Wrong Fit, Missed Gains? Evidence from Skill Training Choices in Liberia

How to cite

Zenker, Juliane; Chakravarty, Shubha; Lundberg, Mattias. 2026. "Wrong Fit, Missed Gains? Evidence from Skill Training Choices in Liberia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017603. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17603-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Juliane Zenker* , Shubha Chakravarty , Mattias Lundberg

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017603
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17603-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2010-01-01 – 2012-08-31
Countries
Liberia ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17603

Abstract

Young job seekers often misperceive returns to job-skills training. We study training choices between a job-skills and a business-skills program for young women in Liberia. We randomly reassign a third of applicants from the oversubscribed job-skills to the business-skills track and compare them with applicants who remain in their chosen track. In the short run, reassigned women achieve employment and earnings gains two to three times larger. In the medium run, mean earnings converge but conceal sharp heterogeneity: some women gain substantially from reassignment, while others lose. Elicited expectations suggest misaligned choices and belief distortions for a subset of applicants.

Experimental design

The study uses a two-stage randomized evaluation design (a randomized controlled trial with a waitlist rollout), embedded in the EPAG training program in urban Liberia.

1) Recruitment and sample
• Young women were recruited in nine target communities around Monrovia (and Kakata), applied in person, completed a registration form (including their preferred track), and took a basic literacy/numeracy screen.
• Eligibility targeted women age 16–27, with basic literacy/numeracy, not recently enrolled in school, and residing in the target communities.
• About 2,106 were eligible; 1,991 were interviewed at baseline and entered the random assignment procedure.

2) Two interventions (tracks)
• Participants could receive either Job Skills (JS) training or Business Skills (BS) training. The intervention package included ~6 months of classroom training + ~6 months of follow-up services.

3) Stage 1 assignment: preference + capacity + random reassignment
• At application, women stated a preferred track (JS or BS).
• Because JS slots were limited, about 30% of JS-preferring applicants were reassigned to BS. This reassignment was done by randomly drawing application forms (manual random draw).
• This creates three “candidate groups”:
• G1: preferred JS and assigned JS
• G2: preferred BS and assigned BS (“BS chosen”)
• G3: preferred JS but reassigned to BS (“BS reassigned”)

4) Stage 2 assignment: randomized rollout (treatment vs waitlist control)
• Within each candidate group (G1–G3), women were randomly assigned to start in Round/Cohort 1 vs Round/Cohort 2:
• Cohort 1 = “treatment” (offered training immediately)
• Cohort 2 = “control” (waitlisted; started ~13 months later, after the first follow-up survey).
• The cohort randomization was done by computer, 2/3 to cohort 1 and 1/3 to cohort 2, stratified by experimental group.
• This yields six experimental groups (T1/C1, T2/C2, T3/C3) corresponding to (G1–G3) × (early vs late start), with sample sizes:
• T1=437, C1=312; T2=540, C2=304; T3=243, C3=155.

5) Measurement and estimation approach
• Surveys were collected at baseline (pre-disclosure of randomization results), first follow-up (after cohort 1 finished, before cohort 2 began), and second follow-up (immediately after cohort 2 finished).
• We report intention-to-treat (ITT) effects based on initial assignment, not actual participation.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer; by random draw
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
1991
Observations
1991
Arms
T1=437, C1=312; T2=540, C2=304; T3=243, C3=155
Primary outcomes
• Any IGA (employment) (indicator) • Wage employment (indicator; primary IGA if multiple) • Self-employment (indicator; primary IGA if multiple) • Any formal business (indicator; registered or requiring substantial capital investment) • Days worked (past week) and hours per typical workday, combined into hours/week • Earnings from all IGAs (past week) (winsorized; analyzed with an IHS-transformation)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords