Higher-Order Risk Preferences and Risk-Management Behavior among Italian Winegrowers
How to cite
Barba, Francesca Romana; Cerroni, Simone; Palma, Marco; Drichoutis, Andreas. 2026. "Higher-Order Risk Preferences and Risk-Management Behavior among Italian Winegrowers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017606. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17606-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study elicits risk and higher-order risk (HOR) preferences of Italian winegrowers. More specifically, we elicit risk aversion, prudence, and temperance, and test their external validity by correlating them to both stated intentions and real-world agricultural risk-management behavior. Previous work suggests a link between HOR and real world behavior (see for example Noussair et al 2014, and Schneider and Sutter 2026). Data are collected through an online survey comprising four components: (i) stated preferences regarding an innovative “green insurance” product that provides economic benefits conditional on the adoption of sustainable practices; (ii) an incentivized experimental elicitation of risk and higher-order risk preferences using 17 lottery choices adapted from Noussair et. al (2014); (iii) subjective beliefs about climate-related production losses affecting grape production; and (iv) a short questionnaire on socio-demographics, farm characteristics, and self-reported risk-management practices; v) at the end of the study, farmers can become eligible for a weather-station free-loan draw by choosing to attend a 90-minute online workshop held after data collection; entry is conditional on full workshop attendance, which serves as the implementation cost. Adopting a smart climate technology such as a weather station can be interpreted as a mild preventive measure against climate-related risks and, therefore, as a risk-management strategy. Survey and experimental data will be integrated, where available, with administrative records on observed risk-management behavior, such as insurance participation and insured area and value.The study is implemented using the oTree open-source framework (https://www.otree.org/).
References:
Noussair, C. N., Trautmann, S. T., & van de Kuilen, G. (2014). Higher order risk attitudes, demographics, and financial decisions. The Review of Economic Studies, 81(1), 325–355.
Sutter, Matthias, and Sebastian O. Schneider. "Risk preferences and field behavior: The relevance of higher-order risk preferences." American Economic Review (2026).
Intervention
The study does not involve any intervention. It aims to test correlation between HORPs and stated intentions and real-world agricultural risk-management behavior. The study elicits three higher-order risk preferences (“treatment conditions”): first-order risk preferences (risk aversion), second-order risk preferences (prudence), and third-order risk preferences (temperance). All participants complete each elicitation (within-subject design); therefore, there is no random assignment to conditions and the study does not include experimental arms.
Experimental design
The study consists of four sections.
In Section 1, farmers state their preferences for an innovative “green insurance” product and selected attributes. Green insurance is described as an insurance product offering economic benefits conditional on the adoption of selected sustainable practices.
In Section 2, risk aversion, prudence, and temperance are elicited via 17 incentivized binary lottery choices following Noussair et al. (2014). The choices are grouped in four consecutive parts: decisions 1-5 elicit risk aversion, 6-10 elicit prudence, 11-15 elicit temperance, and 16-17 test relative risk aversion and relative prudence under expected utility. All participants complete all four parts in a within-subject design; there is no random assignment to treatment conditions and the study does not include experimental arms. Participants are presented with one choice at a time and they always have to choose between two options (no indifference option). The left-right position of lotteries is randomized. Lotteries are presented in compound form and framed as independent coin tosses.
In Section 3, we elicit subjective beliefs about the frequency of extreme climatic events affecting grape production.
In Section 4, participants complete a short questionnaire on socio-demographics, farm characteristics, and self-reported risk-management practices.
In Section 5, participants can become eligible to enter a draw to receive a weather station, provided free of charge under a two-years loan agreement (for use and return). Eligibility is conditional on full attendance of a 90-minute online workshop on how the station works and the relevance of on-farm data monitoring. Adopting this type of smart technology can be viewed as a preventive measure that helps manage climate-related risks and can therefore be considered a risk-management strategy. Participants are informed about this opportunity only at the end of the study, since workshop attendance (and thus draw entry) is used as an outcome variable in the analysis. Two follow up questions are also included: (i) for those who decide not to attend the workshop, their main reason for not attending (e.g., not interested in the station/workshop, time constraints, or already owning a station); (ii) participants’ motivation for taking part in the study, including the option “I wanted enter the draw for the weather station”, to assess potential spillover effects.
Incentives: All participants receive a one-year subscription to a professional agricultural magazine as a non-monetary show-up reward. In addition, 10% of participants are randomly selected to receive a monetary payment ranging from €5 to €170 based on their decisions and luck. The payment is determined by one randomly selected lottery choice from Section 2 and the corresponding simulated coin toss outcome. Payments are made via fuel vouchers.
Additionally, at the end of the study (Section 5), participants can become eligible to enter a draw to receive a weather station on free loan by attending a 90-minute online workshop. 35 among those who attend the full workshop (and thus enter the draw) will be randomly selected to receive the device.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.