AI-Assisted Decision-Making: An Experimental Study of Bargaining in the Second-Hand Market
How to cite
Deng, Weiguang. 2026. "AI-Assisted Decision-Making: An Experimental Study of Bargaining in the Second-Hand Market." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017607. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17607-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study whether generative AI improves bargaining outcomes in real second-hand market transactions. We conduct a randomized field experiment on Xianyu in which participants, acting as buyers, contact real sellers of listed items. A total of 2,000 buyer–seller contacts are randomly assigned to one of four experimental conditions. Primary outcomes include successful bargaining, final negotiated price and the bargaining discount relative to the posted price. This study integrates AI-assisted decision-making with the classic economics and behavioral science issue of bargaining and negotiation, provides randomized controlled evidence in real-world platform settings, helps clarify the relative importance of information supplementation and strategy substitution, and explains the gain and loss mechanisms of AI-generated content in interactive games from the perspectives of algorithm aversion and human-AI collaboration.
Intervention
A randomized controlled field experiment is conducted on the Xianyu second-hand marketplace. The experiment assigns real buyer–seller contacts to different conditions that vary the role of generative AI in the bargaining process, with the interventions designed to manipulate the degree to which AI supports decision-making and communication (e.g., informational support versus strategy support, and the extent of human involvement). Participants act as buyers, contact real sellers, and negotiate under standardized rules with a fixed maximum number of bargaining rounds and pre-specified stopping rules. The study covers multiple product keyword categories that differ in price transparency to examine how AI-assisted bargaining performs across market environments.
Experimental design
A randomized controlled field experiment is conducted on the Xianyu second-hand marketplace. The unit of randomization is an individual buyer–seller contact (a specific listing contacted by a participant). Contacts are assigned to different conditions that vary the role of generative AI in the bargaining process (e.g., whether AI provides informational support and/or assists with drafting messages, and the degree of human involvement). Bargaining follows a standardized protocol with a fixed maximum number of bargaining rounds and pre-specified stopping rules. The study includes multiple product keyword categories that differ in price transparency to examine whether treatment effects vary across market environments.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.