Performance-Based Scholarship Demonstration
How to cite
Sommo, Colleen. 2017. "Performance-Based Scholarship Demonstration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001761. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1761-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
MDRC launched the Performance-Based Scholarship Demonstration in 2008 to test an innovative strategy for addressing two policy objectives: increasing the financial support available to low-income students, and creating an incentive for such students to complete their courses and make more timely progress toward degrees. The idea is to provide a supplement to existing federal and state financial aid that is contingent on enrolling in a minimum number of credit hours and making passing grades. The performance-based scholarships are paid directly to students (rather than to the colleges or universities they attend) in order to reward students for their progress and to allow them to make choices of how best to support their schooling. For some, this may mean buying books or paying for transportation to campus; for others, it may mean cutting back on work hours or hiring a babysitter for their children during finals week.
MDRC tested variations of the performance-based scholarship at eight colleges and one intermediary across six states. The program at each college was targeted to low-income students with high unmet need, based on the cost of attendance and gaps in state financial aid.
The Performance-Based Scholarship Demonstration was designed to produce rigorous evidence of the programs' impacts and to answer policy-relevant questions:
-- Do performance-based scholarships increase short- or long-term academic achievement?
-- How does variation in the amount and duration of scholarships affect academic outcomes? For example, how do the impacts of a $1,000 scholarship compare with those of a $2,000 scholarship?
-- For what target population do the scholarships have the greatest impacts?
-- What are the effects of bundling the scholarships with enhanced student services, such as advising and tutoring?
The results show that these scholarships improved students' academic progress during the program--effects that remained evident several years after the program ended. The effects on students' academic progress appear generally consistent across the different programs and student subgroups. In addition, one program targeted high school seniors and succeeded in increasing their matriculation in college, and three of the programs reduced students' dependency on loans. Most important, this evaluation finds that the programs modestly increased degree completion, measured after five years.
These results show that even relatively moderate investments in low-income students' education can have modest but long-lasting impacts on their academic outcomes. These findings may be especially relevant to states, institutions, and private scholarship providers seeking purposeful and efficient ways to give low-income students additional financial aid that can also help them succeed academically.
Experimental design
Multiple colleges participated in this study, and several colleges had multiple campuses; more than 5,600 students received scholarships at two- and four-year institutions in six states. In California, students were recruited from four geographic areas throughout the state but could attend any college. Multiple cohorts of students were also recruited into the study. A cohort refers to a group of students entering at the beginning of a specific semester (for example, Borough of Manhattan Community College had a fall 2008 cohort, spring 2009 cohort, and fall 2009 cohort). In total, there were 45 unique cohort combinations by college/campus and geographic region. Individual students were randomly assigned to the program or control groups, and this random assignment was conducted separately for each unique combination of cohorts and campuses, or cohorts and geographic regions.
Because the scholarship dollars are limited, the demonstration can use a random assignment research design to compare the outcomes of students who receive a performance-based scholarship (on top of their regular financial aid) with a control group who would not receive the performance-based scholarship but would have access to other scholarships that would otherwise be available. MDRC is using variety of quantitative data sources, including transcript data, other administrative data, and surveys, to determine the impacts of the scholarships. Qualitative data from focus groups and interviews are being employed to understand why (or why not) the scholarship intervention had an effect on outcomes.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Mayer, Alexander, Reshma Patel, Timothy Rudd, Alyssa Ratledge. 2015. Designing Scholarships to Improve College Success: Final Report on the Performance-Based Scholarship Demonstration. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/designing-scholarships-improve-college-success
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.