Three voices, one decision: sharing information to support student aspirations.

How to cite

Ghisolfi, Selene; Casarico, Alessandra; Serra, Chiara; Malisan, Ilaria; Marcolongo, Giovanna; Ovidi, Marco. 2026. "Three voices, one decision: sharing information to support student aspirations.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017740. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17740-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Selene Ghisolfi* , Alessandra Casarico , Chiara Serra , Ilaria Malisan , Giovanna Marcolongo , Marco Ovidi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017740
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17740-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-09-01 – 2028-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I20, I21, I24, I28, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17740

Abstract

Italy’s tracked upper‑secondary school system requires students to make binding choices at age 14, yet mismatch between chosen tracks and students’ skills or aspirations is common. Over‑placement—selecting a more demanding track than readiness—raises the risk of grade repetition, dropout, and long‑term exclusion, while under‑placement—especially among high‑ability students from low‑SES or immigrant families—limits achievement and mobility. Evidence suggests that misalignment in assessment and expectations between families and teachers, teacher bias and families’ limited knowledge of school tracks contribute to this mismatch, and that facilitating dialogue can improve outcomes for disadvantaged students.
Current orientation practices provide information but rarely foster dialogue among students, parents, and teachers, leaving valuable insights fragmented. This project, developed within an agreement with the Municipality of Milan, proposes and evaluates a scalable intervention designed to improve alignment in track preferences through structured three‑way communication and transparent information on track characteristics. The intervention (i) formalizes preference‑sharing among students, parents, and teachers and (ii) provides comparative data on curricula, workload, promotion rates, and post‑secondary prospects. The RCT will measure impacts on track selection, first‑year failure, and dropout, assessing heterogeneity by migrant status, socioeconomic background, and gender.
By addressing a critical transition point, the study aims to generate actionable evidence for policies that promote educational inclusion and reduce inequality in Italy’s tracked system, and provide empirical contribution to understand the causes of school mismatch. If effective, the intervention could be integrated into orientation practices nationwide, offering a low‑cost, high‑impact tool to improve educational trajectories and foster social mobility among vulnerable youth.

Intervention

The intervention identifies students whose high‑school track preferences diverge from those of their parents and teachers, and provides all agents involved with a simple “alignment chart” showing each party’s stated preference to encourage dialogue before the orientation recommendation. In a cross‑randomized design, some schools also receive a brief newsletter with comparative information on high‑school tracks (curricula, workload, promotion rates, post‑secondary options). The goal is to improve alignment, knowledge, and ultimately track choice.

Experimental design

The study uses an individually randomized controlled trial, combined with a school-level cross-randomization. First, all 8th-grade students, their parents, and their teachers complete baseline questionnaires reporting their preferences and expectations regarding the student’s high-school track choice. Using this information, the research team identifies students for whom these preferences diverge. These “misaligned” students are randomly assigned at the individual level to either a treatment or control group, stratified by class and by the type of misalignment (whether the student and parents are more ambitious than the teacher, or the opposite). Students in the treatment group receive an alignment chart that displays the stated preferences of the student, the parent, and the teacher. The chart is delivered through the school’s electronic register between one and three months before the high-school track choice, in order to prompt discussion among the three actors before the teacher issues the formal recommendation.
Independently, at the school level, a second treatment is randomly assigned. In treated schools, families receive a short informational newsletter describing key characteristics of each high-school track, including curricula, workload, historical promotion rates, and post-secondary prospects. This creates a cross-randomized design that allows the study to isolate the effect of preference disclosure, the effect of additional information, and their interaction.
A subgroup of 7th-grade students also receives the intervention earlier in the school path to test whether timing affects engagement and outcomes. The study measures impacts on teacher recommendations, students’ pre-enrolment choices, self-reported final enrolment decisions, knowledge of tracks, and communication within families and between families and teachers.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
individual for alignment chart treatment, school level for information treatment
Clusters
10 schools with 1500-1800 students of which 450 in the alignment treatment
Observations
1500-1800 of which 450 in the treatment
Arms
225 in alignment treatment and 225 in control group ; 5 schools in newsletter treatment and 5 in control group
Primary outcomes
Track choice outcomes: Pre-enrolment high-school track choice (student stated choice in January–February). Self-reported final enrolment choice (end of school year). Teacher recommendation: Non-binding “consiglio orientativo” provided to 8th-grade students. First-year high-school grades and grade retention
Secondary outcomes
Misalignment / match quality: Alignment between student, parent, and teacher track preferences, measured through the misalignment index constructed from baseline and endline surveys. Knowledge and information outcomes: Knowledge of high-school tracks, including curricula, workload, promotion rates, and post-secondary prospects. Communication and decision-process outcomes: Frequency and quality of communication between parents, students, and teachers, particularly whether the intervention stimulated additional discussion about the high-school choice.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords