This study investigates how source attribution affects consumer delegation of financial decisions to algorithmic advisors. Using a randomized controlled experiment, we examine whether institutional branding (Bank Advisor vs AI Advisor vs unlabeled baseline) influences willingness to delegate credit card optimization choices, and how performance feedback (positive vs negative) moderates trust updating across source types.
Participants complete credit card selection scenarios, receive feedback attributed to either a Bank Advisor or AI Advisor, then face a delegation decision where they can accept or override a recommendation from the same source. We measure behavioral delegation (accept/override decisions, reliance weight) and mechanism variables (perceived competence, benevolence, integrity, agency conflict).
The study contributes to literatures on algorithm aversion, institutional trust, and financial decision-making by testing whether institutional reputation acts as a "trust buffer" that protects algorithmic advice from the confidence decay typically observed after errors. Findings will inform how financial institutions should frame AI-assisted advice to consumers.
Intervention
Participants are randomly assigned to receive financial advice attributed to one of three sources: (1) Bank Advisor, (2) AI Advisor, or (3) an unlabeled baseline condition. In the Feedback Arm, participants first receive performance feedback (positive or negative) on earlier credit card choices before making a delegation decision. In the Control Arm, participants proceed directly to the delegation decision without feedback.
Experimental design
Between-subjects randomized controlled trial with two arms:
Feedback Arm (50%): 2×2 factorial design crossing Source (Bank Advisor vs AI Advisor) with Feedback Valence (Positive vs Negative). Valence is determined by participant's accuracy on randomly-selected feedback scenario.
Control Arm (50%): Three-way randomization of Source (Bank Advisor vs AI Advisor vs Neutral) without feedback exposure.
All participants complete identical credit card optimization scenarios and a final delegation task (Scenario 5).
Design details
Randomization method
Computer-generated randomization via Qualtrics survey software.
Randomization uses Qualtrics "Evenly Present Elements" function to ensure
balanced allocation across conditions. Nested randomization: participants
first randomized to Feedback vs Control arm (50/50), then randomized to
Source conditions within arm (50/50 for Feedback; 33/33/33 for Control).
Randomization unit
Individual participant. Each participant is independently randomized to
one experimental condition. No clustering or group-level randomization.
Clusters
N/A - Individual-level randomization, no clustering.
Observations
600 participants (individual respondents recruited via Pureprofile online
panel, Australian adults)
Arms
FEEDBACK ARM (n=300 total):
- Bank Advisor: n=150 (Positive: ~75, Negative: ~75)
- AI Advisor: n=150 (Positive: ~75, Negative: ~75)
CONTROL ARM (n=300 total):
- Bank Advisor: n=100
- AI Advisor: n=100
- Neutral: n=100
Note: Within Feedback Arm, Positive/Negative split depends on participant
accuracy and is expected to be approximately balanced but not guaranteed.
Primary outcomes
1. S5_AcceptOverride: Binary decision to accept or override the
recommendation in Scenario 5 (Accept=1, Override=0)
2. S5_Reliance: Continuous measure (0-100) of how much participants want
the recommendation to determine their final choice
3. SwitchStick: Binary decision to change or keep original choice after
receiving feedback (Feedback Arm only)
Secondary outcomes
1. Trust_Ability: Perceived competence of the advisor to choose the
lowest-cost option (5-point Likert scale)
2. Trust_Benevolence: Perceived alignment of advisor with participant's
financial interests (5-point Likert scale)
3. Trust_Integrity: Perceived consistency and rule-following of advisor
(5-point Likert scale)
4. Agency_Conflict: Perceived financial motive/conflict of interest
behind recommendation (7-point scale)
5. Perceived_Algorithmicity: Belief about whether recommendation was
generated by computer/algorithm vs human judgment (5-point scale)
6. MC_Source_Recall: Whether participant correctly identifies the source
of the recommendation (categorical: Bank/AI/Neutral/Other)
7. MC_Pass: Binary indicator of correct source recall (1=correct, 0=incorrect)
8. S5_MatchAttribution: For participants whose initial choice matched the
recommendation, whether acceptance was influenced by the recommendation
or independent (Influenced/Independent/N/A)
9. Risk_SOEP: General risk tolerance (0-10 scale, SOEP validated item)
10. Task_Objectivity: Perceived objectivity of credit card optimization
task (7-point scale)
11. Delegation_Propensity: General preference for making own choices vs
letting experts decide (7-point scale)
12. AI_Trust_General: Baseline trust in AI systems for decisions/
recommendations (0-10 scale)
13. Bank_Trust_General: Baseline trust in banks to act in customers'
financial interests (0-10 scale)
14. Ambiguity_Aversion: Preference for known vs unknown probabilities
(Ellsberg urn task - categorical)
15. FinLit_Total: Financial literacy score (0-3, sum of correct responses
to Lusardi & Mitchell "Big Three" items)
16. Correct_S1 through Correct_S4: Accuracy on each of the four initial
scenarios (binary: 1=correct, 0=incorrect)
17. Total_Correct: Sum of correct responses across Scenarios 1-4 (0-4)
18. Valence_Determinism: Classification of participant's overall accuracy
pattern (AllCorrect/AllWrong/Mixed)
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.