Understanding Teacher Perceptions of Cooperative and Non-cooperative Students

How to cite

Goulas, Sofoklis. 2026. "Understanding Teacher Perceptions of Cooperative and Non-cooperative Students." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017599. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17599-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sofoklis Goulas*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0017599
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17599-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-01-08 – 2026-02-28
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/17599

Abstract

Teachers will take part in a survey‐based vignette experiment in which they evaluate hypothetical profiles of incoming students. Each participating teacher will be randomly assigned to view one of two types of student profiles:
(i) a cooperative student and
(ii) a non-cooperative student,
where the cooperative vs. non-cooperative signal is described as originating from information provided by the student’s previous school (e.g., comments at the time of transfer). For the assigned profile, teachers will be asked to read a brief description of the student and then rate a series of statements on Likert-type scales.

The survey items will capture:

Perceptions and practices – Teachers will rate statements about how they would approach teaching and classroom management for this student (e.g., expected effort they would invest, monitoring and feedback practices, differentiation, communication with families, and willingness to seek additional support).

Perceived drivers of change in behavior and achievement – Teachers will rate the extent to which various factors would contribute to improving or worsening the student’s behavioral and academic outcomes. These factors may include the teacher’s own instructional and classroom management practices, the student’s motivation and self-regulation, peer relationships, family environment, and school-level supports.

By randomly assigning teachers to evaluate either the cooperative or the non-cooperative student profile and collecting their ratings on perceptions, intended practices, and perceived drivers of change, the experiment will allow us to isolate how initial behavioral signals from a previous school shape teachers’ expectations, planned responses, and attributions regarding future behavioral and academic trajectories.

Intervention

Teachers will take part in a survey‐based vignette experiment in which they evaluate hypothetical profiles of incoming students. Each participating teacher will be randomly assigned to view one of two types of student profiles:
(i) a cooperative student and
(ii) a non-cooperative student,
where the cooperative vs. non-cooperative signal is described as originating from information provided by the student’s previous school (e.g., comments at the time of transfer). For the assigned profile, teachers will be asked to read a brief description of the student and then rate a series of statements on Likert-type scales.

Experimental design

Teachers will take part in a survey‐based vignette experiment in which they evaluate hypothetical profiles of incoming students. Each participating teacher will be randomly assigned to view one of two types of student profiles:
(i) a cooperative student and
(ii) a non-cooperative student,
where the cooperative vs. non-cooperative signal is described as originating from information provided by the student’s previous school (e.g., comments at the time of transfer). For the assigned profile, teachers will be asked to read a brief description of the student and then rate a series of statements on Likert-type scales.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be implemented at the teacher level within the Qualtrics survey platform. When a teacher begins the survey and consents to participate, Qualtrics will use its built-in randomization module to assign that teacher with equal probability (50/50) to one of two experimental conditions: (i) a vignette describing a cooperative student or (ii) a vignette describing a non-cooperative student, based on signals provided by the student’s previous school. Each teacher will be exposed to only one profile, ensuring that responses reflect between-teacher, rather than within-teacher, comparisons and avoiding contamination or carryover effects from seeing both types of profiles. Because randomization occurs automatically within Qualtrics at the start of the survey, assignment is independent of teacher characteristics and prior responses. In the analysis, we will verify the success of randomization by comparing observable teacher characteristics across the two experimental arms (e.g., teaching experience, subject, school level) and will treat any remaining imbalances as random noise, adjusting for covariates as needed to improve precision.
Randomization unit
Teacher level
Clusters
200 teachers
Observations
200 teachers
Arms
100 teachers
Primary outcomes
The survey items will capture: Perceptions and practices – Teachers will rate statements about how they would approach teaching and classroom management for this student (e.g., expected effort they would invest, monitoring and feedback practices, differentiation, communication with families, and willingness to seek additional support). Perceived drivers of change in behavior and achievement – Teachers will rate the extent to which various factors would contribute to improving or worsening the student’s behavioral and academic outcomes. These factors may include the teacher’s own instructional and classroom management practices, the student’s motivation and self-regulation, peer relationships, family environment, and school-level supports.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords