Shaping aspirations among the poor through digital self-diagnosis and mentoring: Evidence from a randomized trial in Honduras

How to cite

Maldonado, Stanislao. 2026. "Shaping aspirations among the poor through digital self-diagnosis and mentoring: Evidence from a randomized trial in Honduras." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017730. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17730-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stanislao Maldonado*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017730
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17730-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-08-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, I32, D91, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17730

Abstract

A growing literature argues that poverty is not only a constraint on resources but also on aspirations and agency, potentially generating self-reinforcing poverty traps. We evaluate a digitally enabled “Poverty Stoplight” (PSL) goal-setting intervention designed to address these constraints by structuring aspiration formation and translating aspirations into actionable goals. The intervention is delivered by Unbound in Honduras and supports households in conducting a guided self-assessment of multidimensional deprivations across 50 indicators in six domains, followed by prioritization and step-by-step goal setting.

We implement a cluster-randomized controlled trial comparing standard Unbound programming to PSL delivered (i) without mentoring, (ii) with individual mentoring, and (iii) with group-based mentoring. Building on theories of the capacity to aspire and collective agency, we hypothesize that the PSL increases aspirations and individual agency, and that group mentoring may further strengthen collective agency by leveraging social interaction, peer learning, and shared goal-setting.

Randomization occurs at the social-promoter cluster level, and participants are followed for approximately one year. The baseline sample includes 2,623 caregivers across 11 departments and 62 municipalities in Honduras. Primary outcomes include measures of critical (individual) agency, collective agency, aspirations across key life domains (education, occupation, housing, and savings), and disaggregated multidimensional poverty indicators. The study contributes experimental evidence on whether digitally facilitated self-diagnosis and mentoring can relax aspiration-related constraints among the poor and complement traditional anti-poverty programming.

Intervention

The study evaluates a digitally enabled “Poverty Stoplight” (PSL) intervention integrated into Unbound’s existing sponsorship program in Honduras. The PSL is a structured goal-setting tool that guides participating households through a self-assessment of their living conditions across multiple dimensions of poverty and supports them in identifying and prioritizing concrete, step-by-step goals.

Using a mobile or tablet-based platform, households assess their situation across 50 indicators covering six domains, such as education, health, housing, income, and financial security. Based on this self-diagnosis, participants identify areas of deprivation and set achievable goals to improve their conditions over time.

The study compares four versions of program delivery. A control group receives standard Unbound programming, which includes light-touch goal discussions and unstructured group meetings. Three treatment groups receive the PSL tool in addition to standard programming: one group uses the PSL without formal mentoring, one group receives individual mentoring to support goal-setting and follow-up, and one group participates in group-based mentoring sessions designed to encourage peer interaction, shared learning, and collective problem-solving. Mentoring sessions occur quarterly, with more frequent remote follow-ups.

The intervention lasts approximately 13 months and is delivered at the community level through Unbound’s existing network of social promoters.

Experimental design

The study uses a clustered randomized controlled trial to evaluate a digitally enabled Poverty Stoplight (PSL) intervention delivered through Unbound’s existing sponsorship program in Honduras. Households are assigned to one of four study arms: an active control group receiving standard Unbound programming, and three treatment groups receiving the PSL tool with varying levels of mentoring support (no mentoring, individual mentoring, or group mentoring).

Randomization is conducted at the social-promoter cluster level to minimize spillovers between participants. Each cluster consists of approximately 7–14 households, and clusters are assigned to treatment arms in approximately equal proportions. The intervention is implemented over a period of approximately 13 months, and outcomes are measured using baseline and endline household surveys.

The primary outcomes of interest include aspirations, individual agency, collective agency, and multidimensional poverty indicators.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented in Stata using block and stratified assignment at the cluster level, with a reproducible random seed. Following Morgan and Rubin (2012), a re-randomization procedure is applied whereby candidate random assignments are repeatedly drawn and evaluated against pre-specified balance criteria on baseline covariates. Only assignments that satisfy these balance thresholds—defined in terms of standardized differences across treatment arms at the cluster level—are retained. From the set of acceptable assignments, one allocation is selected at random. Assignment is approximately balanced across the four experimental arms.
Randomization unit
Randomization is conducted at the social-promoter cluster level. Each cluster consists of approximately 7–14 households served by a social promoter. All households within a given cluster are assigned to the same treatment arm. There is no individual-level randomization.
Clusters
343 social-promoter–level clusters (operational clusters of approximately 7–14 households each).
Observations
2,623 households (caregivers), distributed across 343 social-promoter–level clusters.
Arms
Control (standard Unbound programming): 659 households in 86 social-promoter clusters PSL without mentoring: 662 households in 86 social-promoter clusters PSL with individual mentoring: 655 households in 85 social-promoter clusters PSL with group mentoring: 647 households in 86 social-promoter clusters Total: 2,623 households across 343 social-promoter–level clusters.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of interest capture changes in aspirations, individual agency, collective agency, and multidimensional poverty conditions. Individual (Critical) Agency Measures of participants’ perceived ability to set goals, make decisions, and take actions to improve their living conditions. This includes perceived control over life outcomes, confidence in achieving goals, and self-efficacy related to economic and social decisions. Collective Agency Measures of participants’ perceived collective efficacy and capacity for joint action, including trust in group processes, coordination with others, and beliefs about the ability of groups to solve shared problems and achieve common goals. Aspirations Aspirations across key life domains, including education, occupation and income generation, housing quality, and savings or financial security. Outcomes capture both the level and clarity of aspirations. Multidimensional Poverty Indicators Disaggregated indicators of deprivation across multiple domains (e.g., housing, education, health, income, and financial security), analyzed at the indicator or domain level rather than as a single composite index.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes capture intermediate behaviors, perceptions, and program engagement that may mediate the effects of the intervention on aspirations, agency, and poverty-related outcomes. Goal-Setting and Planning Behaviors Measures of whether households set specific goals, the number and type of goals identified, and progress toward completing planned steps. Follow-Through and Action Self-reported actions taken toward stated goals, such as investments in education, housing improvements, income-generating activities, or savings-related actions. Engagement with Mentoring and Group Activities Participation in mentoring sessions, attendance at group meetings, and frequency of follow-up interactions with mentors or facilitators. Social Interaction and Peer Support Measures of peer learning, information sharing, mutual support, and perceived benefits from group participation, particularly relevant for the group-mentoring arm. Psychosocial Well-Being Measures of hope, optimism, future orientation, and perceived stress or discouragement, which may respond to changes in aspirations and agency. Household Economic Behaviors Intermediate economic behaviors such as saving practices, budgeting, or participation in income-generating activities, without requiring short-run income changes.
Partners
Name: Innovations for Poverty Action Partner_type: ngo Url: https://poverty-action.org/ Name: Unbound Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.unbound.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords