weekly phone call lasting 25-30 minutes over an eight-week period. Instruction starts with the literacy sequence then the numeracy sequence. Instruction and progression is aligned to the one target child per household using a teaching at the right level approach. A child begins
with literacy instruction at the level determined by a baseline learning assessment. The pedagogy is delivered through structured calling guides that teachers follow to conduct each lesson.
(ii) Structured Conversation
The intervention in this arm delivers a one-on-one structured conversation with a female teacher through a weekly phone call lasting 25-30 minutes over an eight-week period. It explicitly does not provide foundational literacy or numeracy instruction. This
arm is designed to mirror the flow, structure, and length of the ConnectEd Tutoring arm. As in the ConnectEd tutoring arm, teachers follow a structured calling guideline that specifies the questions to ask and the intended flow of the conversation.
Experimental design
We conduct a three-arm randomized controlled trial to estimate the impacts of remote, phone-based interventions on children’s learning and empowerment outcomes in Afghanistan. The study sample consists of 2,399 households, each contributing one target child aged 7–16 and their primary caregiver. The sample was drawn from a household listing exercise covering approximately 10,000 households across 26 provinces and prioritizes girls of the age group with limited access to education.
Following completion of a baseline phone survey and eligibility verification, households were randomly assigned at the household level to one of three arms: (i) ConnectEd Tutoring, (ii) Structured Conversation, or (iii) a control group receiving no intervention. Randomization was stratified on baseline learning level (above/below median), baseline empowerment (above/below median), schooling status (in school/out of school), and child’s primary language (Dari or Pashto), yielding 16 strata, with an additional stratum for boys. Within each stratum, assignment was approximately evenly split across the three arms.
The ConnectEd Tutoring arm delivers weekly one-on-one phone-based instruction in foundational literacy followed by numeracy, using a teaching-at-the-right-level approach, over an eight-week period. The Structured Conversation arm delivers weekly one-on-one phone calls of equal length with a female teacher, focused on guided conversation topics and explicitly excluding academic instruction. The control group receives no calls during the study period. All interventions are delivered by trained teachers and last approximately 25–30 minutes per week.
Primary outcomes are measured via endline phone surveys conducted after the eight-week intervention period and include assessments of foundational literacy and numeracy and adjacent cognitive skills not taught during the tutoring sessions, measures of empowerment and agency, and measures of well being and gender attitudes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.