Pragmatism or Emotions: How Narratives Shape Perceptions of and Attitudes toward Immigration

How to cite

Rodina, Arina; Suvorov, Anton; Bouev, Maxim. 2026. "Pragmatism or Emotions: How Narratives Shape Perceptions of and Attitudes toward Immigration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017645. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17645-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Arina Rodina* , Anton Suvorov , Maxim Bouev

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017645
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17645-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-03-19 – 2026-04-02
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17645

Abstract

Historically, immigration has been a topic of heated public and political debate, where public beliefs about immigrants are often shaped by stereotypes and persistent misperceptions. Immigration has also become an economically salient issue, in the view of population aging and a shrinking labor force on the one hand and with the concerns about its contribution to the unemployment on the other. This paper studies how information provision and narratives affect reported beliefs about immigrants, corresponding moral evaluations, and policy preferences. We conduct a multi-wave randomized survey experiment in Russia, that largely builds on Alesina et al. (2023) to ensure international comparability. The experiment contrasts factual and emotional narratives aimed at shifting misperceptions. Our major contribution, besides expanding geographical coverage to a country that has a large, diverse and persistent immigration flows and multi-ethnic population, is to introduce a pragmatic economic narrative in both text and video formats (including a salience-enhanced variant) that frames immigration as an economic input, essential for economic growth in a country with shrinking population. In each wave, respondents report baseline characteristics, are randomly assigned to an intervention, and then answer a common set of post-treatment questions. We also collect standard demographic covariates and apply pre-specified attention checks and exclusion rules.

Our analysis focuses on three questions. First, we examine whether baseline beliefs are distorted in stereotypical directions, especially on salient dimensions such as crime and immigrants’ origins. Second, we test whether different informational treatments reduce immigration-related misperceptions. We further examine whether narrative interventions operate through distinct channels, for example by affecting moral attributions and support for inclusive policies. Third, we examine how heightened threat salience changes the effectiveness of different narratives. Exploiting the close timing of fieldwork around a salient violent event associated with immigrants, we test whether heightened salience makes respondents less responsive to pragmatic economic arguments and more responsive to moral narratives, or whether it instead makes them harder to persuade regardless of the message.

Alberto Alesina, Armando Miano, Stefanie Stantcheva, Immigration and Redistribution, The Review of Economic Studies, Volume 90, Issue 1, January 2023, Pages 1–39, https://doi.org/10.1093/restud/rdac011

Experimental design

We conduct a multi-wave online survey experiment designed to study beliefs, attitudes, and policy support related to immigration in Russia. The survey elicits respondents’ quantitative perceptions of key immigrant characteristics, including the share of immigrants in the population, crime rates among immigrants, countries of origin, and educational attainment. Attitudes toward immigrants and support for immigration-related policies are measured using a standardized set of opinion questions. Perceptions are elicited using quantitative response formats such as numerical entry fields and percentage allocations.

The core of the design is a randomized information experiment. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of several groups: a control group that receives no information, or one of multiple treatment groups that receive a single informational or narrative intervention. The treatments include:
(i) factual information about the overall share of immigrants in Russia and in other countries;
(ii) factual information about the distribution of immigrants in Russia by region of origin;
(iii) an emotional video narrative portraying a hardworking immigrant;
(iv) a concise, text-based pragmatic narrative describing Russia’s demographic constraints and the economic role of immigration;
(v) a video-based pragmatic narrative conveying the same economic content as the text-based narrative; and
(vi) a video-based pragmatic narrative that includes an additional concluding point emphasizing immigrants’ contribution to the country.

Randomization occurs at the individual level, with each respondent exposed to at most one treatment. All outcome variables are measured after the treatment. The survey is fielded in multiple waves, which allows us to examine changes in beliefs and attitudes over time, including responses to a salient negative immigrant-related event, and to assess the persistence of treatment effects in a follow-up wave.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted through the online survey platform. Upon entering the survey, respondents are randomly assigned at the individual level to either the control group or one of the treatment groups with equal probability.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual respondent. All treatments are assigned at the individual level, each respondent is exposed to at most one treatment.
Clusters
0 clusters (individual-level randomization; no clustering)
Observations
2,400-2,800 respondents per wave
Arms
400 respondents per treatment arm per wave, 6 treatment groups + 1 control group
Primary outcomes
Misperceptions about immigrants’ characteristics, attitudes toward immigrants, and support for immigration-related policies.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords