Information Complexity and Advice in the Brazilian College Admissions System: A Choice Experiment
How to cite
Hakimov, Rustamdjan; Bo, Inacio. 2026. "Information Complexity and Advice in the Brazilian College Admissions System: A Choice Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017665. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17665-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study how information presentation (a simple versus a complex user interface) and advice concerning uncertainty of preliminary cutoffs affect applicants’ program choices in a centralized admissions environment inspired by SISU/ENEM. Participants face a choice of 12 programs: they may apply to up to two programs, and observe the preliminary admission cutoffs over three days. In addition, they observe last year’s cutoff.
Participants are randomized in a 2×2 design. Treatment 1 varies the user interface: a simple interface in which cutoff information is directly visible, versus a complex interface in which cutoff information is hidden and must be accessed by clicking, as in real SISU. Treatment 2 varies the presence of advice. The advice emphasizes intense competition and the uncertainty of final cutoffs, highlighting the risk of relying mechanically on last-day cutoffs.
Participants make a single, one-shot simulated SISU application decision. We measure how UI complexity and advice affect (i) Admission status, (ii) Allocative efficiency, (iii) Actual admission in the SISU system, and iv) Diversification of choices. Allocative efficiency is measured using experimental payoffs derived from admission outcomes.
Intervention
This study features two independent individual-level randomizations implemented in a 2×2 design:
• Treatment 1 (UI complexity):
– Simple UI: Cutoff information is visible directly on each program card.
– Complex UI: Cutoff information is hidden and can be accessed only by clicking on a program.
• Treatment 2 (Advice):
– No Advice: No additional information is provided.
– Advice: Participants receive advice on the screen before final choice emphasizing competition and cutoff uncertainty.
Advice is informational only and does not recommend specific programs or personalized strategies.
Experimental design
Participants from the current SISU centralized college admissions cohort are recruited through social-media advertisements to participate in an online survey experiment administered via Qualtrics. As an incentive for participation, respondents are informed that every 40th participant receives an Amazon voucher with a minimum value of R$200. In addition, participants can earn higher rewards through performance in the incentivized task.
The core task is a simulated admissions decision with up to two program applications and deterministic admissions based on an exam score and program-specific final cutoffs. The simulated market is calibrated using real data from past SISU allocations.
After providing informed consent, participants complete a pre-survey collecting background characteristics (e.g., demographics), self-reported ENEM score, and baseline confidence about their relative position in the ENEM distribution as well as streotzpical belief obout gender composition of the best scorers. Participants are then randomly assigned to one of four conditions: Simple–No Advice, Simple–Advice, Complex–No Advice, or Complex–Advice.
In the main task, participants view a set of 12 anonymized programs and observe the payoff associated with admission to each program. Participants are informed that voucher payoffs, conditional on winning the lottery (1-in-40 probability), increase with the payoff value of the program to which they are admitted. Payoffs of programs range from R$10 to R$100.
In the Simple UI conditions, participants observe a table displaying all programs along with daily cutoffs (Days 1–3) and last year’s cutoff. In the Complex UI conditions, cutoff information is hidden behind clickable panels, and only one program’s information can be viewed at a time; opening a new program hides previously viewed information. This design closely replicates the SISU user interface.
Participants in all treatments submit a single ranked application (up to two programs) within a three-minute time window. No revisions or additional choice rounds are allowed.
In the Advice conditions, participants observe the following advisory message displayed above the submission interface:
“Competition is high and final cutoffs are uncertain. For instance, in 2021, in 42% of programs, the final cutoff ends above the last-day cutoff. When this happens, the median increase is about 5 points, a meaningful jump. In 5% of cases, the increase exceeds 27 points.”
Admissions are determined using the realized final cutoffs from the simulated market.
After completing the task, participants fill out a post-experiment survey.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.