Provision of Religious Information about Female Labor Force Participation to College Students in Pakistan
How to cite
Makino, Momoe; Umer, Hamza. 2026. "Provision of Religious Information about Female Labor Force Participation to College Students in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017642. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17642-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite general belief that Islam prevents women's labor force participation, existing micro-level empirical studies offer mixed conclusions. This study focuses on Pakistan, where the population is predominantly Muslim and the rate of female labor force participation (24.5%) is substantially below the global average. We conduct a laboratory experiment targeting male university students. While persistent social norms against women working outside the home are well-documented among older generations of male decision-makers, this study focuses on the younger demographic whose attitudes are supposed to be more malleable. We provide participants with two different types of information, both of which are checked and confirmed by a religious scholar. One type encourages female employment, while the other potentially acts as a deterrent. By isolating the impact of religious framing on attitudes toward women working, this study aims to provide clear empirical evidence of causality from religious information to attitudes toward women working outside the home. The findings will offer critical insights for researchers and policymakers seeking to enhance women's labor force participation in South Asia and Middle East and North Africa regions, ultimately contributing to household financial stability and broader economic development.
Intervention
Lab Experiments: We will use lab experiments to conduct the proposed research. The controlled environment of the lab would enable us to identify the precise impact of Islam on Female Labor Force Participation (FLFP) attitudes, which can be difficult in a field where numerous other factors can possibly dilute this relationship.
We will use two types of Islamic teachings to establish the causal impact of Islam on FLFP attitudes. These Islamic teachings are already checked and confirmed by an Islamic scholar. One type encourages FLFP and the other potentially discourages it. While most scholars agree that Islam permits FLFP while remaining within the Islamic framework, most of the public does not know because these teachings do not get highlighted in society.
There will be one control and two treatment arms(T1 & T2). The control arm will not be exposed to any religious information. T1 will provide Islamic teachings emphasizing women’s right to work (positive frame). T2 will provide Islamic teachings about the rules and regulations women should follow if they work outside home (can be perceived negative). While T1 and T2 both contain religious information about FLFP, there is an important difference: T1 emphasizes women’s right to participate in labor force, while T2 emphasizes religious rules that must be followed by women participating in labor force. Therefore, T1 is inherently positive towards FLFP, while T2 can be perceived negative towards FLFP due to strict conditions that must be observed by women. These two conditions accurately capture the divided perceptions about FLFP in Pakistan, and therefore, are essential elements of our study. The control arm will not be exposed to any information. The exact experimental Instructions are provided in below. These instructions in Experimental Design will be provided to the participants in either T1 or T2 treatment arms.
Experimental design
The lab experiments will be implemented with students at the National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST) located in Islamabad, Pakistan. Within NUST, we will implement the study with students of NUST Business School (NBS). A full-time faculty member of NBS has already made organizational arrangements for implementing our experiments. As our study intends to examine the impact of religious information on FLFP attitudes of young male members of the society, our participants in the experiments will be male students, both undergraduate and graduate. We will exclude female students as they fall outside the aims and objectives of the current study.
We will obtain schedule of those classes at NBS after which the classroom is exclusively available to us for at least one hour to conduct experiments. At the end of the selected classes, Co-PI (Hamza Umer) will enter the classroom and announce that he would like to conduct an economic experiment, clarify that participation is completely voluntary, and the decision to participate or leave will have no impact on student’s academic grades. Interested male students will stay in the classroom and participate in experiment.
On average, there are 50 students in every class at NBS, and approximately half are male. Our previous experience of implementing experiments at NBS shows that on average, three to five students from every class do not participate in the experiment and leave. Therefore, to obtain the required sample of 300 male participants, we will randomly select thirteen classes from the list of classes after which the classroom is available for at least one hour, and hope to obtain 300 participants. However, if our required sample is not achieved, we will again randomly select classes from the list and repeat this procedure until we obtain our required sample. In case we are unable to obtain the required sample from NBS, we will target male students in other departments of NUST by obtaining necessary permissions from those departments. As a backup, we have discussed the possibility of implementing experiments with faculty members of the NUST School of Social Sciences and Humanities (S3H), and they are happy to accommodate our request.
In the reserved classroom for experiments, Co-PI (Hamza Umer) will proceed by announcing the experiment and instructing that the interested students sit in an exam formation to ensure participants make decisions privately. Afterwards, an informed consent form (Appendix) will be distributed among the students. Once students read and sign it, the experimental instructions sheet containing 1 to 3 below (detailed) will be distributed. Once everyone reads the instructions, the decision sheet (4 - 6) will be distributed. Afterwards, the post-experiment survey (7 - 8) will be distributed. At the end, participants will be paid in private the fixed participation fee and the money based on their decision in DG and a signed payment slip (9) will be obtained. The experimental materials 1 – 2, and 4, 6– 9 are the same for treatment and control groups. The intervention component 3 is different for T1 and T2 arms, and absent for the control arm. The list experiments (LE) component 4 is different between LE treated and LE controlled.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.