How CEO Gender Shapes Interpretation of Financial Information: Evidence from an Experimental Study
How to cite
Ferrario, Beatrice; Carvalho, Marcela. 2026. "How CEO Gender Shapes Interpretation of Financial Information: Evidence from an Experimental Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0017595. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.17595-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study is a second wave of a previously conducted experiment in which we surveyed three sections of MFA students at LBS. The design and randomization procedures are unchanged; the second wave is slightly streamlined to reduce completion time and includes fictitious companies instead of being based on real data.
In the first wave, we anticipated that a sample of roughly 300 students might provide limited statistical power. The results were directionally consistent with our hypotheses but only weakly significant (typically at the 10% level). We are therefore re-running the same experiment in a very similar population—MBA & MiM students at LBS—to increase the sample size and improve statistical precision.
Below is the abstract for the second wave of the experiment.
Participants complete two rounds of a forecasting task. Each round begins with a short case about a fictional retail firm whose EPS follows an AR(1) process (participants are informed about the process). After reading the case, participants report a prior EPS forecast and two relative-rank judgments—managerial talent of the CEO and the firm’s fundamentals—on a 0–100 scale relative to retail peers of similar size. The case embeds two independent manipulations: (i) CEO gender, randomized via first name and pronouns while all other text is held constant, and (ii) an information display consisting of noisy signals of the true EPS realization labeled as “experts’ forecasts,” accompanied by a single paragraph that contextualizes those signals; the signals are randomized to be optimistic or pessimistic in each round. Participants then provide posterior values for the same three outcomes.
Intervention
Participants complete two rounds of a forecasting task. In each round, they read a short, standardized case about a retail firm and make an initial EPS forecast. The intervention embeds two orthogonal manipulations: (1) CEO gender randomization and (2) information signal randomization (optimistic vs. pessimistic).
CEO gender randomization: In each round, the perceived gender of the CEO is randomized by swapping only the CEO’s first name and corresponding pronouns from a pre-specified list of gender-diagnostic names. All other case content (firm facts, financials, layout, length, tone) is held constant, and no additional gender cues are introduced. Each participant is exposed to one female-named CEO and one male-named CEO across the two rounds.
Information signal randomization (optimistic vs. pessimistic): After the initial forecast, participants see three noisy signals of the true EPS realization labeled as “experts’ forecasts.” In each round, this set is randomized to be either optimistic (all signals above the true EPS realization known to the researchers) or pessimistic (all below), with equal probability. The three experts’ forecasts are paired with a brief text that contextualizes the signals; these texts are generated by a large language model trained on analysts’ reports to emulate sell-side language and framing.
The two manipulations—CEO gender and the sign of the experts’ signals—are randomized independently in each of the two rounds at the participant × round level.
Experimental design
Participants complete two rounds of a forecasting task. Each round begins with a short case about a fictional retail firm. After reading the case, participants report a prior EPS forecast (incentivized) and two relative-rank judgments—managerial talent of the CEO and the firm’s fundamentals—on a 0–100 scale relative to retail peers of similar size (not incentivized). Each participant is shown one male-named CEO and one female-named CEO across the two rounds. The case embeds two independent manipulations: (i) CEO gender, randomized via first name and pronouns while all other text is held constant, and (ii) an information display consisting of noisy signals of the true EPS realization labeled as “experts’ forecasts,” accompanied by a single paragraph that contextualizes those signals; the signals are randomized to be optimistic or pessimistic in each round. Participants then provide posterior values for the same three outcomes. Randomizations occur independently in every round.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.